OpenAI DALL-E 2 - AI or Artist? Which is Better? 🧑🎨

Dr. Zsolnai tests DALL-E 2 against real artists like Felicia Zsolnai and Andrew Price, running variants and comparing outputs across prompts. The conclusion: frame it as collaboration between human creativity and AI, not competition.
Questions this video answers
100 instances for $1.10 per hour versus $4.10 per hour with AWS (quoted as 73% savings).
Chapters
Dear fellow scholars, this is Two Minute Papers with Dr. Zsolnai. Today we are going to see how OpenAI's DALL E2AI's images stack up to real works from real artists. This is going to be an amazing journey. So hold on tight to your papers. Dall E2 is an AI that took the world by storm in the last few months. What does it do? Well, we can write it a text description and hand it to the AI that creates an amazing image of exactly that. And now I am lucky to say that yes, I have ascended. Thanks to the generosity of OpenAI, I now have access to Dall E2. And my first thought was that if it can come up with high quality and and truly novel images, let's put those to the real test. In other words, see how they stand up against the works of real artists. Our first subject will be my favorite artist in the world. And that would be my wife, Felicia zsolnai. She drew this chimpanzee. Oh my, that is beautiful. So let's try this against Dolly too. Okay, but how? Well, the first way of trying it will be through variant generation. What is that? Well, since this AI is trained to understand the connection between text and images, the understanding goes both ways. This means that we can not only input text and get an image, but input an image too. Does it understand what is depicted in this image? Let's see. Oh yes. Wow. It not only understands what is going on, but it can demonstrate that by creating really good variants of it. But not nearly as good as Felicia. I have to say, let's give it another chance here. I used a text prompt to get a hand drawn chimpanzee looking to the right. And I asked for lots and lots of detail. I have pleaded and pleaded for extra wrinkles to squeeze everything out of the AI, even cherry pick the results. And these were the best I could get. You know, art is highly subjective. That's what makes it what it is. But for now, I have to say team Humanity, team AI1 0. And at this point I thought, this is going to be easy, Easy, easy, easy. And boy, you'll find out in a moment how wrong I was. Here is a work from one of my other favorite artists, Judit Shomojwari. Wow. That is one of her original characters. Very imaginative. I love it. So let's ask for a variant of that. Does the AI understand what is going on here? You know, there is a lot to take in here. Elf ears, makeup and Wow. I cannot believe that I am lucky that the variants are working out so well. Because writing a prompt for this would be quite a challenge. I am truly out of words. These are so good. But not as good as Judith. If, in my opinion, Team Humanity. Team AI 2. 0. That's a good score. But it is getting harder. Now let's look at one of Judith's other works. An ostrich that is also a Formula one racer. I am loving this, especially the helmet and the goggles. I think I can whip up a good prompt for this. So what did the AI come up with? Holy mother of papers. Is this some kind of joke? It cannot be that good. I checked the images over and over again. It is that good. Wow. Now, of course, scoring this is subjective, but clearly both are excellent. I'll give this one a tie. Team Humanity vs Team AI 3. 1. I told you it is getting harder. Make sure to check out both Judith and Felicia's works. The links are available in the video description. And now for the next test, please give a warm welcome to the king of all donuts. Of course, that is the Great Andrew Price, 3D modeler and teacher extraordinaire. Now here are some of the donuts I came up with using Dall E2. And some from the prompts that I ran for my daughter. Loving the googly eyes there, by the way. So these are some great donuts. Now, Andrew, it's your turn. Let's see. Wow. OpenAI's was a good one. But this, this is a Michelin star donut right there. The AI made ones are no match for Andrew's skills. So Team Humanity vs Team AI 4. 1. Now, note that Dall E2 often isn't as good as a real world class artist. But the AI can create 10,000 of these images a day. That must be worth at least a point. So, 4. 2. Whew. We made it. Now, all this testing is great fun and of course highly subjective, so don't take it too seriously. And here comes the even more important lesson. In my opinion, this tool should not be framed as at all as Team Humanity vs Team AI I believe this should be framed as Team Humanity supercharged by Team AI here's why. Through six inspiring examples. Look. First, this is my second favorite prompt. A grumpy cat in a spaceship. That is incredible. Now, almost as soon as I posted it on Twitter, it inspired Fabian to create an animated version of it. And now our adorable little grump is ready for takeoff. Through the ingenuity of Team Human and Team AI together. So cool. What a time to be alive. So I hear you asking if this was my second favorite. What is the first? Well 2. Have a look at this Fox Scientist. I cannot believe how well this came out. It has tons of personality and it also inspired others to repaint it. Here it is. You see, I don't see this as a competition. I see this as collaboration. 3. It also inspired the great beardy man who wanted to see a platypus studying the schematics for a cold fusion reactor. These are absolutely amazing. Not just the quality but the variety of the results. My goodness. Note that he asked for a one eyed platypus, but this iteration of Dolly is not that good with numbers yet. If it could talk it would probably apologize for it. 4. I also ran a prompt for David Brown from Boyinaband which got real interesting real quick. He was looking for a visual pun. What is that? Is this a pan? Is this the pun that we got a pan instead? I am not sure but this is very cool nonetheless. And I also Wonder what the AI is trying to say here. 5. James from Linus Tech Tips also ran a superb prompt. A time traveler insensitive to humanity's trivialities. What a great idea. Oh my. Loving the framing and the thoughtfulness of these results. And finally 6. It inspired me too. I also made this. All hail the mighty Cyber frog. Loving it. And we also have a tiny chihuahua in our home and in the two minute papers labs she is Rosie the paper dog if you will. This is how we see her. And now we can also show how she sees herself when meeting other dogs. Oh yes, I think that is very accurate. And of course, as always, plus one, you didn't think we would leave without looking at some of you fellow scholars holding onto your papers, did you? Well, here you go. And. And as you see, these are some proper papers. You fellow scholars are loving it. But now let's have an even more explosive paper like Dall E2. Oh yes, now we're talking. This scholar is you. Who knows that this paper is history in the making. So much so that I cannot stop thinking about and playing with this thing. It really keeps me up at night. This is an incredible achievement that is going to transform the world around us and fast. So artists, AI people, what do you think? Which results did you like better? Let me know in the comments below. And also I will be on Twitter taking some requests from my followers. So make sure to follow me there and send some prompts. The best ones may appear in a future episode. Here the link is in the description. If you're looking for inexpensive cloud GPUs for AI. Lambda now offers the best prices in the world for GPU Cloud Compute no commitments or negotiation required. Just sign up and launch an instance. And hold on to your papers. Because with Lambda GPU Cloud, you can get on demand a 100 instances for $1.10 per hour versus $4.10 per hour with AWS. That's 73% savings. Did I mention they also offer persistent storage? So join researchers at organizations like Apple, MIT, and Caltech in using Lambda Cloud instances, workstations or servers. Make sure to go to lambdalabs.compapers to sign up for one of their amazing GPU instances today. Thanks for watching and for your generous support, and I'll see you next time.










