Cracked Heat Exchanger
28 Jan 2026 · 3 min
Derek Cole and William Skipper discuss CO detector maintenance and cracked heat exchangers. Replace detectors every seven to ten years, check batteries annually, and place them low near bedrooms. A cracked heat exchanger is a safety hazard: technicians disable the unit, shut off gas, and label it until it's fixed.
Questions this episode answers
Every seven years.
Ten year warranty.
At or near floor level (plugged into a receptacle at floor level), ideally in a hallway by the bedrooms.
Using a heat-exchanger camera (with light and magnified view) to take pictures/screens for the homeowner.
Disable the furnace, kill the gas to it, and place a sticker/label indicating the cracked heat exchanger.
Chapters
Hey, on this episode, we talk about superheat. We have a special guest, William Skipper, to answer that question. We talk about how do you know if there's a crack in your heat exchanger? And do CO detectors really have a lifespan? You ask your comfort and energy questions and they get answered. This is the Ask Derrick Cole Show. Hey, this is Derrick Cole. Welcome to episode 51 of the Ask Derrick Cole Show. And it's been quite a few good days in a row. No rain, sun shining. And by the way, the special guest today is the comfort expert, other half, William Skipper. So let's get into the program. All right.
How often should a CO2, how often should a CO2 detector be replaced and do they go bad?
So, yeah, they do go bad and they need to be replaced. Seven years is what most manufacturers recommend. Every seven years it needs to be replaced. Some are coming out these days with a 10 year warranty. So depending on when it was purchased, is it going to, you know, anything this year would probably be a 10 year warranty. Anything before this year would be every seven years. You do want to check your battery backup in that and make sure it's working. I would change those out before the season starts every year just to make sure you're good to go kind of the same rotation you do like smoke detectors or things like that. So check that, make sure. But yes, it does go bad. It's very important to have one, and not only to have one, but to have it in the right place. Because we go to a lot of homes where that CO detector is part of the fire alarm or the smoke alarm and it's up on the ceiling and that's not where you want it to be. CO is very heavy and it will fall, so you want it as close to the floor as possible. So if you plug it into your receptacle at the floor level, that's where it's recommended. It's also recommended to be in a hallway where the bedrooms are. That way at nighttime, if you're asleep, you do hear it going off and you can't wake up. Because CO is one of those things you do not want to play with whatsoever. It's deadly odorless. You don't smell it, you don't know it's coming. So you need that detector. Anytime you have any combustion item in the home. Gas, water, heater, dryer, heating air, anything like that, you need to have a CO detector.
I've had furnace companies inspect my furnace in the past and tell me that there is a crack in the heat exchanger and the furnace needs to be replaced. I could not see the cracks, but assume that you need magnification to see them. Is there a way, as a homeowner, that you can tell whether it's true or whether they're just trying to scam you?
A couple things should be done in that situation. If it's a very small hairline crack, you're probably not going to see it unless you have a heat exchanger camera and go in there with a light and find it. There are books as well, heat exchangers, depending on the manufacturer. You know, a carrier heat exchanger fails differently than a Goodman heat exchanger does. It has different spots in which is prone to fail. So that's obviously the spot they're looking at. A picture can be taken with these devices. Even the cameras we have. You can actually bring a screen to the homeowner and say, you know, I'm gonna go keep watching screens. You know, you want to see it? I'm gonna go to the furnace and I'll show it to you. So that can be done. That should be done. That way you're confident in what they find as well as if they do find a crack in the exchanger, it is going back to co. It is a danger. It should be disabled. We disable all of ours because it is a safety hazard, because the possibility of CO coming into your house is not worth the risk of not turning off. So we turn it off, kill the gas to it, put a sticker on it. That way, if a company comes behind us, they know that we found a cracked heat exchanger. Now, I've had these phone calls before where companies do come behind us. I'll give you a good example. I have one last year coming behind us, couldn't find the crack, couldn't find the holes. And the technician told me, they take the top off the unit. And I said, did you take the top off of the unit? The guy said, no. I said, well, if you take the top.
More from Derek


713. Fan "On" or "Auto"? The Thermostat Setting That Could Be Making Your Home More Humid


712. Why Is My Upstairs Always Hotter Than Downstairs? The Truth Every Homeowner Should Know