McCall McPherson says less than 5% of thyroid patients can stop medication, those with pure conversion disorder who produce enough T4 but can't convert it to active T3. Even lifestyle changes rarely eliminate the need for treatment entirely. Any reduction should be gradual, dropping small amounts each quarter while monitoring labs and symptoms.
Chapters
When can you go off of thyroid medication? So this is like a two-sided coin because I see a ton of like health coaches, chiropractors online saying that you don't need thyroid medication. And that can be true, but it is the exception, not the rule. So let's talk about the exception, which for me accounts for less than 5% of people at Modern Thyroid Clinic. So when a patient or you have a pure conversion disorder, what does that mean? It means you produce plenty of thyroid hormones, but you can't activate them. You can't take T4 or inactive hormone and convert it to free T3, your active hormone, the hormone that fuels your body. That is when people can come off of thyroid medication because that activation requires micronutrients, low inflammation, a healthy lifestyle, a healthy diet, enough sleep, stress reduction, all of the things that we can influence in our everyday life can sometimes help us convert better. A lot of times not enough to come off of thyroid medication and thrive, but in rare cases, if you improve your lifestyle in a lot of those ways, you can successfully come off. I would always advocate for reducing a little bit every quarter, every time you get labs, see how your body's responding, see how you're feeling before you make the jump and just completely withdraw it, because that is really setting you up for, for failure, to be honest.
