Dark Triad, Romantic Partner Selection, and Dating Advice w/ Rob Henderson

27 Mar 2025 · 63 min
1:03:16

In this hour‑long Upstream podcast episode, host Erik Torenberg interviews author and evolutionary‑psychology writer Rob Henderson. The conversation opens with Henderson’s personal path into evolutionary psychology and his interest in why women are drawn to “dark‑triad” (narcissistic, psychopathic, Machiavellian) and violent men, using the high‑profile case of UnitedHealthcare CEO shooter Luigi Mangione as a concrete illustration. Henderson draws on primate research (infanticide in chimpanzees and gorillas) and works by Richard Wrangham, Frans de Waal, Diane Fossey and Sarah Hrdy to propose an evolutionary mis‑firing that makes violent traits attractive in short‑term mating contexts. The discussion then shifts to the rise and decline of the pickup‑artist (PUA) community, its transformation into “red‑pill”, “black‑pill” and incel subcultures, and how cultural shifts (e.g., MeToo, changing norms) have altered women’s expectations of men. Henderson critiques the one‑size‑fits‑all advice that urges men to adopt dark‑triad traits, arguing that advice must be tailored to individual baseline personality. A large portion of the interview is devoted to practical dating advice for men: basic grooming and hygiene, fitness, clothing fit, improving education and career prospects, securing stable living conditions, and, crucially, building a real‑world social circle to practice interpersonal skills. Henderson links these “status signals” to evolutionary findings that women preferentially choose partners who are similar in education, intelligence, political and religious values (assortative mating), and who signal high status (wealth, age, height). He notes gender‑specific trends such as women’s preference for slightly older men and the higher divorce/infidelity risk when the age gap is reversed. The conversation also touches on vulnerability, the role of authenticity versus performative weakness, and the broader cultural vacuum surrounding romantic‑relationship guidance compared to career mentorship. Henderson observes a growing public‑interest in the “sex recession” and hopes that more open discussion will fill the guidance gap. The episode ends with a brief anecdote about a small‑scale Hinge‑style experiment that revealed a wider range of mutual attraction than the typical power‑law model predicts.

Chapters

More from Erik

49:52
youtube.com

How to Spot Exceptional Talent Before Everyone Else

3w ago
26:15
youtube.com

"Meme Your Dream into Reality" | Replit CEO with a16z

3mo ago
46:31
youtube.com

The New Media Playbook with Marc Andreessen & Ben Horowitz

7mo ago
1:02:55
youtube.com

The Bronze Age Collapse and History's Selective Memory

1y ago
45:43
youtube.com

Why Industrial Revolutions Stall

1y ago
29:35
youtube.com

America’s Tech Strategy w/ Qasar Younis, Sen. Jack Reed, and Josh Wolfe

1y ago
31:09
youtube.com

Palantir CEO Alex Karp & Rep. Ritchie Torres on Innovation & The West | Hill and Valley Forum 2024

1y ago
1:20:45
youtube.com

Helen Toner OpenAI Reflections, Adaptation Buffers, and AI in Warfare

1y ago
1:02:46
youtube.com

Trump V2: Tariffs, American Dynamism, Higher Ed | Byrne Hobart

1y ago
0:49
youtube.com

💸 The INVENTION That Rewrote Finance Rules

1y ago
58:25
youtube.com

The Problem With Reserve Currencies and Switching to Crypto w/ Lyn Alden

1y ago
See all content