MBA2435 Q&A Wednesday: How do I increase my email offer sales conversions?
2 Feb 2026 · 15 min
Omar Zenhom answers Janet's question about flagging email offer conversions. He recommends warming your list with a short pre-offer email, then running a 5-7 email launch sequence with direct checkout links and real deadlines. These changes tripled his conversions.
Chapters
Let me tell you about Intuit QuickBooks. When I was starting out my business, I remember sitting at my desk late at night not working on my business but cleaning up numbers, tracking and reconciling payments and wondering how this became my life. But once I automated the admin side of things of my finances, those nights had disappeared and I felt a whole lot better. Outdo it with intuit QuickBooks QuickBooks is the trusted end to end solution that businesses rely on for getting paid, managing finances, paying employees, finding new customers, and more. QuickBooks provides a team of AI agents and trusted experts, so doing it yourself no longer means doing it alone. Their payment agent gets you paid faster, their customer agent finds leads, follows up and secures more sales, and the accounting agent automates and categorizes transactions. Get your critical business jobs done with QuickBooks on the Intuit platform.
Ready to save on New Tech? It's time for Dell Tech Day's annual sales event celebrating our customers with fantastic deals and benefits. Product perks include Dell Rewards, free shipping, premium support, and more. PCs like the Dell 14 with Intel Core Ultra processors will help you do more faster, and with a premium suite of monitors and accessories, you can upgrade your whole setup with amazing savings. Visit Dell.com deals.
Hey oh welcome to the $1 giving you the insights you need to build the business you want with our practical business lessons. I'm your host, your coach, your teacher, Omar Zenholm, and today is Q and A Wednesday. On Q and A Wednesdays, we answer a question from one of you, one of our listeners. If you've got a question you want to ask, go ahead and email me over at Omar MBA Net. Today's question is from Janet, and Janet asks. Sending out email offers is how I make most of my sales with my online business. But in the past year, my sales conversions via email have dropped. Can you help me out? How do I increase my sales conversions via email offers? Solid, practical question, Janet, Love it. I got your back. I'm also a huge fan of email offers. Email is one of the best ways of marketing. Getting in somebody's inbox is a great way to get their attention. Email is something that people have to deal with. They have to read it, they have to archive it, they got to do something with it. They can't just thumb through it like a social media feed. In a lot of ways, our inboxes are our last sacred place on the Internet. So having access to people's inboxes is a fantastic way to make offers and add value to your customers in a personal way. In today's lesson, I'm going to break down how to analyze your email marketing funnel and see where the bottlenecks are, see where you can do better and how you can make some small tweaks to make some massive conversions. Gonna show you where are the areas that actually move the needle and how by improving these areas, in my experience, can massively improve your conversions. In my case, it improved my conversions 3x. I was making 3 times as many sales after I made these changes. So let's get into it. Let's get down to business. Now we're on the same page. Email is a fantastic tool to sell, but we have to recognize that everybody's different when it comes to email. What I mean by that is that the way people treat email, the way that people read emails, the way people consume email emails, is different. There are people that read every word, every letter of the email from top to bottom, subject line. P.S. everything. There are people that just skim through. There are people that read the first two sentences. There are people that read the subject line and then star your email and hope to read it later. There are people that click through your links and go through your pages. And there are people that don't click on anything at all. So you have to recognize this. And the reason why we have to recognize this is we have to change the way we deliver our content via email. Understanding that people are different and you want to treat people differently based on the way they consume email. This just mindset, this concept really was a game changer for me. And once I started thinking like this, I started to see massive changes. We're going to go through some small changes, some small tweaks to your strategy that are going to make a lot of difference. So the first strategy is you have to recognize that not everybody is interested in what you're offering. There's gonna be a good number of people on your email list that is interested and are potential buyers. There are more likely to buy than other people on your list. So you need to identify these people because you wanna go deep and you wanna be able to treat them differently. You wanna be able to deliver different kinds of emails. So the first type of email I like to send before I send any offers. So say for example, I'm making an offer, I'm doing a sale, I'm doing whatever, a promotion. A few days before, even a week before, I'm going to send a different kind of email to my list. This can be my entire list. And this email is not an offer, but it's free, valuable content about what I'm selling. Let's say, for example, you're a basketball coach and you are selling a course on how to improve all aspects of, of your offensive game. Shooting, dribbling, passing, free throw shooting, you name it. Okay? That's what the entire course is about. If somebody were interested in buying a course like that, what kind of content would they be interested in? Well, maybe it's something that has to do with a pain point or a problem that they're trying to solve around that area. So in this case, it might be free throw shooting. And you want to choose something that everybody can relate to. And free throw shooting in basketball is something that everybody relate to because at some point you're get fouled and you're going to have to shoot free throws and you're going to have to, you know, sync those shots to help your team win. So I would send a very short email, I'm talking about two, three lines max, with a link to a video on my website teaching a quick tutorial on how to really improve the free throw shooting very quickly, whether it's a visualization exercise or whatever. The point here is that I'm going to send an email saying, hey, I got this great training that you want to check out to improve your free throw shooting by x percent. It's only six minutes long. Click here and start syncing free throws. Now. The reason why we want this email to be super short is because I'm not interested in them trying to read a long, long email. My whole goal here is that I need people that actually open the email to click the link. Why? Because I'm going to track, I'm going to tag people, whoever click the link. And you could do this with any email software tag based on if they click something in an email and this lets me know they are interested in improving their offense in basketball. Okay? This is somebody who's interested and would be interested in buying my product. What I find when I do this exercise and I give a good week so people can have a chance to open this email and click the link and watch the video is that I get about 50 to 60 people on my email list that have opened the email to click the link. This gives me a great audience that I created in my email list. Now these are the people I'm going to be promoting to. What do I do about the other people that never opened the email and never clicked the link? You might be saying, well, they're never going to get an offer. Well, not if they don't click the link, I only want the warmest audience. But I have an automation set up in my email marketing software. We use ConvertKit. We love it. They're not a sponsor of the show or anything, but you can create an automation inside your email marketing software to send this email to anybody who did not open it. So you can send a second or third version of this email, say, hey, did you see this video? Hey, I got something for you. And usually I just do two follow up emails. And again, in those emails I have the same tag. If they click on the link, they get tagged with that tag. So that way I know they watched the video or actually they went to the page of the video so that they're interested in improving some aspect of their offense, or in general terms, they're interested in what I'll have to offer in a few days. This alone is going to help you tremendously. One, it warms up the audience, it gets them interested, sort of thinking about, you know, your product, your thing, your world, basketball in this case, it starts getting them thinking about how they need to improve. They start thinking about investing in themselves and implementing some of these strategies. It also allows you to kind of get permission in a way to continue to talk about this because they have already proven that they're interested in this. Next we're gonna talk about the emails we're gonna send to those people that clicked with the offer. Some people like to send one or two emails. Some people like to send 10 emails. Some people like to send seven emails. For me, my sweet spot is for any offer to send five to seven emails. Two of those emails are, you know, last chance emails on the last day. Now I might send more emails if I'm like opening and closing a program like we do with the $100 MBA and it's only open at a certain period of time. And I will not be selling this program for an extended period of time. You know, a bunch of months, five, six months. So it's actually really urgent for them and very important for them to sign up now because they won't have a chance later. But generally, let's say five to seven emails, you could choose what to put in these emails. But if you want to increase your conversions, you have to remember that people don't buy on the email, they buy on your website. And this is something that once I figured out and perfected, really skyrocketed my conversions. So you have to remember that there are a lot of different ways people could buy. They can go to Your website, they can go to the product page itself. They can go to the checkout page where, you know, that's it, they're in the cart. So where do you send them in this email? I'm bullish on getting them in the checkout in the cart right away, meaning I'm not really interested in getting them to hit the sales page. Because the sales page could be quite long and detailed and there's videos and there's some kinds of stuff. And yes, it could help. And you may want to send them there early on in your email sequence. But really, most of the time what I find works the best is sending them straight to the cart where after they've clicked the buy button, that next page where it's like checkout, they put their information and they check out and buy. Why? Because I'd like to use the email to sell and then have the call to action to like buy now. Now, in the first email, you might want to just announce, hey, doors are open. We are selling the product. Here's a quick overview what you're going to get. This is the deal. If you want all the details, here's the sales page with all the details. Go ahead and read it. Offer ends. So and so. That's usually my first email. I don't send them to the car. I send them to the sales page. So. So they have more context and they have more time. There's gonna be people gonna buy right off there, but most people won't. My second email and following emails, I like to start my first line of the email with, hey, if you got my last email and you know about this offer and you're sold, just click here to grab your spot, to grab this offer. This goes straight to the car. Some people are just like, I'm gonna buy anything you sell. They're, they're huge fans of you. Some people, they've already read your email before they've saw the sales page. They're convinced they just needed a reminder. They're going to click save them the time, have them go straight to checkout after that line. You can then, you know, continue to talk about the offer, talk about what is included, why they need it, the scarcity, all that kind of stuff. More about scarcity later. But this is huge, okay? That one liner made a huge difference for me because some people don't have time to read the whole email. They're just interested, they want to buy. I even throw in a line says, money back guarantee. You know, just let them know that, hey, if they just Make a decision to buy right now, there's no risk, they have 30 days, all that kind of stuff. And then all the following emails, I just send them straight to Cart. And then in the PS line I can say, hey, if you are not sold yet and need more convincing, check out our detailed sales page and that will be hyperlinked. The next strategy that has increased conversions for me tremendously is deadlines is scarcity. Real scarcity, real deadlines. I really believe in them because people take action when they do miss in the past an offer. I know we all have experienced this, whether it's Black Friday sales or e commerce sales or a coupon that expired that we forgot to buy something, do it. It works in your business and there's a lot of great tools for this. I mentioned Deadline Funnel before, great tool. There's other tools as well, but I've used Deadline Funnel before and it's a great product and basically it creates countdown timers and deadlines specific to each subscriber on your email list. It's a real deadline, it's not a fake deadline, it's not scammy or anything like that. It's actually legit and it expires. And when the offer's over, the offer's over and they can't get it. It's pretty nifty, it's pretty simple and you can implement it easily with your email software and your website. Now what's great about this is that you can embed a countdown timer right inside the email so they can see when they open, wow, this is how much time I have left. I got to get going now. You don't need this timer in my opinion, in the first initial emails, but especially the last few emails when there's like a day or two left, they need to know, hey, time is ticking. You need to take action and let them know what happens if they don't take action. They need to know. People don't know. Just a timer alone is not good enough. So for example, you will not be able to enroll until, you know, six months down the line or this offer is going to end and you're going to have to pay full price and you're not going to be able to save X amount of dollars or you're not going to get all these bonuses outside this offer. Let them know what they will lose. People have strong feelings towards loss aversion, right? People are more concerned about losing something than gaining something. So you might think you're convincing them by saying you're going to get this and this and this bonus and a discount and all these great things. But the reverse is actually more compelling. You won't be able to get these things. These things won't be on offer. They'll be taken away from you if you don't take action. So scarcity works time scarcity, and of course the bonuses and all the great deals that they're going to miss out on.
Building a portfolio with Fidelity Basket Portfolios is kind of like making a sandwich. It's as simple as picking your stocks and ETFs, sort of like your meats and other topics, and managing it as one big juicy investment. Now that's pretty good. Learn more@fidelity.com baskets Investing involves risks, including risk of loss Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC Member NYSE SIPC.
ADP knows anything can change the world of work. Like what if a blocked shipping port caused a worldwide coffee shortage? Suddenly, businesses are scrambling to manage an increasingly drowsy workforce. Productivity slips 20% just due to the extended time it takes to conduct a job interview while yawning. Anything can change the world of work. From HR to payroll, ADP helps businesses take on the next anything ADP always Designing for People.
To wrap up today's Q and A Wednesday's Question from Janet these are the three strategies that have really propelled my conversions on email. But I want to give one more and that's personality. I like to personally write my own emails and insert my own personality, my own humor, maybe even some anecdotes, some emojis, maybe even a quick one liner about what I did this weekend, or all the work that it took for me to put this product together, this offer together, or even an image of me and my team or whatever it might be. Make it personal. People love to correspond with a human being, right? In a world of AI and people like getting ChatGPT to produce all these different forms of copy, personalization and humor and personality goes a long way. So take the time to write them and insert and infuse your own personality. Even if you get somebody to write them for you, edit them so that they sound like you. Have fun with them. Make them your own. Janet, thanks so much for asking this question on Q and A Wednesday. If you got a question you want to ask, don't hesitate to email me over at omar00mba.net or you could just subscribe to our newsletter over at 100mba.net or download one of our templates and reply to any emails that I send you. I will reply personally. Don't worry. I actually love to reply to email. It's the way I like to connect with our audience. It may take me some time, but I will get to it. And of course I would love to answer your question that you submit right here on Q and A Wednesday. If you'd like, I can give a shout out to your business and your website. Just let me know if you love today's episode. Don't forget to hit Follow on your favorite podcast app. Whether you're using Apple Podcasts or Spotify right now, hit subscribe, hit Follow so you get our next episodes automatically. It's the best way to show your support for the show. Before I go, I want to leave you with this email, your website, your sales pages. It's not a once and done thing. It's all experimentation. It's all tests. It's all taking a look at what works. Tweaking, improving, trying new things, leaving it for a little bit, coming back to it, improving it. It's a lot of fun, It's a lot of experimentation. But that's how you know it works. That's how you know it's getting better. And if I didn't do that, I wouldn't have discovered the things I shared with you today on this episode. Thanks so much for listening and I'll check you in Friday's episode. I'll see you then. Take care.
ADP knows anything can change the world of work. Like what if a blocked shipping port caused a worldwide coffee shortage? Suddenly, businesses are scrambling to manage an increasingly drowsy workforce. Productivity slips 20% just due to the extended time it takes to conduct a job interview while yawning. Anything can change the world of work. From HR to payroll, ADP helps businesses take on the next anything. ADP always designing for people.
