End Bedtime Battles For Good
12 Nov 2025 · 1 min
Dr. Cathryn Tobin explains why kids fight bedtime: their nervous system triggers cortisol and adrenaline at separation. She offers concrete tactics like the "connection cup" metaphor, family photos, transitional objects, and naming feelings to calm kids before bed. Most families see fewer callbacks within a few nights.
Chapters
Smokey the Bear. Smokey the Bear. Then you know why Smokey tells you when he sees you passing through, remember, please be careful, it's the least that you can do. Don't play with matches, don't play with fire. After 80 years of learning his wildfire prevention tips, Smokey Bear lives within us all. Learn more at SmokeyBear.com and remember, only you can prevent wildfires. Brought to you by the USDA Forest Service, your state forester, and the Ad Council. Wee-hoo, wee-hoo!
And Doug, there's nowhere I wouldn't go to help someone customize and save on car insurance with Liberty Mutual, even if it means sitting front row at a comedy show.
Hey, everyone, check out this guy and his bird. What is this, your first date?
Oh, no. We help people customize and save on car insurance with Liberty Mutual together. We're married.
Ah!
Me to a human, him to a bird.
Yeah, the bird looks out of your league anyways.
Only pay for what you need at LibertyMutual.com. Liberty, liberty, liberty.
Liberty, liberty. You know the moment when you almost make it to the couch? The kids are upstairs in their beds. You've done the whole bedtime routine—books, snuggles, the lullaby which you've started to hate. You're holding it together, which is a gold star to you. You're already picturing it—feet up, trashy TV, maybe some Halloween candy leftovers you don't have to share. But then one of the the kids need some more water, or different water, or the nightlight's too bright, or it's not bright enough. And by the time you reach the top of the stairs, you hear it: "Mommy! Mommy!" And you know if you leave, they're gonna lose it. So you don't leave, and the couch stays empty yet again. Now, if bedtime separation feels like a Supreme Court negotiation with a kid in footie pajamas, Well, you're not alone. In today's episode, we're unpacking why bedtime feels so hard, what's actually going on when your child clings, stalls, or falls apart the second you try to leave, and what you can do to make bedtime calmer, happier, and shorter. So let's get into it. Welcome to Toddlers Made Easy, the podcast that keeps things short, simple, and supportive because parenting doesn't leave much time for fluff. I'm Dr. Cathryn Tobin, pediatrician. Actually, I've just retired. Mom of 4 grown kids and your guide in Big Hearted Parenting. I've walked this road from toddlerhood to adulthood, and I'm here to share what truly works in the long run. You know those callbacks, the endless requests? Suddenly your kids need water, a hug, a snack, the potty, or maybe to tell you something that happened 3 weeks ago. Well, believe it or not, that's not really defiance. That's biology. Here's what's happening. Your child's body is resisting sleep because separating from you naturally triggers discomfort. All day long, they're within arm's reach of you, following you from room to room. And from an evolutionary standpoint, a child alone in the dark equals danger. And their nervous system hasn't really evolved much past that ancient wiring. So when it's time to separate, their brain sounds the alarm. Cortisol rises, adrenaline kicks in, and what looks like defiance is really their body just trying to feel safe. Now add this: the later bedtime drags on, the more wired they become. The giggles? Well, that's their nervous system burning off stress. The running? It's a way to discharge extra energy. And the endless talking? It's a final plea for connection before separation. Your child isn't really trying to make your life harder, although it can feel that way, but their brain is doing exactly what it's built to do. And here's the thing, telling them, you're fine, sweetheart, go to sleep. Well, it doesn't work. Not because they don't want to listen, but because the part of their brain that handles logic and impulse control, it isn't fully developed. And a dysregulated nervous system has to feel safe before it can relax. So instead of fighting biology, let's work with it. When bedtime becomes less about control and more about connection, your child's brain can relax. And that's when you get the peaceful goodnights everybody wants. So here's how to do it. Overfill their connection cup before lights out. Think of the cup like an emotional gas tank. If it's running on empty when you say goodnight, they'll keep coming back to fill it up one request at a time. But if you fill it up before you leave the room, the callbacks ease dramatically. So let me walk you through 4 simple ways to do this. The first way is to create a visual connection. And so place some family photos where your child can see you from their bed. Choose happy, smiling moments so they feel your presence even in the dark. Number 2 is give them a companion. If your child is old enough, encourage a transitional object, a blankie or a stuffed animal. Frame it as a friend. Hey, Honey Bunny is going to stay with you all night. She'll keep you company while Mommy and Daddy are in their bedroom. Transitional buddies help kids feel less alone. Not every child is instantly comforted by one, but in another episode, I'm going to share a sweet way to encourage that bond. Number 3 is you can help your child to feel seen and understood. Before you leave the room, say something like, "You're sad we won't see each other till morning. I'll miss you too, and that's because we love each other so much." When you name the feeling, your child feels understood and the callbacks fizzle out. And then do the one last thing before your final goodnight. Give them a choice. Would you like one last hug? One last sip of water? One last story? One last trip to the bathroom? One thing, your choice. It gives your kids agency and it fills their cup one more time. They get to choose. They get what they needed and their brain can relax. Make your final moments with your child in their room. Loving, warm, calm, and filled with gratitude. What was the best part of your day, sweetheart? Now let's talk about those nights when your kids are already buzzing, giggling, zooming, can't sit still, energy everywhere. Well, instead of stop jumping and go to bed, which is like asking the body to do the impossible, try this. Let's shake the day out together. Then literally shake your bodies, wiggle, jump, dance it out for 30 seconds. You're helping them release energy on purpose. Or you could say, 5 deep breaths, then lights out. Let's do it together. And then do your big breath in and your long breath out. You're co-regulating their nervous system in real time. Or, wanna snuggle before sleep? Physical closeness helps calm your child. That bonding hormone is released that naturally lowers stress. These small shifts meet your child's nervous system where it is, and then you can gently guide them towards calm. And a calm body follows a calm nervous system, not a command. Now, what I want you to remember is that bedtime isn't about defiance. It's your child's brain making one less call for safety. And when you respond with connection instead of control, You're able to shift things. Will it be a perfect night every night? Of course not. Some nights are just hard. You're tired, probably more like exhausted. Actually, a vet recently told me to not let my dog lick his open wound. Well, the stores were closed. I was babysitting my granddaughter and I didn't have a car seat anyways. So asking my dog not to lick his wound was like asking a toddler not to press the elevator button. The advice stuck with me though. It made me rethink the kind of advice I give to parents every day, because I never want to hand you something that sounds good but isn't really doable. So realistically, you won't always stay calm when your child resists bedtime. You have a nervous system too, but it's a lot easier when you understand what's happening and you can see bedtime through your child's perspective. That's what big-hearted parenting is all about. Not pretending or forcing yourself to be calm, but actually feeling calm because you're informed and you're grounded. And here's the best part: when parents try this, most will see fewer callbacks within a few nights. Bedtime gets smoother, resistance drops, because at the end of the day, your child needs to feel safe enough to relax. You're helping your child's nervous system learn, "I'm okay when Mommy or Daddy isn't right here," and that's huge. And that's growth, and that's because of you. Now, if you want more strategies like this, you know, the kind that actually work because they're grounded in developmentally smart strategies, well, check out the Toddlers Made Easy course. It's packed with practical tools for the moment that matter most. Have a lovely week and happy parenting.
More from Dr.


The Hardest Moments After Bringing Home a New Baby... and How to Help Your Toddler Through Them


When Potty Training Goes Sideways. Your toughest potty training questions, answered




