23. Continuity Offer. Discount + One Time Fee. | $100M Lost Chapters Audiobook
14 Nov 2025 · 6 min
A trainer's gym offer sparks a breakdown of the continuity model: deep discount on first month plus a separate enrollment fee. The setup fee recovers acquisition costs and makes customers less likely to quit. Real examples include 95% off plus $1,900 fee, and a weight-loss coaching business charging $5,000 upfront.
Chapters
Continuity Offer: Discount One-Time Fee. Spring 2015. I was walking out the front door of my La Habra location. The sun baked the black asphalt of the empty parking lot. It was midday before the afternoon rush would begin in a few hours. Before I could take a step towards my car, a man quickly approached me, almost out of nowhere. "Hey, you the owner?" I was a bit startled. I said, "Uh, yeah." Before I could ask what he wanted, he plowed right into his pitch. My name's Owen. I'm a personal training manager of a gym that just went under across town. I've got a group of trainers that just want to sell personal training packages. We do about $100,000 a month in personal training sales. We just need a facility to work out of. We don't really offer personal training here, I said, half lying because I didn't like the guy's vibe. He just didn't seem trustworthy. I started to turn my side towards him to show I wasn't interested and began to make my way towards my car. He realized he needed to change his approach. I promise we're a self-sufficient team. I can see through the window, you guys have a lot of dead space, even when your sessions are going on. We can just help you monetize that area. It'll cost you nothing. It's just upside. It'll cost me time and attention, I countered. And most importantly, it'll cost me the goodwill I've accrued with my customer base. No, no, no, no. We won't even talk to your customers if you don't want us to. We'll just go get our own leads and sell them. We just ask that you give them a discounted month upfront and we'll charge an enrollment fee, which I just give to my guys as commission for the sale. So whatever they can close for the fee is theirs. That's how we do it. It'll cost you nothing. "Hmm, I'll think it over." After thinking it over, I decided I didn't want a foreign group of trainers and salespeople that I hadn't vetted walking around my gym representing my company. But I did notice the offer structure he presented: a discount plus a fee. He'd clearly seen success with that, that much I believed, and this was the first I'd heard of this monetization structure. It both attracted customers with a discount and liquidated commissions and acquisition costs through a fee. Here's how it works. Description: You charge a discounted rate for your first term or period of service. Then you charge one or more additional fees that you just made up. Just like the free with fee structure. If you can waive some and charge others, waive them all or charge them all. It gives you a lot of offer flexibility depending on the strength of the salesperson. This offer will tend to surprise fewer people since they already came in expecting to pay something, which is one of the key benefits of using discounts over free for this particular structure. Examples: any recurring service, offer 95% off the first month, $1,900 off the first month, first month for $100. Monetization: they come in for the first month for $100, but they still get charged a $1,900 setup fee. All in all, they get charged $2,000 and go straight into recurring. From a monetization perspective, they just got charged $2,000 for their first month and each month thereafter. To be clear, you still have to explain this and sell this, but I'm saying that's how the offer works. Any defined end service or program. Offer: 88% off first month. Selling a 12-week program for $3,000. Monetization: you'll say it costs $1,000 a month for 3 months, but you get 88% off your first month, which would be $120 in total. But then we have a $1,000 setup fee. They end up paying $1,120 for the first month and then continuing their next few payments at $1,000 each. Same idea. You just separate the recurring from the upfront, and then it allows you to be more flexible with your advertising. Details. To be clear, always obey the advertising rules within your area and of your time period. Details. The higher the one-time startup fee, the lower the churn. The higher the barrier to entry, so too becomes the higher the barrier to exit. John told me that when his tanning empire had a $100 signup fee for the $10 monthly membership, the churn on those clients was next to nothing, whereas the clients who paid $19 down and then $19 a month churned at a higher rate. This means you can use made-up fees we've been talking about to actively decrease your churn and increase the investment of your prospects. This helps them and you in the long run. Everyone wins. When people pay, they pay attention. This is especially important for services where you require something to be done by the customer. Getting you information, filling out forms, showing up certain times, making selections, changing behavior, etc. If you need someone to do something in order to be successful, then more times than not, it makes sense to charge a one-time setup fee or startup fee to get them invested in the long run. You can even have a massive disparity between setup and recurring. A good friend of mine who runs a multimillion-dollar online weight loss coaching business charges $5,000 to start and then only $267 a month thereafter. His average client lifespan is more than 2 years. Compare that with the normal average fitness client who stays 4 months. This large upfront sum gets the client invested in the process and makes leaving almost insane. And you guessed it, if they leave and want to come back, then they have to pay it again. So this just keeps people committed, especially when they have to do part of the work to achieve the result that you sold them, whatever that may be. Note: be clear about what the reason for the one-time fee is, even though it might be made up. This should not be a fee taken lightly. It's also something that you should bring up with any and every customer. You're doing the work, so you might as well let them know exactly what you're going to be doing for them. So here are 4 steps to creating your one-time fee. Number 1, pick your fee name. Number 2, pick your fee price. Number 3, pick your reason why. Number 4, start charging it, discounting it, or waiving it. Summary points. This play is incredibly flexible. You can use it on top of any business. The big discount can attract lots of interest. These fees will help you offset the acquisition costs of marketing and sales. It works very well with recurring or defined-end programs. And in general, the larger the one-time fee upfront, the higher the stick rate. Not only does this help you make money on the front end, it can dramatically enhance the lifetime value of the customer. These fees are also really good to think through. Even if you don't plan on using this monetization structure, as they can provide additional revenue streams for your business. There are lots of things that you're doing as a business owner. You might as well get credit for it. Waiving made-up fees can also help you generate more goodwill than just signing someone up directly. You can also leave these fees to the discretion of the salesperson to help them, quote, sweeten the deal for someone on the edge. Unlimited uses here.