What Twins Tell Us

This is Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedantam. In October 2014, psychology professor Nancy Segal heard a story. It was about her specialty, the study of twins. It's December 1988. A woman from a remote farming village in Colombia makes a day-long trek to a hospital. She gives birth there to to a pair of identical twin boys. One of the twins needs more advanced medical care that isn't available.

One of them was extremely sick.

Since the mom is still recuperating, a relative takes him to another hospital 6 hours away in Bogotá, the capital. At the Bogotá hospital, another set of identical twin boys has just been born. Their mother is a seamstress who lives in the city.

The scene was quite chaotic.

The hospital staff is tired and overworked.

It was approaching Christmas time. People were thinking about the holidays.

Now, nobody knows exactly what happens next, but something goes wrong. The baby from the countryside is switched with one of the babies born to the mother from the city. By the time all the babies are sent home, one boy from each pair of identical twins is in the wrong family. Each family thinks their twins are fraternal. The homes the boys grow up in are in totally different places, 150 miles away from each other and a world apart.

One, the lively capital city of Bogotá, And the other in a very remote farming village.

25 years later, when the truth was discovered, Nancy says it was also deeply painful.

It was also a tragedy in the sense that 2 of the twins grew up in a home where they were not biologically connected, and they discovered in a matter of minutes that their identities were totally shattered. They weren't who they thought they were. They belonged in other families. Their parents were not their parents. In short, everything about their life was basically a lie.

This week on Hidden Brain, we revisit the story we released a couple of years ago about the Bogotá twins. It was a tragedy, a soap opera, and a science experiment all rolled into one. And we'll also find out why twin studies can act as a natural experiment to test some of the biggest questions about human nature. Support for Hidden Brain comes from Liberty Mutual Insurance. Making smart decisions includes considering how to protect your car and home and how much you're paying to insure them. Liberty Mutual customizes your car and home insurance to save you money. Because when you've worked hard for something, choosing insurance should be easy. Start your quote at libertymutual.com. Support for Hidden Brain comes from Principal, the perpetual pen tapper, the arbitrary fridge reorganizer, the holiday party planner that starts in May. Principal knows your star employees have their work quirks. Principal also knows how much those employees mean to your business. You need them. They need benefits. Work with Principal so they can help you help your team with a retirement and benefits plan that's right for them. Principal Life Insurance Company, Des Moines, Iowa. Support for Hidden Brain comes from U.S. Bank. With a U.S. Bank SmartLevi Visa Signature Card, you earn an unlimited 2% cash back on every purchase. No quarterly activations, no categories to track, Just unlimited 2% cash back on every purchase. Visit usbank.com/smartlycard to learn more. The creditor and issuer of this card is U.S. Bank National Association pursuant to a license from Visa USA, Inc. Some restrictions may apply. Nancy Siegel is a professor of psychology at California State University, Fullerton. She's the director of their Twin Studies Center. She wrote about the Bogotá twins in her book, Accidental Brothers: The Story of Twins Exchanged at Birth and the Power of Nature and Nurture. In both the remote farming village and the city, each set of mismatched brothers had very different outlooks and personalities. In each family, one brother seemed outgoing, the other reserved.

And in fact, people would kid the twins and the parents and say, Are you sure you're twins? And how could you have 2 boys who look so different? But people, again, are sensitive to fraternal twin differences. People know that ordinary siblings in a family who have the same genetic relatedness as fraternal twins often look and act very differently. So it was not such a tremendous surprise. The other interesting thing, though, is that in Bogotá, the mom had been told she was having identical twins. And this might have been information gotten from an early scan. It's possible. But it could be that, you know, sometimes these things can be unreliable. And so when she had fraternal twin boys, she accepted it and was quite pleased.

William and Wilbur, the 2 brothers who grew up in the farming village, eventually move to Bogotá and get jobs behind the counter at a butcher shop. It's the summer of 2013. They're now 25. And it's here where their lives begin to intersect with the brothers in the city, Jorge and Carlos, where it starts to become clear that someone, somehow, has made a terrible mistake. A coworker of Jorge, again, one of the twins raised in the city, runs into William at the butcher shop.

One day, 2 women went to the butcher shop to buy some meat. Now, one of those women was a coworker of Jorge's, and her first impulse was, what is Jorge doing behind the butcher counter? Is he moonlighting as a butcher on weekends? Is he short of money? She was really baffled when he didn't greet her. Meanwhile, the friend that she was with said, don't be silly. That is my boyfriend's cousin. So they're going back and forth, back and forth on this. And finally he said, my name is William. I'm her boyfriend's cousin. I don't know Jorge. And that was it. But when Laura, this friend, went back to see Jorge the following week at work, she told him about it. They had a good laugh about it. And nothing really happened.

But something about the incident sticks with Laura. She tracks down a photo of William and brings it to Jorge's desk. She tells him to sit down. He's about to be shocked. Jorge stares at the image on Laura's phone. He swears. That's me, he says. One thing leads to another, and the 2 biological brothers meet for the first time at a public square in Bogotá. The scene is captured on someone's phone. A friend, offscreen, sounds shocked. Jorge and William. Look exactly the same. Another friend breaks the ice. William is whiter, he says. But other than their complexion, they are like mirror images—both handsome with delicate features. Both have an easy laugh. They steal glances at each other and shift from side to side. Oh my God! says their friend. This can't be true. Jorge says, "I can't believe it." To an onlooker, this moment would look like nothing—just young men joking around. Its meaning would sink in only later. But right now, they have so many questions. William and Jorge go to a nearby coffee shop. Where they find they have instant chemistry.

They got along well. They understood the world the same way. And that was something rare for them because neither one of them shared it with their fraternal twin— their so-called fraternal twin brother.

Up next would be the reunion of the other identical twin pair, Carlos and Wilbur. And here's something I've left out of the story. Wilbur was also at the square that night, watching from the sidelines. It was decided then and there that he should meet his identical twin Carlos as soon as possible. The 3 young men get in a cab to go find Carlos. The reunion is hard for Carlos. It meant he was supposed to have grown up on a farm, not a city. It meant his brother was not his real brother. His sister was not his real sister. His mother was not his real mother.

Because you've got to remember that Carlos was a city boy. He loved his mother, who had passed away a few years earlier, and to discover that she might not be his mother was absolutely devastating to him.

The first time he saw his identical brother Wilbur, Carlos went out of his way to try and find differences between them.

But he looked in vain because they looked exactly the same. Both of them were very, very interested in appearance. Both of them got their eyebrows waxed, very into fashion. They both liked similar types of girlfriends. They both called themselves the crybabies because they were very sensitive as children. They were always complaining and always kind of undergoing various medical complaints, whereas Jorge and William had no medical complaints whatsoever. We gave them long medical histories, and Jorge and William just had handed them in blank. But Carlos and Wilbur had long lists of various types of pains and aches and other ailments.

Hmm. Did the brothers stay in touch after the mix-up was corrected and revealed?

Oh, yes. In fact, they call themselves— well, I call them the Band of Brothers because they do that. They have stayed in touch. They make decisions based on 4. They have a common email address. They really are very close. You know, what's important is that there are 2 ways they could have handled this. One would have been complete despair, and the other is simply accepting and moving on. They and their family members say, look, we did not lose a nephew. We did not We did not lose a brother. We did not lose a son. We're gaining. And I think that they should be applauded for that kind of an attitude and for carrying it out so successfully.

As a researcher, obviously, you've been fascinated by, you know, how the bonds of genetic connection might prompt, you know, similarities. But when you went down to Bogotá, did you also find that the bonds of familial connection, growing up in the same household, growing up in the same environment, did that form or forge connections that are also still apparent today?

Yes. Each pair of unrelated brothers feels a tremendous loyalty toward the other one. So Jorge wondered initially if perhaps Carlos would feel left out. And so he went and got a tattoo of Carlos on his chest next to the one he has of his mother. And in Spanish, it says, my sacred family. And that was very touching for Carlos. So they maintain a lot of family loyalty, as do William and Wilbur. Now, William and Wilbur were in the Army together. They were in the army together. They went to Bolivia together. And they watched out for one another a great deal when they were there. And, of course, they worked together for many years in that butcher shop. So the loyalties are there, but at the same time, the twins will tell you that there is disagreement. There is animosity. There is friction. And they don't have that immediate understanding with the unrelated brother that they so quickly forged with the related brother whom they met for just a short time.

You've studied a number of other twins, twins raised together, twins raised apart, identical twins, fraternal twins. We'll talk about the science of twin research in the second half of our conversation and what this means in terms of parenting and other issues, but I want to look at a couple of other examples first. Tell me about the Jim twins.

Well, the Jim twins, Jim Lewis and Jim Springer, were identical twins born in Ohio and grew up about 30, 40 miles apart. And they met when they were 39 years old. One of the families had been told the other twin had died, but she later learned that was not the case. And the twins eventually decided it was time to meet, and they did.

I'm looking forward to meeting these next 2 gentlemen. You may have heard or read about my next guest. In 1979, just a few months after the twins first met— 18 months or They shared their story on The Tonight Show Starring Johnny Carson. Would you welcome, please, Jim Lewis and Jim Springer. The similarities were incredible. We both— well, Jim's been married 3 times. I've been married twice. His first wife, name the same as mine. His first wife is the same name as yours. And our second wives are both Linda.

They both married different women named Linda. They both divorced them and married women named Betty. And then one of the Jim twins divorced Betty and married Sandy. And so I imagine that Betty is a little nervous waiting in the wings to see what's going to happen.

We both named our first sons the same, James Allen. Oh, and we both named our dogs Toy.

And both of them had light blue Chevrolets. They both liked to vacation on the same 3-block strip of beach in Florida. And it's amazing they didn't meet there. They both used to bite their fingernails. They both used to scatter love letters around the house to their wives, and they both enjoyed woodworking. So their similarities went on for a long time. And what's interesting is that they were the ones who first launched the Minnesota Study of Twins Raised Apart, directed by Professor Thomas Bouchard at the University of Minnesota. And this pair got so much attention that other pairs suddenly came out of the woodwork. And before Bouchard knew it, he had 15 pairs in— Wow.

Now, of course, when you're a researcher and you're studying twins like this, it's difficult to distinguish between things that are actually points of connection and things that are coincidences. In other words, the fact they both married a woman named Linda might be a coincidence. It might have nothing to do with the fact they're identical twins. How do you go about distinguishing between those 2 things, telling the things that are coincidences from the things that you think actually are driven by some form of connection?

Yeah, well, first of all, let's say that maybe being attracted to women with a certain name is not random. We don't know that for sure. But the way we can distinguish coincidence from real scientific hard data that's got a genetic basis is that you compare identical twins with fraternal twins with reference to a particular attribute. Now, we had different kinds of quirky habits that we would see in some identical pairs. So, for example, one of the identical pairs always read books from back to front. And another identical pair, both twins used to scratch their ears with paperclips. So you can't start looking for paperclip scratching across pairs or for reading books back to front. What you can look for are matched unusual habits. And if you find matched unusual habits more often in identical twins than you do in fraternal twins, this gives you some clue that the genes may be driving that behavior, at least in part.

You looked at another pair of twins who had some remarkable things in common, including some of the behaviors you just described. Tell me about the Giggle Twins.

Oh, the Giggle Twins. They were from Great Britain. And when they met for the first time, they discovered that with each other, but with nobody else, they would giggle uncontrollably. They even did this to me once on a TV set, which was really irking the producers. But there was something about the other one that just set them off. But they also had other similarities in that, besides their identical appearance, they both had the same crooked pinky fingers. They both disliked politics. They both had a habit of sort of wrinkling their nose, something they both called squidging. So they had a number of similarities as well. But we called them the Giggle Twins because that was their hallmark feature.

When we come back, how twin studies reveal what makes us us and the complex dance between our genes and our environments. You're listening to Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedantam. Support for Hidden Brain comes from Stripe. Stripe is built for whatever comes next, because as your business scales, so does the complexity of fraud— new customers, new markets, new AI-driven attack patterns. Stripe Radar protects your business as it scales with the scale of the Stripe network. The more payments Stripe sees, the smarter its AI gets at detecting these patterns as they emerge. Stripe's network is so vast, it has seen $1.9 trillion in payment volume across millions of global businesses. In fact, when a card is used, there's a 92% chance the Stripe network has seen it before. All of this means fraudulent patterns across payments, accounts, and customer abuse can be detected, flagged, or blocked more easily, based on the rules you set up, of course. Blocking bad actors, welcoming good customers, keeping more of your revenue your revenue. Learn more about fighting fraud with Stripe at stripe.com/radar. Support for Hidden Brain comes from LinkedIn. Hiring for a small business is hard. LinkedIn Hiring Pro acts like a helpful hiring partner. Chat with it about what matters most, compare candidates side by side, and share feedback like, I want someone with more hands-on experience. HiringPro adjusts and surfaces candidates who fit your needs. Get started by posting your job for free at linkedin.com/hb. Terms and conditions apply.

Comcast Business is now offering advanced big business cybersecurity for small businesses with an AI-powered firewall Built right into your network connection. Switch to Comcast Business and get started for just $50 a month for 1 year on a qualifying internet package with 1 month of Security Edge Preferred on us. Plus, for a limited time, ask about a $500 prepaid card. Call today. Limited time offer. Restrictions apply. New customers only. Requires 300 megabits per second internet, Security Edge, Security Edge Preferred, and Wireless Connect. 1-year agreement. Paperless billing and automatic payments required. Equipment, taxes, and fees extra. After promo, regular rates apply.

This is Hidden Brain. I'm Shankar Vedantam. Psychologist Nancy Segal has made a career of studying unusual cases of twins. She says there's a specific genetic difference between fraternal and identical twins that influences the outcomes of twin studies.

Identical twins result when a single fertilized egg divides sometime between the 1st and 14th day after conception. So these twins share all their genes in common and are always of the same sex. Fraternal twins result when a woman releases 2 eggs at the same time and they are separately fertilized by 2 sperm from the father. So these twins share half the genes on average, just like ordinary brothers and sisters. So what we do is, as scientists, we gather large numbers of both types of pairs and we compare the similarities with respect to intelligence, personality, running speed, interests, food preferences, and In virtually every study that I've seen, identical twins tend to be more alike than fraternal twins, which suggests that the genes do play a role in the development of that trait. On the other hand, identical twins are never perfectly matched. There are always some differences. And so that becomes exciting because we can look to see what are those differences and what— how do we explain them? What environmental effects can we use? Now, Twin studies are not just for twins. That's a very important point. Twin studies are a model. They're a research paradigm for how we understand genetic and environmental influences on development in the population at large.

So there have been hundreds of studies looking at this idea. What does this body of research tell us, Nancy, about things like personality and intelligence, the things you just mentioned?

Yes, well, there have been a lot of studies in both of those areas, and we find that for intelligence, general ability, that that has about a 70% to 75% genetic influence. We find for personality closer to 50%. But let me be clear about what those numbers mean. It does not mean, say, that for personality, I could take a person and slice their extroversion or sociability into a genetic and environmental component. Not at all. Those are completely intertwined within individuals. What it does mean is that if I study personality in a population or a group, there's going to be variation from person to person. Not everybody's the same. About half those differences are explained by the genetic differences among the people, and about half the differences are explained by environmental differences.

In some ways, what you're pointing out is that the superficial take on what twin studies mean is actually perhaps not accurate in terms of depicting reality. I mean, when it comes to individuals, your environment can shape who you become in profound ways, just like your genes can shape who you've become in profound ways. You've in fact studied Identical twins who've turned out very different sometimes because of environmental differences that begin right in the womb.

That's right. There was a pair of twins I studied once who differed in height by 4 inches when they were 7 years old at the time that I studied them. And what happened in that case was that one of the girls, the one who was shorter, had a marginally attached placenta, which means that she did not get enough nutrition prenatally. As they grew up, I was shocked when I met them the first time because they looked like the same version of each other, but just one very small and one very big. And then when I went back to see them again in their young adult years, it turned out that the taller twin was 7 inches taller than the other one. So that was something that had a lasting imprint on these still identical genes.

Differences in the womb led these twins to look very different. Similarly, other environmental differences can act on 2 people with the same genes and reshape them dramatically. One of the best examples of this might be the Bogotá twins that Nancy studied. Consider, for example, one of the brothers who grew up in the wrong home, William. He was born to the city mother but raised on a farm. Even as a small child, He was studious and drawn to learning. But his circumstances put brakes on his natural inclinations. Opportunities for education in his poor farming village, Nancy says, were greatly limited.

They were not available, and so he decided to join the army. And in the army, once you complete your service, you are entitled to take some sort of officer's training course, and that seemed perfect for William. It would have meant going to school and being paid for by the government. But it turned out, unfortunately, that while he was in the service, he had contracted a disease called leishmaniasis. And while he recovered from it, that put him completely out of the running.

William's dream of getting an education through the Army was dashed. And by the time he discovered the truth about his origin, he had resigned himself to not getting a proper education. He had begun to work at the butcher shop in Bogotá. This is when the coworker of his identical twin, happened to stop by the shop. What happened in the years that followed is even more revealing about the power of the environment to reshape our genetic inheritance.

With William, there were just fewer opportunities he could even pick from. That was his trouble until he got down to Bogotá. Now, what's happened to William since then, and since he's met his brother Jorge, he is now enrolled in law school. in Bogotá. He's in his second year of it now. And with the help of Carlos, actually, who was not related to him genetically or environmentally, Carlos helped him research law schools. And now that's where he's looking to continue his education. He has political aspirations. He wants to go back to the town that he grew up in and become the mayor of the town.

Carlos was the other brother who grew up in the wrong home. He was born to the poor family from a rural area, but was raised in Bogotá. His life, too, was dramatically reshaped by living in the city.

Carlos is working as a financial analyst, having completed college and several advanced certificates. And he's very much a man about town. He loves nice clothes. He loves cultural activities. And for a long time, he had a lot of trouble with William, saying, well, why didn't William do this? And why didn't William do that? But he really didn't understand that there were no opportunities There just weren't any.

For an academic discipline, twin studies have drawn an extraordinary amount of controversy. There are debates about its central paradigm, which is that differences between identical twins and fraternal twins are explained by genes. But if families and teachers treat identical twins differently than they treat fraternal twins, Could some of the differences between the groups be driven by upbringing, nurture, rather than nature? Underlying many of these debates is an unease. If genes determine our intelligence and personality, what does this say about differences we see in society between people? Although we've seen how it's impossible to separate the effect of genes from the environment in any person, It's tempting to explain differences between people by pointing to their genes. Why is one person rich and another poor? Genes. Why do we see different outcomes in the workplace between a man and a woman? Genes. If biology explains intelligence, why bother with public education? After all, if we are smart, it's because of our genes. If we are dumb, it's because of our genes. I asked Nancy what she made of such arguments.

Well, that's a real misunderstanding of the way that the genes work because, after all, behavior is a function of genes being expressed in an environment. And by moderating or fixing the environment in different ways, you can alter gene expression. Now, some behaviors are harder to alter than others, but everybody can improve. Everybody can develop new skills and get better at that. People can't all be the same. We're not all the same. We're not all one big identical twin. But everybody probably has talents, interests, all kinds of abilities that are undiscovered because they've never had a chance to express them.

Just as people are wrong in thinking that genes determine everything about our lives, those who say the environment explains everything are also missing something crucial. The environments we find ourselves in are themselves shaped by the proclivities and propensities that are encoded in our genes. Especially when it comes to human behavior, nature and nurture really are inextricably intertwined.

Yes, exactly. We all pick certain items in our environment that are compatible with who we are. And so while one person might be drawn to dance lessons, one person to music, one person to art, these are the things that mean that we We fashion our environment. So environments, in a sense, are genetically influenced. And then within those environments, certain genetic propensities might be expressed.

So in some ways, what I'm hearing you say, Nancy, is that our genes indeed are very powerful in shaping us, but they're not necessarily deterministic. It's one thing to say that intelligence is heritable, but when you say, you know, 62.35% of your intelligence came from your genes, we might be guilty of false precision.

I agree with that. And I think that some of the fears people have had from this research is that once you've got your genes, you're stuck with them. And that's not really true. We are the ones who make decisions about what we will do, how hard we will work, how we will go about getting our goals. After all, genes are just propensities. They're not deterministic. I think that we can all take tremendous pride and happiness in those things that we accomplish.

I understand that you yourself have a twin?

That's correct. I have a fraternal twin sister, Anne. I'm the older twin by 7 minutes, but I'm also the shorter twin by 4 inches. And we are very different in our outlooks, in our appearance, in our talents, but we have a lot of family loyalty. And I think there's probably no one I love as much in my family as my sister.

Nancy Segal is professor of psychology at California State University, Fullerton, and the director of their Twin Studies Center. She's the author of Accidental Brothers: The Story of Twins Exchanged at Birth and the Power of Nature and Nurture. Nancy, thank you for joining me today on Hidden Brain.

It's been an absolute pleasure.

Hidden Brain is produced by Hidden Brain Media. Our audio production team includes Bridget McCarthy, Laura Quirrell, Kristen Wong, Ryan Katz, Autumn Barnes, and Andrew Chadwick. Tara Boyle is our executive producer. I'm Hidden Brain's executive editor. Our unsung hero today is Luis Clemens. Luis is an editor at NPR, and he cares deeply about opening doors for young journalists. When Hidden Brain was produced at NPR, I often saw Luis in the cafeteria helping interns craft cover letters and prepare for job interviews. Luis is a walking reminder of how we can all help change the trajectory of other people's lives. Thank you, Luis. For more ideas about human behavior, as well as brain teasers and moments of joy, Be sure to check out our weekly newsletter. You can subscribe at news.hiddenbrain.org. That's news.hiddenbrain.org. I'm Shankar Vedantam. See you soon. Thank you.

Pandora makes it easy for you to find your favorite music. Discover new artists and genres by selecting any song or album, and we'll make you a personalized station for free. Download on the Apple App Store or Google Play and enjoy the soundtrack to your life.

Hi, I'm Angie Hicks, co-founder of Angie. When you use Angie for your home projects, you know all your jobs will be done well. Roof repair? Done well. Kitchen sink install? Done well. Deck upgrades? Done well. Electrical upgrade? Done well. Angie's been connecting homeowners with skilled pros for nearly 30 years, so we know the difference between done and done well. Angie, the one you trust to find the ones you trust. Find a pro for your project at angie.com. When an intruder approaches a home, they expect a camera. What they don't expect—

Stop. This is SimpliSafe. Police are on the way. Using smart AI cameras, live US-based agents, help deter intruders in under 30 seconds.

Don't just record a break-in, stop it from ever happening. Plans starting around $1 a day. Right now, get 60% off your new system with professional monitoring at simplisafe.com/SXM. 30 seconds response time requires monitoring plan with outdoor protection starting at $49.99 a month.

Visit simplisafe.com/licenses for alarm license information. See something on the rack that caught your eye? The one you're not sure how to wear, or where, or with what? We've all been there. The good news? Someone here already knows exactly what to do with it. Just ask. You have a stylist at Maurice's.