CW 1091 FBF - Vernon Grant Client Case Study - Highest & Best Use of Equity, Maximizing ROI, Retirement Planning, NYC vs Tampa
30 Nov 2018 · 40 min
In this episode of the Creating Wealth Show (Flashback Friday #809), host Jason Hartman interviews client Vernon Grant about his parents' real‑estate portfolio and retirement plans. The conversation covers the fundamentals of using equity efficiently—selling under‑performing assets, 1031 tax‑deferred exchanges, and "refi‑till‑you‑die" equity stripping. Hartman emphasizes rent‑to‑value ratios as a universal metric, illustrating that a 0.5% monthly return is typical across markets, and argues that a 1% target is more realistic for wealth building. The duo compares the parents' New York and Tampa properties, discusses the emotional resistance to selling, and evaluates options: selling, refinancing, or swapping via 1031. They also explore a planned acquisition of three Memphis properties funded by a $68k cash‑out refinance, projecting $2.7‑$3k monthly cash flow. Throughout, Hartman weaves analogies about vocabulary and mindset, warns about depreciation recapture, and stresses consulting tax and legal professionals. The episode ends with practical advice on diversification, the pitfalls of condos, and promotion of upcoming seminars.
Chapters
Be sure to check out our Cyber Monday sale. It is going all week long. It will end soon. But it's our best deals of the year@hartmaneducation.com that's hartmaneducation.com where all of our info products and educational products are half price for Cyber Monday. Our best sale of the year. Hartmaneducation.com welcome to this week's edition of Flashback Friday. Your opportunity to get some good review by listening to episodes from the past.
That Jason has handpicked to help you.
Today in the present and propel you into the future. Enjoy. This show is produced by the Hartman Media Company. For more information and links to all our great podcasts, visit hartmanmedia.com.
Welcome to the Creating wealth show with Jason Hartman.
You're about to learn a new slant.
On investing, some exciting techniques and and.
Fresh new approaches to the world's most historically proven asset class that will enable.
You to create more wealth and freedom.
Than you ever thought possible. Jason is a genuine, self made multimillionaire.
Who'S actually been there and done it.
He's a successful investor, lender, developer and entrepreneur who's owned properties in 11 states, had hundreds of tenants, and been involved.
In thousands of real estate transactions.
This program will help you follow in Jason's footsteps on the road to your Financial Independence Day. You really can do it.
And now, here's your host, Jason Hartman.
With the complete solution for real estate investors. Welcome to the Creating wealth show, episode number 809. 809. This is Jason Hartman. Thank you so much for joining me today as we do another case study. Yes, we have one of our clients on with us today and we love it when our clients come on the show and share their experience. The good, the bad and the ugly ask questions and get them answered. So if you would like to be on the show, just reach out to us and let us know if you're working with one of our investment counselors. Now, you can just reach out through them or you can just reach out through jasonhartman.com and we'd love to put you on the show and answer your questions, hear your experience, et cetera. Of course you can always reach me on Voxer as well. My Voxer Name is jhart88. Jhart88. If you just have a quick question there which we may play on the show. We don't always play those on the show, but sometimes we do. Sometimes they're a little hard to organize and too many of them come in and I can't keep track of them all But I, when, when applicable, I tried. I got to get back on that and start playing those on the show. Anyway, yeah, let's get to our guest today and do this little client case study. I hope you enjoy it. And one of the things I want to remind you of, and we, we talk about it here on this interview with our client, is that the ideal thing in terms of properties where you don't have good rent to value ratios, the ideal thing, if they're really far off, is always to sell them. Do a 1031 exchange if necessary. So you have tax deferral and then buy less expensive properties with better rent to value ratios. That would be the first choice. The second choice is to refinance them because at least if you refinance them, you get control of that equity. You've engaged in the practice that I call equity stripping, which is a very good practice so that your equity is no longer lazy money, it's not tied up in the property. You can use it, you can do some good with it and you actually lower your risk. I know this is counterintuitive for many people and we've talked about it many times on the past 808 episodes. Just keep that in mind. Selling, doing if necessary, a 1031 tax deferred exchange. Which by the way, a word of caution here. And remember that I am not a tax advisor, I'm not a lawyer. Always seek competent and it's not easy to find competent. By the way, always advice when it comes to this stuff because taxes and legal questions are particularly complicated. And one of the things that people are sometimes surprised by is, is that they can have a property that they are selling for the same price they bought it, but they've taken a big tax write off for many years. And that tax write off is the best tax benefit because income property is the most tax favored asset class in America. And that is called depreciation. It's a non cash write off. It's a phantom write off. It's a wonderful, wonderful tax benefit. But remember, if you've taken that tax benefit for the last five years, five years, and you sell the property for the same price you bought it for, then hey, you gotta pay that back. And that's called depreciation recapture. So even if you're, if you think from a very elementary understanding that you're just breaking even, you're really not, you're really making money. And this is the thing with real estate investing, because it's this wonderful multidimensional asset class income property, the most Historically proven asset class in the world, a multidimensional asset class where we earn our profits, we earn our returns from many dimensions. With that in mind, a lot of people, they just, they're making money, they're winning the game, and sometimes they think they're losing because they don't know how to keep score. And that's what we teach you to do, is keep score on this show, know how to keep score. And of course, go to realestatetools.com for some excellent tools that can help you keep score and help you be a better investor. Go to Jason hartman.com listen to or really watch that free 27 minute video that we've got on how to analyze a real estate investment that can be very, very, very helpful in learning how to keep score. And so part of keeping score is knowing that you've received this tax benefit for in that example I just mentioned the last five years. And if you sell the property for the same price you bought it for, hey, you're gonna have some depreciation recapture potentially, right. And so you still might want to do a 1031 tax deferred exchange. So that is something very important to keep in mind. Okay. So in either case, we let's get to our guest interview today. And if you're out there, you're one of our clients, we'd love to have you on the show as well. Just reach out to your investment counselor or contact us through Jason Hartman.com or contact me through Voxerheart88. And we'd always love to have you on the show. Anyway, here we go with our client case study. Hey, it's my pleasure to welcome one of our clients back to the show. Well, first time for this one, but we've had many clients on the show over the years and we always like to share these talks with you as sort of case studies and also have them ask some questions and so forth. And all of those questions apply to many of you listeners as well because many people have the, the same questions and are thinking along the same lines about stuff. And I just want to welcome Vernon Grant. Vernon, how are.
I'm well, thanks. And yourself?
Good, good to have you on the show. And you're coming to us from New York City area and it's great to have you. And you have really been helping your, your parents out with their real estate investing, it sounds like, and, and doing some of your own. Give us a little background if you would.
Yes, well, I'm an engineer by trade, but I went into business for myself in 2001 and been continuing that day. And now I have a little bit more time that I can help my parents out with their investing that they started in the 90s, I would say. And I like a lot of your ideas, and I would like to put what they have to good use, because what they have already is growing, but I think it could do a lot better based on their stuff.
Yeah, well, that's. That's a great topic. When did you discover my podcast?
Actually, I was listening to Ryan Moran's podcast, Freedom Fast Lane. I'm not sure if you remember it.
Yeah, I've been on a few of Ryan's shows, so. Yeah.
Yes. And so it was quite a while ago that I heard about your podcast, but I just was so busy, I didn't have the time to listen. And within the last, I would say, two months, I have binged so many episodes of your podcast. It's so great. You have so much good knowledge. You know, so many people, they will pick and choose information that they wish to share, but it's not the big picture. And you give such a clear big picture. You tie in so many things to the market and what if and what if and what you should do in those situations. And you're quite conservative with how you invest, and so, I mean, it just makes so much sense.
Well, I appreciate it, Vernon. Thank you. And I'm glad you like the show. So you've been binging on the episodes. Any idea how many episodes you've listened to?
Oh, man, at least a couple hundred.
Yeah. Good. Good stuff. Well, I hope you don't get sick of me anytime soon, but you're probably sick of me already. And you went to college for computer and electrical engineering, and then. And you were also in the Marine Corps for eight years as well, huh?
Yeah.
Good stuff. So. And then you said you started your own business in 2001. What kind of business is that?
Well, it was automotive accessories. So, you know, people hooking up their cars to go faster and look different and all of that stuff, and I was really into that scene. I still love cars. However, I wanted to try to shift gears because, you know, as the economy changed, things changed with the industry. And although I love cars, it's just not that great of a business anymore. And. And, you know, we've made a lot of money, and in the crisis, we've lost money. And so, again, you know, with your strategies, even in those different markets, I could have been making money, so I don't want to lose any more, so to speak.
Let's not miss any more opportunities if we can help it. So your father was a property manager. In fact, he was managing director of a property management company in the 80s and 90s. So you've got that background in real estate and that interest, it sounds like.
Yeah, I mean, I've been around it so much, you know, there have been times where he had to go back to Manhattan at like 3am because some commercial property that he's managing, some crisis happens, and so I've been in it. And even his father was a realtor as well. So I like it. I just hadn't had time to wrap myself around it and digest all the information, because there's a lot of information, but thank goodness in this day and age, it's so readily available.
Yeah, good stuff. Well, sounds great. Well, tell me about some of the questions you have and what you're thinking of doing, and let's outline some strategy here because you've got couple of different moving parts and I think we could, you know, align those really well for you.
Okay, so we've already identified a few properties that we're getting. But my main question is my parents have a particular house that they want to retire in. And when they bought it in 96 it, they purchased it at approximately $195,000, and now it's worth about 424,000. So they've got quite a bit of equity in there. And I'm not sure which direction will benefit us best, keeping in mind that, you know, they still want somewhere to go to vacation and have fun and. Or live for several months out of the year. So I want to take that equity out and do something with it or do a 1031 exchange. But I need your advice as to which one might be best.
Remember, you're listening to Flashback Friday. Our new episodes are published every Monday and Wednesday. Okay, so the $424,000 property, I believe that's in the Tampa, Florida area, is that correct?
Yes.
Okay, and your parents are living in that area. Are they living in New York or. Kind of both or what?
They're still living in New York.
Okay, so they live in New York and they want to retire in the. Potentially in the Tampa property, right?
Correct.
Okay, good. So do they own a home in New York?
Yes, they do.
And how much is that worth?
That is about the same. About the same.
About 425,000. Same price.
Exactly.
Okay, and what. What's their target date for retirement? Maybe.
My mom will definitely retire within the next year. So they want to Move. Not maybe right away. I would say within the next four or so, four or five years.
So is the property in Tampa rented out now?
Yes, it is.
Okay, and how much rent are they getting? Well, actually, I can tell you okay, without. Without knowing. I'm gonna guess that they're getting somewhere in the ballpark of maybe $2,100 a month.
Wow, that's really, really good.
Is 2222. You know, I was gonna say 2200, and I just didn't want to be too aggressive knowing that they paid 195 for it. So they're basically getting about a 0.5 rent to value ratio. And Vernon, isn't it amazing? You know, I have tried this little parlor trick all over the world, and it doesn't matter what city, what language, what currency. You know, it can be Paris, France, it can be Hong Kong, it can be, you know, Tokyo. It doesn't matter where it is. It could be la, you know, it can be Tampa, Florida, or Miami or anywhere, Boston. It doesn't matter.
Numbers and numbers, right?
The ratios are always about the same. It's incredible. You know, if you've got a Property that's worth $424,000, you can convert that any. Into any currency on earth. And that rent to value ratio not notwithstanding, you know, rent control or communism or, you know, something like that. Right. But if it's in the free market, it'll generally be just about the same ratio. So it's, it's truly amazing to me. It really is. I remember I was in Belize once looking at properties down there, and this has nothing to do with those properties because I wasn't interested in them. But I was talking to a wealthy insurance guy about his business and so forth, and he. I talked about this on a former episode, and I don't even remember where he moved from now. But, you know, he, he and his family had moved and they were renting a place in, I think, Miami, if I'm not mistaken, taken. And they said it was worth. I think they said it was worth 1.3 million. And I said, oh, so you're paying about 4,000 in rent? And he said, how do you know? And I, you know, I just know. It's. It's amazing how well that works. So listeners, that. Let that be a lesson that it's all about ratios. And those ratios hold hold true in, in every language, every currency, every geography. It doesn't matter where. So it's really amazing. Okay, so they're getting 22 for their, their Tampa property, and it's worth 400 and let's just call it 425,000. And they're renting it now. So is. Do they have some attachment to that property? You know, like, when did they buy it? 96, I guess. Did they ever live there or was. Did they just turn it into rental and say, hey, you know, in 20 years, we'll retire here? Was that their thinking or.
That's exactly what it was. In 20 years, we'll retire here.
Okay. All right. So, I mean, from a pure numbers perspective, I would definitely be selling that property. And, you know, when they retire, they. They can buy another property. And that retirement thing is a moving target. You know, they might not retire in the time frame. They're thinking they might find a better property. They might pick a different area. You know, I don't know. I mean, all of this stuff is such a moving target, and there's so many opportunities and the world is changing so quickly nowadays that, you know, from a purely investment standpoint, that property definitely does not make sense. Right. Because as you well know, I would like to see them get 1% per month. So again, for 425,000 invested capital, I'd like them to get, you know, $4,250 per month, not 2,200 per month. That's just a pure numbers angle. It doesn't include psychology. It doesn't include sentimentality and emotions and various things like that. Of course, you can't quantify those things very well. But then the other thing they've got to think about is the. The property in New York. Of course, when I. I probably wouldn't do anything with that because it would be too upsetting to their life, you know, unless they want to move and they don't like it. If they. If they want to move, then I would sell that one and. And pay $2,200 to somebody else to have the equivalent home, you know, and live in New York until they retire. There's also a question of kind of timing the real estate market, because that New York market is such a. A frothy cyclical market. Right. And it's, as I always say, it's very difficult, Vernon, to time any market. I would certainly say it's, you know, it's on the verge of being overvalued. Okay. But again, who knows? You know, that could. That could, you know, if. If the Trump economy really does boom and the money loosens up, I mean, that. That frothy market could go on for years more. I'm just Saying that today from a fundamentals perspective, it's out of whack. And we all, we all know that. Okay, did you have a deeper question here?
So they are also old school mentality. So it takes a bit of convincing to let them know that it's not about, we get the property and you pay and you pay till you pay it off, which is what they still. Especially my mom, she has that mentality. She, she's a nurse, by the way, so, you know, she's. And she's been working at the same job for like 40 plus years and that they just want to pay it off. So if I introduce to them an idea that they're gonna have to pay for where they live again, it has to be. I have to offer them something more than, hey, you have to pay your monthly mortgage on this place, on this new place, or whatever it is.
Yep. The, the hard thing in life, especially for old school people that are thinking like the old school way, which, by the way, they're not wrong. They're just out of sequence with the times. Right. Their plan worked great. When it all started to not work was post 1971 when we went off the gold standard. Then the game really changed because the lending standards changed, money got easier, and inflation reared its ugly head. And the game just totally changed. That was really the inflection point when it all happened. The hard part, as you've heard me talk about on the show, Vernon, to get people to understand in any area of life, not just investing, is that you can't hear the dogs that don't bark. They never look at what might have happened or what didn't happen because they did or didn't take another path. They only see what they did. They didn't see what they didn't do or what they could have done. That's hard for the human mind to think that way. And it's. It's that old thing. You can't hear the dogs that don't bark.
I've heard a quote. Sorry to cut you. I wrote a quote that. That reflects that same thought. That you can't see past the choices you don't make.
Oh, that's a good quote. Who said that one? I like that.
Yeah, I don't remember.
I like that. Let's. Let's find that. I gotta. I'm gonna, I'm gonna search that. That's a good quote. You can't see past the choices you don't make. Mm. Oh, really good. Thank you for sharing that one. I like that one. I almost like that one better. It's, it's more understandable than you can't hear the dogs that don't bark, but any. Anyway, yeah, you can't see past the choices you don't make. So it begs the question, what choices are your parents or many other. There are tens of millions of people in this very similar situation. Right. What choices aren't they making? Well, they're choosing not to sell $850,000 worth of two properties and do 1031 exchanges where they could buy eight single family detached homes in diversified markets. That would net them around. Well, not net. I want to say it's really gross, but it's net. Also, I'm kind of thinking of it differently than myopically people would think of it from accounting perspective, but it would just get them 800 or $8,000 per month in income. Right. And then they could turn around and rent the place they live in and pay 2,200 for that one. Right. Because in New York or, or Florida, it's the same deal. You know, it doesn't matter. Right, right. They could rent that equivalent property they're living in now for about 2200amonth in New York, and then when they move to Tampa, they could also do the same thing. But most people's minds say, well, hey, if I'm renting, I'm throwing money away. That's how everybody thinks of it. And it's how I used to think of it, too. But what they, the choice they didn't make is they chose not to get $8,000 a month for that same value of real estate.
Right. I mean, it's, it's also the tools that they have. You, you can't really understand a thing if you don't have the tools to understand it with.
Right. Yeah. You know what that reminds me of? It's, it's kind of like the concept of vocabulary. Now, we're going on a little tangent here, but when, you know, certain languages have, you know, fewer words from which to choose, so it literally limits the population's ability to think. And, you know, uneducated people or children, for example, you know, they have a smaller vocabulary. Right. So they, that, that's. Their vocabulary is literally the tool with which you can think. And if you have a big vocabulary, you can think more thoughts. You literally can't think a thought that you can't express usually. Right. And so if there's not a word for it, then, you know, it's very hard to think about it. Right. So. Yeah.
Yeah. How do you Express it. That's why we come up with labels for things and containers to put things in, classify things so we can understand them.
Yep, yep. No question about it. And, you know, props to the English language, the most widely spoken language on earth. It's also the largest language with about 6, 700,000 words, I believe, where if you look at, like, French, Spanish, Italian, I think they've all got around 150,000 words. So a lot fewer tools. And the reason English is that way is, you know, not because English is so great or anything. It's just a language that happens to adopt and sort of suck up a lot of words from a lot of other languages. You know, we have all sorts of foreign words woven into the English language. Right. And I. And I guess other languages don't do that as much as English does, so it's just kind of interesting. Tangent alert. We're on a tangent alert here. Yeah, but. Okay, so the other thing they could do if they don't want to sell those properties, because I know that, you know that that mindset that, you know, your parents have, my mother has that same mindset, is when you sell something, it's like you lost it. Right. You. You gave it up. Right. And that mindset is very hard to, to, you know, kind of argue with. Right. So the other thing they could do is they could do refi till you die. Right. And that is another option because at least they could get that equity out and make it work for them. Do you know what kind of debt they have on the properties, if any, or have they paid them off?
I'm not sure about the Florida property. I know they're still paying it for it, but very minimal amount, and I know the one in New York, I did recently convince them to refinance it. So refi. Cash out. So that's how we're getting those extra few properties that I was just mentioning to you. And I'll be at the Memphis tour, by the way.
The way. Oh, good. Hey, I look forward to seeing you at the Memphis property tour with that boy. I'll be at Memphis in six days. I haven't even been thinking. It's right around the corner. So we'll look forward to seeing you there. And by the time people listen to this, that will have probably already happened.
So we're going to buy about three properties with that, with the equity.
Okay. How much are you pulling out to buy the three properties?
I think so far total, it came out to about 68,000 that we have to put down.
That's not bad.
Not at all.
Basically, for $68,000, you can buy three properties. You'll gain. Or they. Or you. Or, you know, both of you, I guess, will gain diversification because you'll be in a totally different market. Right. Which will be good. And those three properties should produce somewhere in the neighborhood of, you know, 2,700 to $3,000 per month in income, right? Yeah.
Good cash flow, actually.
Yeah. Fantastic. And once. Once your parents see. You know, sometimes you gotta do it to really internalize it or understand it, you know, in your. In your gut. Once they see that and they actually do that deal and they see that, look here, we're getting a thousand dollars per month for each of these properties, for example. And I'm just pulling out a round number. I don't know the exact properties you're looking at. Then, you know, they'll think, well, these three properties with only $68,000 down, we generated a gross of $3,000 per month. They're going to be thinking, well, here we've got $425,000 in this property in Tampa, and all we get is 2,200amonth. Mm.
And it's only break even sometimes.
So that will probably go a long way in getting them to see the light, if you will. You know, And I know it's. It's hard. You know, I. I mean, I take my own mother's example. The countless conversations had, you know, slash arguments that I've had with her about this stuff. You know, it's funny, too. This is the funny thing. Another funny thing about the way the human mind works. And I don't know why it's this way. It just is. But we will trust a stranger, a total stranger, more than we will trust our own friends and family, the people we know well. And I don't know why that is. You know, there's an old saying, familiarity breeds contempt. And even if we love these people or, you know, like them really well, there's a familiarity. We just don't respect that as much as we respect the someone you know, at a distance.
It happens all the time. Even like, let's say my dad, if he's having some medical issues, like with eating and stuff like that, because I've taught myself so much about health and so on. I tell him, okay, this is what you should eat, and this is why you're having this problem, because you're doing this. And he not listening to me at all. And then one day he goes to the doctor. The doctor tells him, that's when he changes. I said to him, what is it? Because I don't have a PhD or an MD. That's why you don't listen to me. Come on, I've been telling you this for years.
Yep. You know, you're right. But even if you did have a PhD and an MD, you still would be family and he would not listen to you.
That's so true.
It's just, it's just the way. I don't know why that is. It's just a. There's all kinds of these funny quirks about the way the human mind works, but it just is. It's just an odd, odd thing the way it works. So just a reminder, you're listening to Flashback Friday. Our new episodes are published every Monday and every Wednesday. I think with your folks that that refi plan is really going to help when they see those three properties performing. Now are those going to be all three in Memphis or are those. Have you purchased those properties yet or. Tell me about that.
We're under contract, so we're just getting our approval stuff. We're already pre approved and we just need all the paperwork in so they can run it by the underwriters.
Okay, good stuff. And where are those properties?
Those are all in Memphis.
Okay, so after you do those three in Memphis, if they're, you know, if they decide to sell one of the two properties. And by the way, I didn't ask you, do they own any other properties?
Yes, they do. They own a couple pieces of land and one other property. But that property, you know, they lost some money on it. So they're just, it's rented and the price is re appreciating again. So they're just weighing it out.
Tell us a little bit about that one.
That one is actually also in, in South Florida. That is near Tampa. I forgot. Exactly.
Yeah, don't worry about that. How much is it worth? Do you know the, the metrics on it? What it's worth and what it rents for?
Not what it rents for. But I do know they purchased it at 105 and the current value is 89.
Okay. So it's gone down in value and that one is probably got a pretty good rent to value ratio. So oddly, that one that they lost the money on is probably the one that they maybe most likely should keep. However, I have a feeling, and I don't know this, but I have a feeling that that's a condo. Isn't.
Absolutely. Is.
Yeah. I don't like condos unless they're very good deals. I just don't like condos. And there have been a lot of condo problems in various areas around the country. And, and look, listeners, I don't want you to hear me say that I'll never do a condo. I will do a condo. It's just gotta be a much better deal, okay? There's gotta be something to offset the fact that it's a condo. Okay? I just, I just don't like condos. They have a whole new set of potential problems with them. Okay, so that one, you know, that probably rents for around 900,000amonth, I bet, right?
Yeah, I'm thinking it because I remember seeing the numbers, it was like anywhere from eight to nine.
Yeah, so, so that's, that's fine. In terms of rent to value ratio. Now the one thing we didn't explore on any of these properties, by the way, is the debt structure on them. You know, what is the, as they say, the capital stack. Right. You know, if you have a high interest rate loan on one or an adjustable rate loan on one, and you know, maybe you have a low interest rate on another, these things could also influence your thinking on selling or refinancing or, you know, when you refinance, if you've got a very low interest rate first loan on the property, occasionally it'll make sense to put a second loan on it, sometimes not. So there are, there are numerous factors here, right? We, you know, I just want to make sure everybody knows that maybe the age of the property, the location, you know, properties. Some areas in Florida, for example, have really high insurance costs. Properties in New York have really high property taxes. Right. So, you know, there are multiple things to think about. And in New York you might be in a rent controlled area and that's really bad as an owner, but it could be really good as a tenant. So there are all kinds of other dimensions. But what were you going to say?
Was gonna ask what. So I'm assuming that the advice would be the most optimal thing would be a 1031 exchange, correct?
Oh yeah. The 1031 exchange is the way to go for sure because it allows you to basically trade properties all your life and defer, defer, defer the gain. And you know, listeners also need to be very mindful. I was looking at one of my properties, I've been, over the past several years, I've been reworking my portfolio and selling some properties and trading them for others. And so I've got this one property in an old market we used to do Mobile, Alabama, and it's been Very good to me. I bought it when there was something called the go zone going on. And you hear me talk about that on the old episodes.
Yes, I have.
Yeah. And that was a tremendous tax benefit. Like so many government policies, it eventually turned into a mess because the, you know, so many investors got attracted there that the properties became overvalued and we stopped recommending it. But our, our clients who got into the go zone early enough did very well, and including me. You know, this particular property is only worth about the same as what I purchased it for, but because I had such tremendous gozo and tax benefits, I would, I would potentially sell it and break even. But I would really need to do a 1031 tax deferred exchange on that property. Because. And I asked my accountant, I said, hey, do, what's my depreciation recapture on this property? And guess what he said then, by the way, this property is worth about $170,000, give or take. But if I sold that outright and just broke even on paper, by the time the tax consequences came up, I would get at $98,000 in depreciation recapture on which I would have to pay taxes.
Wow.
So, you know, in a way, you can get kind of trapped into this real estate game, which it isn't all bad. Okay. It's actually quite good. But you've got to really think of it. And, and you know, people make mistakes sometimes and they'll sell a property thinking, hey, you know, I'm just breaking even or I'm making 20 grand. It's no big deal. I'll just pay the taxes on the 20 grand. No, you've already taken a bunch of tax benefits over the years here that you got as a deduction. And now if you don't do a 1031 exchange, you gotta recapture those and pay them. Okay? So things aren't always as simple as they look. So be careful. Always consult a tax advisor and make sure you have one that knows about real estate.
Yeah, certainly.
Very, very important. So any other thoughts or questions you want to share with the audience?
At what point do you know if it should be a refi till you die versus 1031 exchange?
Well, really, what tells you that is the rent to value ratio. And on both of those properties, ideally, if there was no sort of life hassle factor or emotional factor involved, from just a cold, pure numbers standpoint, I would definitely be selling those properties. Okay. And doing 1031 exchanges. But I do, of course, understand there are other considerations. So, you know, those, those are, there are other Factors to weigh in there. And you know, if your folks are going to retire in two years, it's looking like the market's gonna continue booming pretty well. I mean, that's what most people think. I think, you know, the money, money supply is flowing into real estate for all the Trump reasons I've mentioned on prior episodes of, you know, our, for him being our first real estate president, you know, eliminating or softening Dodd Frank, et cetera, et cetera. If they're gonna retire in two years, just stay put and make life easy and keep that New York property. You know, it's only two years. Not a big deal. Right. And, and, but, but I would really consider selling the Tampa, Florida property.
Okay. And I guess purchasing another one that they like somewhere to live down there.
Yeah. Or three or four more. And, and then they can buy back into that market or they might really decide they just want to rent because maybe that's, you know, that's not their final perfect location. Maybe it's not their dream home. Maybe they want to have some flexibility. You know, maybe they want to go on a cruise for a year or travel. I mean, renting is just so, so, so much easier, you know.
That's true. You don't have all those costs that you have to worry about.
Yeah, yeah. No question about it. It's, it's really quite easy to be a renter, you know, and you don't have to unload a property. You know, you can, can just give 30 days notice and move out. You don't have to show it and have people invading your privacy and it's just much easier. There's a lot of hidden costs in homeowner home ownership too.
Upkeep and all that stuff. Oh, man. Yeah.
And you know, a lot of time they're spending working on their house and going to the hardware store and when you're a renter, you just, you just live there, you know, it's much easier. So all good stuff to think about. But Vernon, hey, thanks for coming on the show and sharing your story and your parents story with us. And, you know, hopefully they will listen to this podcast if you can get them to do that, and I hope it helps them. And we will look forward to seeing you at our upcoming Creating wealth seminar and Memphis Property Tour next weekend.
No problem. Thank you so much for your help and time.
My pleasure. Happy investing. Thank you so much for listening. Please be sure to subscribe so that you don't miss any episodes. Be sure to check out this show's specific website and Our General Website HartmanMedia.com for appropriate disclaimers and terms of service. Remember that guest opinions are their own, and if you require specific legal or tax advice or advice in any other specialized area, please consult an appropriate professional and we also very much appreciate you reviewing the show. Please go to iTunes or Stitcher Radio or whatever platform you're using and write a review for the show. We would very much appreciate that. And be sure to make it official and subscribe so you do not miss any episodes. We look forward to seeing you on the next episode.
More from Jason


2482: AI Labor Displacement and the K-Shaped Housing Affordability: High-End Housing and the New Economic Divide with Adam Taggart


2482: AI Labor Displacement and the K-Shaped Housing Affordability: High-End Housing and the New Economic Divide with Adam Taggart


2480 FBF: Investor Mindset & DuckDuckGo Founder, Super Thinking Mental Models & Traction, How Any Startup Explosive Growth by Gabriel Weinberg


2480 FBF: Investor Mindset & DuckDuckGo Founder, Super Thinking Mental Models & Traction, How Any Startup Explosive Growth by Gabriel Weinberg


2478 FBF: Jim Rickards on The Death of Money, Aftermath, Currency Wars & The New Great Depression


2478 FBF: Jim Rickards on The Death of Money, Aftermath, Currency Wars & The New Great Depression


2477: Builder Profit Margins Hit 26-Year Lows and Solving the American Housing Crisis

