Episode

9 Dec 2020 · 36 min

0:00

In this episode of the Class Disrupted podcast, host Diane Tavenner and guest Michael Horn examine the complex role of teachers’ unions in decisions about school closures and reopenings during the COVID‑19 pandemic. They begin by noting the heightened public focus on education and introduce unions as a powerful, yet under‑discussed, stakeholder. The conversation moves through several interlocking themes: (1) unions have often advocated for more conservative reopening policies, citing safety concerns such as inadequate ventilation; (2) there is a stark racial and economic mismatch between the predominantly white‑female union membership and the increasingly diverse, low‑income student populations they serve; (3) teachers are simultaneously expected to provide childcare while maintaining a professional identity centered on instruction, creating tension when unions push for full pay and benefits without addressing childcare needs; (4) the pandemic has foregrounded debates about who counts as an “essential worker,” exposing inconsistencies in how society values teachers relative to other frontline occupations; (5) schools differ fundamentally from other businesses (e.g., medical offices, retail) in scale, duration of contact, and logistical constraints, making direct comparisons of safety protocols misleading; (6) the crisis revealed systemic flaws such as insufficient technological infrastructure and a lack of coordinated communication tools, leaving teachers to shoulder the entire burden of remote instruction; (7) union contracts often enforce high teacher autonomy, strict work‑hour limits, and require additional pay for professional development, which hampers rapid innovation and flexible scheduling; (8) the prevailing narrative of “learning loss” is critiqued as a symptom of a teaching profession that, in the hosts’ view, is not consistently grounded in evidence‑based practice, especially in areas like reading instruction; (9) despite these challenges, the hosts identify hopeful possibilities: small‑group “POD” models, micro‑schools, flexible learning times, and collaborative professional development that could re‑imagine schooling; (10) they conclude with personal reflections, noting the emotional weight of the pandemic, the importance of holiday connections, and Michael’s upcoming children’s book aimed at promoting health and movement for youth. Throughout, the dialogue balances critique with optimism, urging a deeper structural conversation beyond blame on unions.

Chapters

More from Michael

PodcastHow AI Could Transform, or Replace, the LMS
Podcast

How AI Could Transform, or Replace, the LMS

7mo ago
PodcastHigher Ed 101: Tenure Explained
Podcast

Higher Ed 101: Tenure Explained

7mo ago
PodcastThe AI Behind Flourish Microschools
Podcast

The AI Behind Flourish Microschools

7mo ago
PodcastWill a Flood of Credentials Threaten the Four-Year Degree?
Podcast

Will a Flood of Credentials Threaten the Four-Year Degree?

8mo ago
PodcastWill a Flood of Credentials Threaten the Four-Year Degree?
Podcast

Will a Flood of Credentials Threaten the Four-Year Degree?

8mo ago
PodcastThe AI Behind Alpha School
Podcast

The AI Behind Alpha School

8mo ago
PodcastThe AI Behind Alpha School
Podcast

The AI Behind Alpha School

8mo ago
PodcastThe Impact of AI Optimization on the Use of Time, Space, and Resources in Schools
Podcast

The Impact of AI Optimization on the Use of Time, Space, and Resources in Schools

8mo ago
PodcastThe Impact of AI Optimization on the Use of Time, Space, and Resources in Schools
Podcast

The Impact of AI Optimization on the Use of Time, Space, and Resources in Schools

8mo ago
PodcastInside the Role of College Trustees During Turbulent Times
Podcast

Inside the Role of College Trustees During Turbulent Times

8mo ago
PodcastInside the Role of College Trustees During Turbulent Times
Podcast

Inside the Role of College Trustees During Turbulent Times

8mo ago
See all content