This Real Estate “Rule” Is Costing You Wealth! (Rookie Reply)

You've got cash ready but can't make the numbers work for a house hack. High interest rates are shaking your brrrr plans and your tenant wants out of their lease early. What now?

Today we're unpacking three pressing questions that many rickies are facing right now with real solutions that you can apply immediately.

This is the real estate rookie podcast. I'm Ashley Kerr.

And I'm Tony J. Robinson. And with that, let's get into our first question. So who question number one today comes from Ben. Ben says hey everyone, I'm 26 years old. My wife is 29. We've been travel nursing for the last two years and have a pretty great cash pile to get started in real estate investing. We were planning on traveling longer but just found out that we're expecting. Odds are we will need to reel in our wonderlust and settle back down where it all started, which is Akron, Ohio. The main goal for us is to find a two to four unit, preferably turnkey and and it live in one side for a year or so before refinancing and scaling. An issue I'm running into in my market though is high listing prices and lower rents not meeting the 1% rule. Those that do not meet the 1% rule are value ads that will need more work than I can put in right now. Looking for input though on a duplex I found in a great area. It's listed at 285,000 and one side is already renting for $1,100. It's newly renovated and turnkey. If we live on one side we'll still be paying $835 per month plus utilities. This seems like a lot for a house hack. Is the asking price outrageous, Is the rent too low or are these situations the new normal? All right, so house hacking and what actually makes a house hack a good deal. So I guess what jumps out at you first, Ashley, as we as we hear that question?

Yeah, well I think bringing up the 1% rule, I think for several years now it's been hard in a lot of markets to hit the 1% rule. But that shouldn't be the only metric that you are looking at. There's other metrics that make you money and the 1% rule doesn't always mean that it's a great deal. For example, in Buffalo, New York I for a very long time could very easily hit the 1% rule, sometimes the 3% rule. But they were on duplexes that were in lower income areas. They actually I found out became the headache properties and the property taxes were so high on them that they beat the 1% rule, but they didn't make the 50% rule where your expenses should be 50% of the rental income. So I would definitely take the 1% rule, just like any other metric, with a grain of salt and make sure that you're looking at other metrics of the property instead of just the 1% rule.

I think we should also reframe what makes a house hack successful. And much like the 1% rule, and being able to hit that has changed, I think so too, has the perfect house hack where. Where you're getting paid to live somewhere. Living expenses are typically one of the biggest expenses after taxes for the average American. And if you can reduce that even by some percentage, I think you're still getting ahead. And in this scenario, they said that they're paying $835 a month for their side of that duplex, while the side right next to them is renting out for eleven hundred dollars. So they're saving close to four hundred dollars on their rent every single month. Right. Or three hundred, I guess, in the scenario, several hundred dollars every single month on what they would be paying in rent elsewhere. So I think in theory, you're still winning on this deal because you're, you're getting reduced housing expenses. You have a tenant already placed on the other side, so you have the ability to build equity with this property over the next, however long you tend to hold it. And then when you move out, if you're renting, both sides say rent doesn't even increase. You're renting both sides at 1100 bucks. That's $2200 total. Right. So now you're, now you're netting, right now you're cash flow positive on that deal. So I think there's more to look at than just, are we getting paid to live here or are we able to live here rent free? And. And making sure that you're taking into account all of the other factors.

Yeah, I couldn't agree more with that. My sister, when she first did her house act, she was paying $45 to live there in an apartment that was. She could have rented for around $900. And she's on that property, I think, for five years now, and she's been able to increase the rent in the other unit. Her mortgage payment has stayed the same, so she's paying nothing to live in there now. And also it's become a more expensive apartment where if she went and lived in a very similar apartment to that one that she would be paying, you know, a lot more in rent. So I think you have to look at the long term, you know, result of house hacking too is that your mortgage payment stays the same. You can increase the rent as time goes on. And if you did rent somebody else, your rent most likely would continue to go up to where your mortgage payment will go up slightly due to insurance and property taxes. But most landlords raise their rent to cover and still profit above and beyond that. So you're still making out that way.

And I think one last thing that I'll comment on is, is in the question. They say our main goal is to find a two to four unit, preferably to turnkey, live in one side for a year or so before refinancing and scaling. And that before refinancing, I think is, is like a very important caveat. Let me know what you think, Ashley. But I, I feel like buying a turnkey duplex and being able to refinance in a year is probably going to be tough if it's because there's no value add, right? Like what you bought it a year ago is probably going to be pretty close to what it's worth in 12 months from there. So if that is the goal to be able to refinance and scale, you're basically asking about burying. I might almost focus on something that needs a little bit of love where you can do some value add. So that way when you do refinance in the year, there's some, some room there. So just a very important piece to call out.

I actually just had a refinance done on the property and literally the first question and it was a very short time period. It was bought the property and within a month was refinancing. And the first thing the appraiser asked was what did you do? What were the improvements? So even if we didn't do anything and we had bought the property below market value, the appraiser was still wanting to know, obviously she's looking at the purchase price, what we bought it for. She wants to know what those improvements were, where we added the value to the property that she's out here appraising it for. So I think yeah, definitely going the value add route. Also the they're saying Akron, Ohio is look at what the appreciation is in that area. We you've watched the news, you've seen that the market is shifting. It's becoming more of a buyer's market than a seller's market, which could lower the, the sales prices of properties in that area and appraisers appraise the property based on comparable sales in the area. So a year from now that house could potentially be worth less. So that's always like a risk. So one thing I always like to be cautious of, if you are not putting in any value, you either have to buy the property below market value, get a deep discount on it, and maybe the way the market is changing that will happen. Or you have to be okay that in a year you might not be able to refinance the property and pull out more money. Two other considerations is looking at the closing costs on these properties for doing two mortgages back to back. So if you did one mortgage, what are your closing costs going to be when you purchase it and then what are the closing costs? What amount does that equal to and does it offset what you'd actually get back in the refinance to you? So I think weigh out those two scenarios and run the numbers on it. So house hacking might have changed, but what about refinancing your burr at today's higher rates? Up next, let's unpack if waiting is worth it. But first we'll take a quick break to hear a word from today's show sponsors.

Landlords Here's a quick tip.

A standardized checklist for property inspections can save you time, money and headaches. Preventative maintenance means fewer expensive surprises later. Want to save even more? Rent ready helps you stay on top of rent collection, lease management and maintenance requests all in one easy to use platform. And right now you can get six months of rent ready for just $1. With promo code BP2025, visit rentready.com that's R E N T R E D I.com and use code BP2025 to get started.

This show has talked about assets that appreciate in value. Now let's talk about one that can haul those assets up a mountain. The Toyota Tundra and Tacoma are designed to outlast and outlive, combining raw power with precision engineering, all backed by Toyota's legendary reputation for reliability. Climb inside a tundra and experience the uncompromising strength. With its available iForce Max engine, the Tundra delivers exceptional power, torque and towing capacity. Plus, the spacious and high tech cabin keeps you connected on the run. Or check out a Tacoma. Agile, dependable and unstoppable, the Tacoma is designed for those who go beyond the trails. Stay ahead of the pack with available off road features like crawl control or break out your tunes with the available portable JBL speaker. Toyota trucks are built to last year after year, mile after mile. So outlast every adventure and outlive the moment. Buy a Tundra or tacoma today. Visit buyatoyota.com Toyota's official website for deals or stop by your local Toyota dealer to find out more. Check this out. Funding your next real estate deal might be easier than you think. Simply by using your retirement account with a self directed ira, you can invest those retirement funds into real estate while reducing or eliminating taxes.

And here's the best part. You don't need a huge IRA to get started. You can partner with other IRAs or funding sources to make it work as BiggerPocket's exclusive self directed IRA provider Equity Trust brings over 50 years of experience and $58 billion in assets under custody and administration.

Get online in minutes@trustc.com BP that's trust etc.com BP okay, welcome back.

So we got our second question today and this question comes from Amos. My partner and I have successfully used the BUR method, gaining us five doors in the last five years. Congratulations. However, this last project has posed a dilemma. In short, we went over budget on the rehab and the proposed interest rate is 8.75%. If we move forward with financing, we used our own cash to buy it and fully renovate as the property required. Going down to the studs, our forecasted rental income of $2,145 per month will cash flows about $200 per month based on the interest rate as high as 8%. Additionally, going over budget with a higher interest rate at 8.75% made us pause to reconsider other options. We are totally against analysis paralysis, so we need your help. Could or should we consider delaying the refinance for at least another year? If we can likely get cash from other sources for the next rehab, which is currently in the demo stage, what would be the implications, good or bad in regards to taxes, cash on cash return or anything else? Mind you, my partner and I have decided against personal financing at 7.65% as we prefer to not risk our other assets. Okay, I think this is actually a dilemma a lot of people have run into over the last year or so, or maybe even a little bit longer as rates have shifted. As to having that interest rate shock of oh my gosh, this is not what I expected.

Yeah, I think there's, there's a few options. Right. One you've got. I guess they didn't say how much they they purchased it for, but however much they bought it for, all of that is Just cash, right. That's sitting in that deal. So you've got a good amount of equity right now tied up into this single property. So I, I think you have to ask yourself what kind of return on equity are you getting? Right, like what kind of return on, on investment are you getting with all of your cash sitting in this deal? Rent is going to be 2145. You know, maybe you're netting after expenses a little less than 2000 bucks, you know, 1500 somewhere in that ballpark, after you pay all of your expenses. So is that 1500 bucks per month? Is that a good enough return for you and your partner to say, yeah, we can write it out for another year. If it's a 50% return, yeah, obviously it's a no brainer if it's like a 2% return, well now you got to ask, okay, can we actually go out and get a better return on that capital even with the eight and three quarter interest rate, can we go and get that cash back and redeploy it elsewhere to get a better return? So I think there's something to be said about how much cash do you have stuck in that deal right now and what does that return look like?

Yeah, I'm seeing two other options. One is you look at selling the property. What would you make if you sold the property? Would that be a large amount of money that it's actually worth it to unload and then you're just adding to your capital pile. The second thing is to refinance, but don't pull all of your money out. Maybe do half so your mortgage payment is lower, you're still recouping some of your funds and you still have some of that money to for the next rehab. So that's honestly probably the route I would take if you, you know, bought this property to have it as a buy and hold. I would look at refinancing, but not taking all of my money out. And then at a future date you could refinance, which stinks, you having to pay the closing costs twice. But you could also look at a commercial line of credit too. So you could do the commercial line of credit now even and, or you could do the commercial line of credit in the future and still have the mortgage on the property too. So I think there are certain options. The biggest recommendation right now is what you're going to do is talk to under other lenders and figure out what other options do they have like the commercial line of credit, things like that. And then I would run the numbers on if you didn't pull all of your money out, but you just took some of it back out.

Yeah, that's a great point. Ashley, on talking to more lenders. Like, I, I wonder how many folks Amos actually talked to. And is 8.75 the best rate or is that the only rate that you've seen so far? Because to Ashley's point, every lender could look at this same exact deal and give you a completely different menu of options in terms of what financing looks like. So actually like that should be the very first step is go shop this deal to 50 lenders and see who can maybe give you better terms based on what you've done because you're cash flow positive, newly renovated, you know, I'm assuming maybe it's stabilized already, so you've got a good asset. So it's, can you get someone else to maybe give you better terms? The last thing that I would call out is maybe also look into an adjustable rate mortgage. I've personally never done one before. But if, you know, if you can get the, you know, the rate down to, to somewhere below 8 for the next three to five years, like, does that give you enough to say, okay, cool, now we can refinance, get our capital back. And to Ashley's point, if you need to refinance again later or sell later, that's an option. But at least you've freed up some of that cash flow in the short term. So I think maybe even exploring some different loan products, which again, you'll have those brought to you as you start talking to different lenders.

Yeah, we actually had Dave Meyer on recently on an episode, and he's doing an adjustable rate mortgage right now on a property and he ended up getting like another interest point off because he already had a relationship, he had a brokerage account, I believe, with this bank, and they actually gave him like another percentage point off of the interest rate because of that relationship. So I think that's another avenue to look into too. If you already have, you know, even just money sitting in a savings account, you know, banks want those deposits, they want your money. So if you have something like that, talk to that bank and see if they do have options for you or consider moving your money to a bank that does do something like that where they give you a discount on lending because of your current relationship already with having money with them.

To talk to more lenders feels like the big solution here to, to get more insight. There's actually one part though, actually this question that we didn't really address. And it was the fact that they actually already have another demo going on. Right. So they said get cash from other sources for the next rehab, which is currently in the demo stage. So they've already committed to this next deal. And if you are able to get sources, you know, cash from other sources, then maybe that gives you some more time to figure this out. But if, if, if, you know, time is ticking and you guys are out of cash now, you've got another deal that maybe is going to end up sitting you, maybe you've got hard money on that. Who knows where you guys are at with that? So maybe you're, you're almost forced into some sort of refinance in this deal to free up that cash and get into the next one. So I wouldn't look at it in a vacuum and make sure that you're taking into account this deal that's already started the demo stage as well.

Yeah. And I think the commercial line of credit would be a great option for that too, is having the line of credit to use towards at least getting that on the property and using those funds towards the rehab until you decide what to do with this other property or wait till rates go down. I saw an article the other day stating that it's projected There might be 2 more interest rate cuts this year. So wouldn't that be nice? But we'll see.

All right, guys, we're going to take a quick break before our last question. But while we're going, be sure to subscribe to the real estate rookie YouTube channel. You can find this at Real Estate Rookie. And if you're listening to this in podcast form, be sure to follow us on your favorite podcast player. Subscribe. That way you guys are notified anytime we drop a new episode. So we'll be back with more right after this.

Inspecting your rentals again.

Here's a pro tip.

A simple checklist makes sure nothing gets overlooked. It saves you time and costly repairs down the road. And when it comes to managing your rentals, rent ready makes everything easier. Rent gets paid on time, leases get signed online, and maintenance requests don't get.

Lost in your inbox.

And if you're a BiggerPockets Pro member, I've got great news for you. RentReady is already included in your membership for free. Don't leave it sitting on the table. Log in to your BiggerPockets Pro account and start using RentReady today.

This show has talked about assets that appreciate in value. Now let's talk about one that can haul those assets up a mountain. The Toyota Tundra and Tacoma are designed to outlast and outlive, combining raw power with precision engineering, all backed by Toyota's legendary reputation for reliability. Climb inside a tundra and experience the uncompromising strength. With its available iForce Max engine, the Tundra delivers exceptional power, torque and towing capacity. Plus the spacious and high tech cabin keeps you connected on the run or check out a Tacoma. Agile, dependable and unstoppable, the Tacoma is designed for those who go beyond the trails. Stay ahead of the pack with available off road features like crawl control or break out your tunes with the available portable JBL speaker. Toyota trucks are built to last year after year, mile after mile, so outlast every adventure and outlive the moment. Buy a Tundra or Tacoma today? Visit buyatoyota.com, toyota's official website for deals or stop by your local Toyota dealer to find out more. Looking to build serious long term wealth in real estate? A 1031 exchange can be one of the smartest ways to make that happen. This strategy lets you defer capital gains taxes while reinvesting in new properties. Whether you're looking to diversify into new markets or different property types, Equity 1031 Exchange will guide you through every step.

Learn how to defer taxes and reinvest smarter in just minutes. Visit getequity1031.com bprookie that's getequity1031.com BProokie.

On WhatsApp, no one can see or hear your personal messages. Whether it's a voice call message or sending a password to WhatsApp, it's all just this. So whether you're sharing the streaming password in the family chat or trading those late night voice messages that could basically become a podcast, your personal messages stay between you, your friends and your family. No one else. Not even us. WhatsApp message privately with everyone With a.

Venmo debit card, you can Venmo more than just your friends. You can use your balance in so many ways. You can Venmo everything. Need gas? You can Venmo this. How about snacks? You can Venmo that. Your favorite band's merch? You can Venmo this or their next show. You can Venmo that. Visit Venmo Me Debit to learn more.

You can Venmo this or you can Venmo that. You can Venmo this or you can Venmo that.

The Venmo MasterCard is issued by the Bancorp bank and a pursuant to license. My MasterCard International Incorporated card may be used everywhere MasterCard is accepted. Venmo purchase restrictions apply.

All right guys, let's jump back in. So our next question comes from Garrett. All right, Garrett says I have a tenant who wants to break her year lease five months early. She has offered to pay three of the five months but keep her deposit and last last month's rent if we let her go. Having some buffer to find a new tenant would be nice, but the fact that we need to find one during the holidays and leading into winter does still not sit well with me. Plus she's breaking her lease. Should I negotiate the amount with her and let her go and hoping we can find someone for Jan1 or do I play hardball and hold her to the lease? Now there's some additional context here which I think is important for how we answer this question. So they go on to say some backstory. She paid her first six months up front because she sold her house to get out of debt. She did not have a job, but paid up front to build trust and assured us that she would have a job in six months time. Last week she sent a picture of a small hole in the linoleum floor and crack in the trim which looks like she dropped some heavy piece of furniture. She said it happened while she was out of town and now she does not feel safe in the house. December was the first month she was supposed to pay after her six month prepayment. But I knew right away she was going to use this strange hole in the floor to get out of her lease now that she needs to start paying. She did pay December's rent and then waited a week before she said she wants to leave. Any suggestions on how to handle this the house in North Carolina? So just to like recap here because I know there was a lot, but basically this tenant is unemployed, has a big chunk of cash, they move into into garage unit, pay several months upfront, six months up front. And then the first month that she's supposed to start paying again, she pays and then makes this big claim about her not feeling safe and wanting to break her lease. And Garrett's assumption here is that maybe she hasn't gotten a job, maybe she does, you know, she doesn't have enough to keep paying rent. So hearing all that, Ashley is our resident long term rental tenant management queen. What's, what's the advice?

I have to say that my opinion on this has changed over the years. I would have been, you know, posting the same thing as to like I am not and basically I Would have been like, I am not letting this person leave, they signed a year lease with me, blah blah blah blah. I have completely shifted after having a ton of tenant experiences. I would let them go if this is already a headache. If they don't have the money, if they didn't get a job, like you don't want them anyways, you're just going to have to evict them down the road. I wish that some tenants would say I, I need to get out of my lease, I, I need to move before I actually had to spend $2500 to evicted them. So I think even though this person obviously isn't being honest, if that's the case, or whatever it may be, if either way, I already see this tenant as being a problem and I would rather let somebody out of their lease. Here's a big mindset shift that I have had. Being a landlord should be customer service to a sense, like there is a line but you want someone to be happy in your property. It is first of all such a good feeling when somebody is telling you they love living there, blah blah blah. But you are providing someone a home and it will make your life so much easier if they love where they live. You want somebody to love where they live and providing a, you know, a nice safe house for them. If they don't want to live there, it is just going to be a headache for you. Why make somebody stay in the lease? Okay, and I get your point of like having to fill the vacancy. That is expensive. Okay. I'm also saying all this from the state of New York where it is very, very difficult to evict someone. And if someone doesn't want to live there and they feel forced to live there, there may be the chance that they just stop paying. And if you already think she doesn't have the money, let her out of the lease. Because it could be way more expensive to go through an eviction, collect that unpaid rent than it would be to get a new tenant in place. One thing I would do though is I would do a move out inspection with her and I would go ahead and charge her for that damage on the floor. Even if it happened while she was out of town. It is her property. She should have went and filed a police report then that somebody obviously came into her property and did damage in her floor. And if she doesn't have that, then you are entitled to her to that. And so I think looking at this scenario is if I was in this situation, I would let the person out of the lease because they're going to be a headache going forward. I, if, especially if you think they don't have the money to pay, let them out because then you're going to be stuck with them. I would take their security deposit and I would use that to fix the floor, though I would not let them give you an excuse for that. It happened while they were occupying the unit. And if it was some kind of damage, they should use their renter's insurance policy to replace it themselves. Or they should file a police report and have the police investigate who broke into their apartment and did this damage and then they can take that person to small claims court. So three of the five months, but keep her deposit in last month's rent. Okay, first of all, I think that's great that she's already offering to pay three of the five months. That gives you three months to find a tenant. That should be plenty of time to get somebody else in place. And as far as her deposit, I would, I would still weigh that out as to, you know, look at there. I'll have to do a walk through of the property to see if there is any damage in place on the property before you agree to give or deposit. I also recommend in the future in your lease agreements, you put in what happens if somebody does break their lease. So in most cases a common clause is stating that, um, they will, if they decide to break their lease, they will be charged one month's rent. Their security deposit will be retained. Another one is that they will be charged until the unit is filled. And as a, like a lot of state laws have it as to, you have to, as the landlord, actively list the unit and try to get someone in it. So look in your lease agreement too. Do you already have something in there that state some of this in that.

Ladies and gentlemen, is why Ashley is our resident tenant relations queen for, for the podcast.

It's just because I spent a lot of time crying, pulling my hair.

But you know, I love the point of the police report because it really forces them to either A, you know, admit that they were maybe lying or B, file a false police report, which is a crime in and of itself because what are the chances that there's some, some burglar who's breaking into apartment units, not stealing any, just poking holes in people's floor, you know, so I, I love that approach. But I, I, I appreciate you saying that, that your, your philosophy around this has changed as you've matured as an investor. And I think that's the cool part of like Doing this, you know, multiple, multiple, multiple times is that you start to identify the assumptions you made when you were starting out and how some of those assumptions were true and you can keep those ones and then how some of your other assumptions were false. And this one, I think it's more of like a, like a pride thing than like a truly logical thing. Because mathematically, if we just looked at this question, the answer is black. And you know, it's plain and clear, right? Like, okay, cool, she's offering three months of the five months that are left. That's more than enough cash for me to go out there and find a new tenant. If anything, I might end up making more money if I can turn this unit and get it re rented in less than three months. So mathematically it's easy. I think the bigger part is just like, and you kind of feel like this person's taking advantage of you maybe in a way. And I think that's the point that I'm trying to make is that as a real estate investor we have to sometimes separate our emotions from the facts of the situation. And if we can look at the facts objectively and say, what is the actual best decision for the business and not for my ego, you can tend to make better decisions. So I appreciate you sharing that, Ash, because I think a lot of rookies need to need to hear that.

Yeah. And that's my point of view. And I'm going to give you the other point of view that most other investors would have. As they would say, stick to the lease use. Tenants will start to walk all over you if you give in. This person, you know, like maybe you have a multi unit and this person, oh, they got to leave early. I, the landlord will let me do this too. So their investors will have two very different takes on this as to how to handle it. I'm just giving you my opinion. I don't like stress, I don't like headaches. I would rather just be done with this person and move on. And I think the fact that they're going to pay three months rent, I don't think I've ever had a tenant that has tried to break a lease that has offered that up front. I had to negotiate something like that with them, so I think that's great. But yeah, there, there are other investors that say like, no, stick to the lease agreement. They signed the lease, you signed the lease, so whatever is in the lease agreement is fair. And if you don't have an early termination clause in there, then look at, then you have A one year lease and you should stick to that so, you know, do what you think is best for your business. But I at least wanted to give you that other viewpoint because my opinion is not what every investor would do.

Yeah, but like you said, like your, your sanity and your peace of mind is, it's hard to put a price on that. And we've had guests, Ash, who've checked into our short term rentals and just start complaining about everything. The last guest just checked out. They, they left us a glowing five star review. Hey, we love the place, exact same property. Someone else checks in and they're just complaining about everything. And we've had situations where we're like, hey, look, if this place doesn't meet your standards, unfortunately there's nothing we can do to change that. We'd be happy to give you a full refund if you leave the house tonight.

I learned that from you, Tony. And I've done that like two times and it was like I, I don't care about the money. Like yes, that's going to hurt us but like having to deal with these people for another four days and getting a bad review, not worth it. And both of those times they left good reviews. They were like so thankful. They said we will leave a good review and they did.

So yeah, it's hard to put a price on, on peace of mind. So I agree with you, Ashley. And you know, obviously I think there's something to be said about sticking to the lease, but when, when you compare the pros and cons to your point of like having to deal with this person for another four months, I, I think the benefit of just letting them leave far outweighs the, the, hey, let's stick to the, stick to the lease piece. So anyway, hopefully, hopefully people got some, some value from that. I appreciate hearing your, your insights on how to deal with the, the tenant relations as always, Ashley.

Well, thank you guys so much for joining us today on this episode of Ricky. Reply. I'm Ashley, he's Tony and we'll see you guys on the next episode.