Episode 11: Understanding Syndication Deal Structure - Equity Splits, Preferred Returns, and Waterfalls

Welcome to Building Passive Income, the podcast for professionals, entrepreneurs and investors who want to build wealth, diversify beyond Wall street, and create true financial freedom through passive commercial real estate investing. I'm Wayne Courageous III, founding and managing principal of Crei Partners, a leading commercial real estate company, I created CreiColin, an AI powered resource to serve as your investor education guide. Built on the insights and experience we've developed at CREI Partners, Creicollen is here to educate you through passive invest tax strategy topics to help your journey in passive investing. Just a quick disclaimer. This podcast and CRA Colin is for educational purposes only and is not legal tax or investment advice. Always consult with your attorney, CPA and financial advisor before making any investment decisions. I've spent nearly two decades helping investors understand the power of commercial real estate. From multifamily to storage to retail. Each episode is under 15 minutes, simple to follow and and packed with insights to help you grow your income and protect your capital without becoming a landlord. If you're ready to learn quickly and invest smarter, you're in the right place. Welcome to Building Passive Income. Let's build wealth together. Here's creicollen.

Not all syndication deals are created equal, and if you don't understand the deal structure you you could be leaving money on the table or worse, taking on more risk than you realize. I'm Crow and this is Building Passive Income, where we give you the strategies to build real wealth through passive real estate investing. Today we're breaking down syndication deal structure, equity splits, preferred returns, waterfalls, promote structures. These aren't just terms to gloss over in the ppm. They determine how much you make, when you make it, and and how aligned the sponsor is with your success. So let's dive in and make sure you understand exactly what you're signing up for before you write that check. Let's start with the foundation the equity split. This is the percentage of ownership between limited partners. That's you, the passive investor, and the general partner or GP. That's the sponsor. The most common split you'll see is 70 30. That means 70% of the profits go to the limited partners and 30% goes to the sponsor. But you'll also see 8020 splits, or sometimes 6040 on more aggressive deals. Here's what you need to understand. The equity split alone doesn't tell you the full story. A 7030 split sounds great, but if the sponsor is taking massive fees up front acquisition fees, asset management fees, construction management fees, you might actually be worse off than an 8020 split with lower fees so when you're evaluating a deal, don't just look at the equity split. Look at the total fee structure. Is the sponsor charging a 3% acquisition fee? A 2% asset management fee? Are they marking up construction costs? Add it all up. That's the real cost of doing business with that sponsor. Now let's talk about the preferred return or pref. This is one of the most important investor protections in a syndication deal. And it's non negotiable. For me, if a deal doesn't have a preface, I don't invest. Period. Here's how it works. A preferred return is a minimum return that limited partners receive before the sponsor gets any profit share. The most common pref is 8%. That means you as the LP get paid 8% annually on your invested capital before the sponsor gets a dime of profit. Let's say you invest $100,000 into a deal with an 8% pref. In year one, the property generates $15,000 in distributable cash flow. You get your $8,000 first, that's your 8% pref. The remaining 7,000 gets split according to the equity split. Let's say 70, 30. So you get another 4,900 and the sponsor gets 2100. But here's the key. If the deal only generates 6,000 in cash flow in year one, you get all 6,000. The sponsor gets zero because the pref wasn't met. That's alignment, that's protection. Now here's a critical Is the pref cumulative or non cumulative? A cumulative pref means if the deal doesn't hit the 8% return in year one, that shortfall carries forward and must be paid to LPs in future years before the sponsor gets profit. A non cumulative pref means the shortfall doesn't carry forward, it's just gone. Always ask, is the pref cumulative is. If it's not, that's a yellow flag. It means the sponsor can underperform in early years and still take their profit share later without making you whole first. Alright, now let's talk about waterfalls. This is where deal structures get more complex. And it's where sponsors either prove they're aligned with you or they don't. A waterfall is a tiered profit sharing structure. Instead of a flat 7030 split on all profits, the split changes based on how well the deal performs. The better the deal does, the more the sponsor earns. This is also called a promote structure. Here's a common tier 1. An 8% pref to LPs, then a 7030 split until LPs achieve a 12% IRR. Tier 2 After LPs hit a 12% IRR, the split changes to 60 40. Tier 3 After LPs hit a 15% IRR, the split changes To 50 50. So if the deal performs well and you're getting a 15% plus IRR, the sponsor earns a bigger share, 50% instead of 30%. That's their promote. They're incentivized to outperform, not just meet projections. Here's why I like this. It aligns interests. The sponsor doesn't just collect fees and coast. They have to deliver strong returns to earn their promote. And you as the LP are protected on the downside with your preface, but you still participate in the upside. But here's the flip side. If the waterfall is too aggressive, like the sponsor starts taking 50% at a 10% IRR, that's a red flag. They're not aligned. They're taking too much too soon. So when you're reviewing a deal, ask yourself, does this waterfall reward the sponsor for truly exceptional performance? Or are they taking an outsized share at returns? That should be table stakes. Now let's talk about fees. But because this is where a lot of investors get blindsided, sponsors don't just make money from the equity split and the promote. They also charge fees throughout the life of the deal. Here are the most common fees you'll see. Acquisition fee typically 1 to 3% of the purchase price. This covers the sponsor's cost to find, underwrite and close the deal. Asset management fee typically 1 to 2% of collected revenue paid annually. This covers ongoing management and oversight of the property. Disposition fee typically 1 to 2% of the sale price. This is paid when the property sells. Construction Management fee if it's a value add deal with renovations, the sponsor might charge a fee to oversee construction, sometimes 5 to 10% of the construction budget. Financing fee. Some sponsors charge a fee for securing debt. This one's less common and honestly, I think it's a bit much. Here's my take. Fees are fine. Sponsors should be compensated for their work. But the fees need to be reasonable and they need to be disclosed upfront in the PPM. If a sponsor is charging a 3% acquisition fee, a 2% asset management fee, a 10% construction management fee, and a 2% disposition fee. And they're taking a 30% profit share on top of that. You need to ask, is there enough meat left on the bone for me? Run the numbers. Look at the total fees over the life of the deal, then compare that to the projected returns. Does it still make sense? Alright, let's bring it all together. When you're evaluating a syndication deal structure, here's what you're really asking. Is the sponsor aligned with my success? Here are the questions I 1. Is there a preferred return? If not, why not? If yes, Is it cumulative? 2. What's the equity split and does it feel fair given the sponsor's track record and the deal's risk profile? 3. Is there a waterfall or promote structure? If yes, does it reward truly exceptional performance or is the sponsor taking too much too soon? 4. What are the total fees over the life of the deal? Are they reasonable or is the sponsor double dipping and extracting too much value? 5. Does the sponsor have significant skin in the game? Are they co investing their own capital alongside LPs? If they're not investing, that's a red flag. The best sponsors eat their own cooking. They co invest, they tie their compensation to performance, they structure deals where if you win, they win and if the deal underperforms, they feel it too. Alright, let's recap. When you're evaluating syndication deal structure, you need to understand 1. The equity split between LPs and the GP and and the total fee structure that goes with it. 2. The preferred return is there? 1. Is it cumulative and what's the rate? 3. The waterfall or promote structure. Does it reward outperformance or is the sponsor taking too much too soon? 4. The total fees over the life of the deal acquisition, asset management, construction, disposition. 5. Sponsor alignment. Are they co investing and and is there compensation tied to your success? Here's your action step. The next time you review a private placement memorandum, go straight to the section on distributions and fees. Read it carefully, run the numbers and if something doesn't make sense, ask the sponsor to explain it. If they can't or won't walk away. And as always, consult with your CPA attorney and financial advisor before making any investment or tax decisions. If you're ready to start evaluating syndication deals and you want help understanding the structure, let's talk. Check the Show Notes for a link to schedule a call with us@creipartners.com Next time on Building Passive Income. We're bringing back TaxPro Tina to talk about one of the most confusing documents you'll ever receive as a passive investor. Your first K1. Until then, remember, financial freedom isn't a dream, it's a decision. And it starts with understanding exactly what you're investing in. I'm Crei Collin. Let's build wealth together.

Thanks for tuning in to Building Passive Income. Today's episode helped shift your mindset or gave you a new tool to grow your wealth. Do us a favor and like, subscribe and share this podcast with someone you care about. Want to go deeper? Join our free Passive Investor Coaching program at passive investor coaching.com it's the perfect next step to start building wealth through commercial real estate the right way. Remember, financial freedom isn't a dream, it's a decision. And it starts with Building Passive Income. We'll see you in the next episode.