Avery Carl - Connecting Investors Across the Nation with Great Short Term Rental Investments

Welcome back to the Short Term Rental Riches podcast. I'm happy you're all here again. We have an extra special guest today, Avery Carle. She's the Amazon best seller of short term rental long term wealth. A lot of you may have heard her on her show, the Short term Show, which is a fabulous podcast as well. She wears a lot of hats, so I'm excited to dive into it with her today. Welcome to the show, Avery.

Hey, thanks so much for having me.

Yeah, yeah. I'm excited to have you on today. I know you got a just vast knowledge and experience in the short term rental world. You want to give us a quick background?

Yes. Okay.

So I did not, as a kid, did not grow up saying, I want to be a real estate investor or real estate agent when I grow up. It kind of backed into it. I think, as most people end up doing.

Was working in the music business in Nashville for very little money. It's very glamorous, but they don't pay anything because there's always an intern willing to do it for free.

My husband and I, I guess, need to start a little further back. My husband and I, when we moved from New York City to Nashville, our real estate agent was really trying to get us to buy a house in this really hip, appreciating part of Nashville called East Nashville. And we said, no, thank you. We are moving from Brooklyn to Tennessee. We're tired of neighbors. We want to go out in the country. So we did, but we had a little bit of money left, and she'd made such a huge deal about all this appreciation that we were like, I don't know, maybe we should buy one of those and we should like, rent it out and the renters will pay the mortgage for us and we won't really have to pay anything. And then by the time our future kids need to go to college, we can just sell it and it will have appreciated enough that we can pay for it, their college with that instead of out of our own pockets. And I thought I was this genius, personal finance genius, totally stupid. But we did buy one. We bought a long term rental and luckily we got really lucky that it was a really good deal and it cash flowed about $1,000 over the mortgage every month, which when you did the. The math on what I was making a month, that was about what I was making after my paycheck deduction. So we went, wait a minute, we just doubled my income with this one house. We need to buy more of these. We need to make a business out of this. So then we started educating ourselves on real estate investing after we'd already made the huge purchase. Started listening to podcasts, reading all the books, and we had just enough.

Money for one more property for a down payment. And we said, what can we buy that's going to make us the most amount of money the fastest so that we can go buy more? And we landed on short term rentals. And we knew we did not want to do it in Nashville because the regulations already, even at that time in 2015, were too crazy and we couldn't afford to buy something and then be told we couldn't use it for that. So we just been on vacation to the Smoky Mountains, which is about three and a half hours east of Nashville, and. And we'd stayed in a cabin. Everybody else that was there was staying in cabins. So he said, somebody owns these cabins. Why can't it be us? And we'll figure out this self management thing remotely. Because at the time, the standard for that market was 40% of your gross. And we were like, we can't afford that. We need that 40%. We've got more real estate to buy. And so we kind of figured out this was before.

Any. There was no podcast, there was no. There was to get paid for your path. That was it. Um, there was no gurus, there were no courses, there were no Facebook groups. So we just kind of had to, like, figure it out as we went. That very first one went really well. Yeah. Back in the day, had to go uphill in the snow both ways. First one went well, scaled that to five over about a year and a half. Five and a half years later, we've got 250 doors, no partners. Eight of them are short terms. The rest are single family, multifamily, long term. I'm a big believer in a diverse portfolio.

Me too.

Yeah. Started the short term shop on our second purchase because we realized there weren't really any agents in the space who could answer our questions about this specific type of investing. So our first market was in the Smokies, and Now we've got 70 agents across 20 markets in the country. And if you buy with us. Yeah. We teach you how to manage it for free while you're still under contract. So by the time you close, you're ready to go. You already know what's going on. You're not floundering around with a $500,000 investment. You're, like, ready to turn the key and rock. So.

Awesome. Yeah, awesome, awesome story. Awesome to see you practicing what or preaching what you practice and also great to see that you have a diverse portfolio. I think a lot of people in the industry are, a lot of times people really niche down and it's the only thing they do. I also believe that having a diverse portfolio is a good idea. Not just one asset class, but across multiple markets, even so. So you guys have eight of those are short term rentals, you said, out of your current portfolio. Okay, are they all. Do you mind telling us a little bit more about those? Are they all the same type, like vacation rentals? Are they in the same areas or.

Yeah, so we like to stick to the vacation rental niche of short term rentals. So what I mean by that is in vacation markets that are depend on that, tourism that are dependent on short term rentals. So in areas where there's not a lot of hotel presence. So we have five cabins in the Smoky Mountains in Tennessee. So in and around Gatlinburg, Pigeon Forge, Sevierville, Wares Valley, everything from a studio to a five bedroom. We've got three across the panhandle of Florida, two single families. One of them is a four bedroom with a pool in Destin, Florida. The other single family is a four bedroom, one house off the beach in Cape Sandblast, Florida. And then the last one is actually a mixed use building that's commercial on the bottom, which is, I'm actually sitting in it. It's my office on the bottom. But the top is a, a three bedroom condo.

Okay, very cool. Do you have a, do you have a favorite among those?

I think the four bedroom in Destin is my favorite. That one was a real turning point in our portfolio. We were able to get a really good deal on it. It had been foreclosed on twice and the second person that it was foreclosed on had already, they were flipping it or rehabbing it. And they'd already done all the really expensive hard work. So all that was left for us to do after they ran out of money was cosmetic. So we were able to get a really good deal on it. And, and it is a really great property. It's. It's a beach house, but it's kind of like uniquely shaped and cool looking and it's bright blue. And that one really like the, the income versus the purchase price versus what that property did for us income wise in terms of being able to expand our portfolio makes it my favorite.

Yeah. Yeah. Awesome. It's nice to find those properties to where a lot of the hard work's already done. I mean you get into some of These monster renovations, and that's when you start losing hair and it turns colors. And I've. I've been there as well, so. Well, let's see. A lot of ways we can go with this conversation. I guess it'd be interesting to dive into it since you guys have so many agents and you help so many owners buy properties, and we are in sort of different economic times, but I think the bright side of it is that we are in a buyer's market, which we haven't been in for forever. Right. So do you mind just filling us in on kind of how you. How you see things out there at the moment?

Yeah. Yeah. So I'll tell you like I tell our clients. Yeah, the interest rates are high right now. There's no disputing that. But they're just a line item on your spreadsheet like any other expense. And the good thing about the interest rates being so high is they've scared off all the amateurs. So two years ago, when we had new clients come in to our office, I would say, hey, guys, you know, you're going to have to go in here and offer, like, 50,000, 100,000 over asking immediately on every single property. You don't have time to analyze. You analyze. After you get the contract, you don't have time to do anything because there were a thousand people offering on every property, and things were going in, like, 30 seconds. So now, because. And that's, you know, when the interest rates were 2 and 3% and everybody could buy one. So now that the interest rates are higher, you have the space and time to really think through the property, analyze it, find opportunities to increase its income. Before you make the offer, figure out exactly what number works best for you. You can ask for closing costs to be paid. You can negotiate purchase prices. You can do all of those things to get better deals because all the amateurs are out of here there, you know, all the people that just were buying these things not as. Weren't looking at them as the business that they are, just looking at them as, like, a cool way to impress their friends. And let me just slap this up on Airbnb and get rich when I'm not using it. It's not real life. So all those guys are gone, and the real investors who are really willing to do the work are all that's left. So you have a lot of opportunity to get really great deals as an investor.

Yeah, yeah, definitely. It's nice to not have to make a decision.

Under all that pressure. I mean, those are crazy times that we're under. It's nice to be able to ask for things that are broken to be fixed, you know, and we're.

So with all that said, I, I mean, what are your opinions on sort of the supply side of things? I sort of think that yeah, we are in a buyer's market, it's a great time, but there's maybe not as many people buying. So for those of us that already have short term rentals, I think if we, we hold strong and we learn to understand like the new economy that we're in, that we're going to still do really well because there's still a lot of demand for short term rentals. Do you have some, some thoughts on that?

Yeah, yeah. So I think that on the owner side of things that now the difference is really in optimizing your management having great amenities and your decor. So, you know, five, six years ago you could buy an old grandma cabin and slap it up because there weren't really a lot of sophisticated operators in the market just yet. And so now there's a lot of people who have really done their homework, who are really good at managing their properties. So the bar has been raised a little bit and I think the people who have not raised their property with that bar are the ones that are seeing the real declines. So I, I don't think that there's going to be any sort of short term rental crash in certain markets. There may be in some markets because real estate is really market specific, it's not nationwide. So in areas that are the areas that I try to stick to as an investor and with the short term shop are typically true vacation markets that are dependent on people staying in short term rentals, not a lot of hotel presence. It's been the normal thing for people to come to these areas and stay in short term rentals for decades and decades. So it's not that, I mean, in some areas, yes, but it's not that there's all these brand new short term rentals that were not short term rentals before flooding the market necessarily. A lot of the growth that we're seeing in supply, you know, it's coming from data sources like air DNA, which is a great source, but it can only measure what's on Airbnb and VRBove. In a lot of these markets there were thousands and thousands of short term rentals that were just on these big archaic old school property management companies that have been around since the 60s that this is how they run their business, that's how they're still running their business and they're not on Airbnb and vrbo. So as those properties have been sold to newer, more sophisticated investors that are converting them from that management, those types of management companies onto Airbnb and vrbo, you're seeing, I think the growth numbers are a little inflated because of that, because they weren't, they were short term rentals already. They were a part of the inventory. They just weren't measurable, they couldn't be tracked because they weren't on those platforms and now they can. So anyway, long story to make a long story long.

No, no, no, that's a great point. Yeah, I like the stability in these vacation rental markets like you said. I mean they're vacation rental markets and they've been that way for a long time and that's how the local economies thrive. Right. So the risk of having regulations change and prevent is a lot lower than it is in like an urban city for example, sometimes. So one of the challenging things in some of these vacation rental markets I've seen though, at least for individual homeowners, are their property management options. Because a lot of times there is like that one property manager that just dominated the market and they charge 20, 30, 40% and they can do a really good job. And now that we have so much access to all these OTAs, there are other options available. And I know, or as you said, you guys are self managing, I think this is something you guys teach about too. So do you mind shedding some light on the self management side of things compared to a traditional property manager?

Yeah, absolutely. So we started self managing because we could, we needed that money, we needed to cut costs wherever we could so that we could keep it and buy more properties. So I think that depending on where a person is in their investment career in their life will determine whether or not a property manager or self management is right for them. Most of the people that come to us just by design are people that want to self manage. So I call it growth phase versus cruise phase or growth mode versus cruise mode. If you're in growth mode where you're really trying to squeeze every last dollar out of all your properties, whether it's short term, long term, whatever, so you can scale and grow, that's probably the time for self management in terms of if you're, if you're already like, okay, you know what, I've got enough properties, I'm kind of tired of messing with this stuff, I'm in cruise mode, then that's probably a good time for a property manager. Now in vacation markets. When I first started, all the property managers were like Airbnb.

What?

That's kids stuff. And they know Airbnb. Every now and then they'd be on vrbo and they were only relying on direct bookings to their website. And a lot of times these guys were not like using SEO or anything like that to get. They're just hoping that you find Uncle Ricky's cabins.com because your grandmother came here. And so now through the whole.

Kind of emergence of self management has also come a newer type of property manager who understands why an owner might not want to go use one of those big property management companies. And they understand what it's like to be a self manager and the proper tools to use to optimize the listings. And they're kind of like a, they're now becoming property managers, but they have a much better hold on what's going on in technology now and what gets bookings and how to optimize than a lot of those, those big old dinosaur guys. So I think the whole, you know, the emergence of self management has kind of created a newer type of property manager that is better and more optimized and, and able to fill those gaps that the older school property management companies either couldn't or don't care to.

Yeah, no, great point. I, I mean, I, I think of myself as a techie guy, used to work for a software company and I can't even keep up with all the software options, you know, and so some of these older establishments, you know, unless they have a big team devoted to that, it's hard to decide what tools to use. Now I know there's a whole bunch of programs out there. I'm just curious, do you have like a favorite, maybe not necessarily the most important software tool you use, but just like a favorite?

We use Hospitable and Price Labs and touchstay.

Okay.

So, you know, three do three different things, but those are our key components there.

Right? Okay. I use the Price Labs one. We've talked about that quite a bit on, on this channel before. Pricing obviously is very important. Right? I mean, we can have a perfect property, but if it's not priced right, people aren't going to be booking it or at least not booking it too often. And actually in your book you talk about affordability and I, I think affordability is really important. I mean, a lot of people in the US economy are getting squeezed or really around the world with inflation. And do you mind talking about affordability and how that, that plays into how Someone might want to make a decision on where they're purchasing a vacation rental.

Yeah, yeah. So I typically divide my vacation markets into two types, so blue chip markets and emerging markets. So your blue chip markets are going to be the areas that are. They are great places to own vacation rentals. Always have been, probably always will be. You're going to see really, really, really high gross annual income numbers there. But you're also going to pay quite a bit to buy a property in those markets because of that. So places like the Smokies, Destin, Florida, Broken Bows becoming one of those.

And then you have what I call emerging markets. And they're not emerging in terms of tourists finding them. These are still mature vacation rental markets where tourists have always gone, but they're emerging in terms of there's not a lot of sophisticated managers there yet. So maybe they're, they're smaller markets and some of them are not necessarily smaller vacation markets. So.

Like western North Carolina would be a good emerging market. Cape Sandblast, where I bought my most recent one, would be a good emerging one. But the problem with those, they are more affordable. You're. But you're not going to see a lot of great data because the reason they're emerging is that the majority of the properties are still on those dinosaur property managers like Kick Sandblast, like something like 85% of the properties are still on 1 to 2 property management companies that have been there since the 80s. And you can tell their website is not like sleek at all. So because of that, there's not a lot of great data. So you're kind of trading that lower price point for there not being a lot of data. But there's a lot of opportunity in those types of markets because they are more affordable. The Smokies was one back when I started buying in 2015. But now, you know, the cat is very much out of the bag. A lot of really sophisticated operators have moved in. So, you know, it's not what I would call emerging anymore. But looking for those emerging markets, the price points are going to be a little lower, the income data is going to be a little lower. But you know, that's the trade off that you have and lower price point versus, you know, where the interest rates are right now.

Yeah, yeah, great, great points. There.

A couple things I sort of want to dig into, I guess. One is like when we don't have a lot of data, how we can really educate ourselves to get a fairly accurate idea of what that property might do. You guys talk about or in Your book, you talked about the Enemy method, which is a very catchy name. So stuck. Do you mind just breaking that down real quickly kind of what, what that is?

Yeah, absolutely. So you can have the best data in the world. Data can tell you what a property is doing, but it can't tell you why a property is doing that. So it can say this four bedroom is doing this amount, but without looking at it and looking at the other properties around it or your enemies, you kind of can't tell whether that's underperforming. Is that over performing? Is that about where it needs to be? So, so you're using the Enemy method to look at what your enemies are doing and how your property could outperform or maybe not perform as well. So, you know, if, if your data says this property makes this much, but you go look at it and the P in the pictures, the paint's like peeling off and the windows are broken and it's missing shingles and the yard looks like crap. Well, you know, that's not the best it can do because it looks like crap. And if you spruced up the outside, it would do better. So basically you're using the Enemy method to kind of run comps and see where on that data spectrum that you have a property that you're looking at might fall. Because there's a lot of intangibles that go into how much a property could make other than just the data. Like can I add X, Y and Z amenities or does it already have that? What are the ways that I can improve this to get this to the number that I want it to be at versus where it's performing right now?

Yeah, great point. I, we talk a lot about comp sets and that's, that's pretty much what that is, right? Your, your enemies are your comps and we need to understand them as best as possible to have the most accurate picture of, of what we're kind of getting into. So super, super important for anyone out there looking at getting a market. We want to make sure we know what the possibilities are there and what opportunities we have. Another thing, Avery, that I think playing into the affordability and sort of the migrations across the US is our ability to work remotely now. People are more virtual than ever. I really like the fact that people are living in Airbnbs now or they're at least staying there for much longer. I think that it's just, it's kind of the way things are going. I know it impacts certain types of short term rentals differently. Than other like urban properties, for example. It's much easier or much more common, I guess you could say, to see the, the much longer extended stays. Are you guys seeing.

Since you focus mainly on vacation type markets, are you guys seeing those reservation links extend a little bit as well?

So we don't get as many of the digital nomad types as we just get like families on vacation. I'm sure there are some, you know, that I haven't just drilled down on that data, but for us personally, we're all vacations all the time.

Yeah, gotcha. Okay, well, people always want to take vacations. I don't think that's ever going to go away. Right. Doesn't mean we always can, but we're always going to want to, I think. And a lot of times in a down economy too, people, they maybe jump off that very top tier of vacations or the most luxurious travel options and maybe they settle for something kind of like a little less than that. Do you have some thoughts on that and how that might play out in some of these more like higher end vacation rental markets?

Yeah. Yeah. So in the blue chip markets that we focus on, they're still cheaper. So we'll, we'll take like the Smokies, for example, or like Panama City Beach. So the Smokies is always going to be cheaper than going to Aspen or Vail or Breckenridge or any of that stuff because it's. Most of the tourists are driving in. Same thing with Panama City Beach. It's a lot. It might not necessarily be cheaper than Mexico prices, but it's less of a hassle if you live in the Southeast to just drive four or five hours, go to the beach at Panama City beach, then fly to Mexico. So in a potential downturn where people, you know, maybe wages have decreased or maybe they're a little tighter on money, they may not be taking those Aspen trips, but they will still be able to drive to like the Smokies or Shenandoah or somewhere like that where it's not as big of an expense on travel, but it's still a mountain vacation. So we try to focus on that and on regional drivable because it's still always going to be more affordable than those big, huge, like Hawaii destination vacations where the whole family has got to get flights, you got to get there, it's a huge deal. Or you can just, you know, drive to the Florida Panhandle and call it a day.

Yeah, no, no, excellent point. Gosh, you cut out just the airfare and then if you think of this in terms of like a family going there and there's five people in the family and you, you chop out five flights and they settle for a drive to destination like you're talking about, that's a huge savings. I can't believe how expensive flights are sometimes these days. It's, it's, it's crazy.

Well, really good, really good points there. I think one of the most important pieces of being successful with a real estate investment, finding the right property. And of course you guys have been helping lots and lots of people do that. So do you mind telling us a little bit about the short term shop and what you guys do and how you can help some people in our audience?

Yeah, absolutely. So we are a team of real estate agents across 20 markets where the all we do are short term rentals. So we don't even take clients who want to buy a primary home or sell a primary home or a long term rental. We only do short term rentals. Most of our agents are short term rental owners. If they're not, they're on their way to being that. But we are all just live, eat, sleep and breathe short term rentals. So basically what we do, when buyers come to us, we have a little consultation call. We talk about what markets might be best and let them, you know, figure out some questions because you know, sometimes there are your price point, like what you want to spend is a lot of times going to determine which market. So if you want a single family on the beach, Destin, Florida is probably not the place for you unless you want to spend $5 million, at which point the investment may not make sense. But you know, maybe we scoot over to Carolina Beach, North Carolina and now that single family on the BE makes sense. So we'll have a consultation call, kind of figure those things out. Then we'll get you with one of our specialized agents in the market. So you want to buy in. We'll help you choose the right market. We teach you how to analyze. We don't analyze for you because there's just too many variables. And like we could never, no one can really account for the X factor of anyone else. So we help you through that and then we teach you how to manage your property. So most of the clients that come to us want to self manage. And so we've got a whole backend program, we call it Management Mondays where our clients can go and learn how to manage their property. They learn everything from how to set up their Airbnb and VRBO listings to how to use the property management software to, you know, getting help sourcing their local, local boots on the ground, cleaners, handyman, etc. And we do it all while you're still under contract. So by the time closing date rolls around, you're already confident you know what you're doing. You're not like, oh my God, what do I do? I've just closed on this expensive house and I don't know how to run this thing. You already know all those things. And then we provide support for you basically forever. So if you ever run into a guest problem that you don't know the answer to, you can come to us. We've got a private Facebook group with a bunch of all of our past clients helping each other and us helping them. So, you know, it's a community and we're here to make sure everyone else is successful as well. So that's. That's what we do.

That's awesome. It's a one stop shop, right?

Pretty much. And you guys obviously have tons and tons of experience. If anyone out there hasn't heard Avery's podcast yet, I highly, highly suggest it. Lots of great info, a lot of great interviews, a lot of good information.

Let's see here. Well, shoot. Let me ask you one other thing, Avery. The title of this podcast is Short Term Rental Riches. And a lot of times when someone thinks of the word riches, they sort of think of the financial side of it. But that's not all that life is about, obviously, right, people, there's lots of rich people that aren't happy. So is there one thing in your life or something that you've changed in your lifestyle recently that's enriched your life, but not in a financial way.

Well, really just the ability to stop working when my kids are out of school. So when they get out of class every day at 2, I'm there to pick them up. So they're the ability to be able to give them the stay at home parent experience while still having a job and bringing in income has been really, really invaluable because, you know, they're only little for so long. And so investing in real estate and short term rentals has given me the ability to do that. Like, I picked my daughter up from theater camp the other day and she goes, would you like to go see a movie with me? She's four. I was like, hell yeah, I want to go see a movie with you. Let's go see a movie. We went across the street to see a movie. So, you know, real estate investing has given me the ability to do that for them. And that's, you know, irreplaceable at that time.

Definitely, Definitely. That's. That is. That's the goal, right? Leaving the rat race and having. And having that flexibility. Well, I want to thank you, Avery, for coming on. Tons of great insight. I'd love to have you on again in the future. I know the industry is just changing really, really quickly. We'll make sure that we have all of your contact information, our show notes and everything. But any last words before we jump off?

I don't think so. Thank you so much for having me. I hope to have you on my podcast soon. And thanks again.

Awesome. Thanks.

I've dedicated years figuring out how to.

Manage my personal portfolio remotely. And a while it wasn't always easy.

And it took a long time. But now my amazing team can professionally manage my properties without me. And good news, our team can also manage yours. Let us save you the stress and headaches and some money by offering you an industry low fee. To find out more about partnering with us, head to Strike the property management button, answer a couple quick questions and meet with me personally. That's strrices.com rest easy knowing that with my team, your properties will be in excellent hands.