In this solo podcast episode, pediatrician and parent Dr. Cathryn Tobin addresses the common problem of toddlers waking parents at 2 a.m. She explains why night awakenings are developmentally normal and why the usual “go back to bed” response often fails. Drawing on research by sleep physician Avi Sadeh, Dr. Tobin introduces the “Midnight Helper” or Comfort Buddy approach: a new stuffed animal that the child is tasked with comforting when it “feels scared” at night. She walks listeners through a step‑by‑step implementation—choosing a new, slightly sad‑looking plush, introducing it during the day with a story, incorporating a bedtime tuck‑in ritual, rehearsing the comforting actions, and giving a brief reminder before leaving the room. The episode also covers common parent concerns (child still calling, lack of connection with the toy) and offers practical responses. Dr. Tobin reports that families often see a reduction in night visits within a few nights and invites listeners to a masterclass on broader sleep strategies. The episode is framed with brief sponsor messages before moving into the instructional content.
Chapters
Smokey the Bear. Smokey Bear. Then you know why Smokey tells you when he sees you passing through, remember, please be careful, it's the least that you can do. Don't play with matches, don't play with fire. After 80 years of learning his wildfire prevention tips, Smokey Bear lives within us all. Learn more at SmokeyBear.com and remember, only you can prevent wildfires. Brought to you by the USDA Forest Service, your state forester, and the Ad Council. And Doug, there's nowhere I wouldn't go to help someone customize and save on car insurance with Liberty Mutual, even if it means sitting front row at a comedy show. Hey everyone, check out this guy and his bird. What is this, your first date? Oh no, we help people customize and save on car insurance with Liberty Mutual together. We're married. Me to a human, him to a bird. Yeah, the bird looks out of your league anyways. Only pay for what you need at libertymutual.com. Liberty, liberty, liberty. Welcome back to Toddlers Made Easy, the podcast that keeps it short, simple, and supportive because parenting a toddler doesn't leave you much time for fluff. I'm Dr. Cathryn Tobin, pediatrician, parent of 4 now grown children, and your guide in big-hearted parenting. Having navigated the full journey from toddlerhood to adulthood, I'm here to share what truly works in the long run. I remember those nights all too well, standing exhausted in my child's room at 2 a.m. for the third night in a row. Go back to bed, I'd whisper, trying not to sound too frustrated. Now, if this scene sounds familiar, today's episode is especially for you. I'm sharing a big-hearted strategy that transformed our nighttime interruptions years ago, and it's so simple simple, you can start tonight. I call it the Midnight Helper approach, and by the end of this bite-sized episode, you'll have a practical tool to help your little one feel secure enough to stay in bed when those middle-of-the-night wake-ups happen. Looking back now with adult children, I can tell you these sleep foundations really do matter. So let's dive in. A good place to begin is to consider what's happening during those 2:00 AM wake-up calls. Toddlers aren't waking up just to test our patience, although it certainly can feel that way, but the reality is much more understandable. Waking up in the night can feel genuinely scary for a little one. Everything looks different in the dark. Shadows make familiar objects seem strange. The house makes unfamiliar sounds. And sometimes children just feel unsure without you there. Because if you think about it, it's really the only time they're actually without an adult present. Most importantly, young kids don't yet have the skills to calm themselves down when their feelings get big. And that's completely normal for their developmental stage. Now, the traditional approach of repeatedly saying, go back to bed, often doesn't work because it doesn't address the underlying need. And that's why your child keeps getting up night after night despite bribes or despite begs and pleading. Your child isn't necessarily being defiant. They're just looking for some comfort and security. But there's a beautifully simple technique that's backed by research that can transform these wake-ups into stay-in-bed moments without you having to get up multiple times at night or without your child sneaking into your bed or asking to come and get in your bed. Now, this is a strategy I've seen work not just with my own children, but with countless families in my pediatric practice over the years. And this approach was actually developed and researched by a doctor by the name of Avi Sadeh. And forgive me if I'm not saying his name correctly. He's a renowned sleep physician who found that helping children feel a sense of purpose during nighttime wakeups significantly reduces their anxiety and helps them return to sleep more readily. And here's how it works. Choose a new stuffed animal to be your child's special nighttime comfort buddy. The key is that this should be a new stuffed animal, one that hasn't been part of their bedtime routine before. So if you can find one, a stuffed animal, particularly one that looks a little sad, this is ideal. And you'll understand why in a moment. So you're going to frame this stuffed animal as a little being who also sometimes feels scared at night, just like you, and needs some comfort. This simple shift is going to give your child an important job. Instead of focusing on their own fears in the night, they get to be the brave one who provides comfort to someone else. And it's a powerful way to help your toddler feel more in control and capable during those nighttime moments. So toddlers are kind and they're giving little people and they want to help others. So this kind of support will come naturally to them. So let me explain this in a little bit more detail. During the day, not at bedtime when everyone's tired, but during the day, present the stuffed animal to your child with a little story. You might say something like, look, I want you to meet Hippo. He sometimes feels a little scared at night because he's away from all of his family and friends and he becomes a little scared and even a little sad. Do you think you could help him feel better by giving him hugs and maybe even telling him a story if he wakes up feeling scared or sad? What you're doing here is you're tapping into your child's natural kindness and compassion. Toddlers really love to help and take responsibility, and they truly do take this job seriously. They feel proud to be the one who can comfort their new friend. Now, this approach works because it shifts the dynamics entirely. Instead of your child feeling helpless and needing you, they get to be the helper, the brave one who can make someone else feel better. Once you've introduced the comfort buddy during the daytime, it's time to incorporate it into your bedtime routine. So make tucking in the comfort buddy or the stuffed animal a special part of your nightly ritual. This should be a consistent, predictable part of getting ready for sleep. You might say something like, "Let's go tuck in Hippo because it's bedtime. He needs a hug and a goodnight kiss." Then have your child give Hippo a hug and a kiss goodnight. This establishes the pattern of comforting actions that your child can repeat if they wake up in the middle of the night. So next, practice what to do if Hippo wakes up scared. "Let's practice what you'll do if Hippo wakes up feeling scared or sad in the night. Can you show me how you'll give him a big hug and maybe tell him it's still nighttime and everything is okay?" Have your child physically go through the motions of hugging the stuffed animal and whispering comforting words. This rehearsal helps them feel prepared and it builds their confidence, and it's muscle memory. Finally, as you're leaving the room, give a gentle reminder: "Remember, if Hippo wakes up feeling scared tonight, you know exactly how to help him feel better. You can give him a big hug and tell him everything is okay." This approach works on multiple levels where simply saying "go back to bed" often fails. First, it acknowledges that nighttime can feel scary, validating your child's feelings instead of dismissing them. Second, it gives your child agency. They're not helpless in the face of scary things. They have a specific job they can do. And third, it creates a lovely physiological shift. In comforting their stuffed animal, children actually end up comforting themselves. The words they say to Hippo—it's okay, I'm here, it's still nighttime—are precisely the reassuring words they need to hear. And fourth, it breaks the habit of needing you to come into their room multiple times at night to comfort them. They have their own solution right there in bed with them. Parents in our community have reported that this approach starts working within just a few nights. One mom told me her daughter went from calling out 3 to 4 times each night to staying in bed with her special bunny whom she would comfort back to sleep. So let's address a couple of questions that might come up. What if my child still calls for me? Well, if this happens, keep your response brief and redirect back to their special job. Remember, Hippo needs you to help him feel safe. Can you give him a big hug? I'll check on you both in a few minutes. And then wait a few minutes before checking back. Often you'll find your child has gone back to sleep. What if your child doesn't connect with the stuffed animal? Well, try involving them in choosing the comfort buddy or frame it differently. This is Hippo's first night in a new home. He's feeling a little nervous. Can you help him feel welcome? Find the story that resonates with your child's interests and personality. So here's the takeaway for today. Nighttime wake-ups are normal and can be managed without tears and with less frustration. The Comfort Buddy approach transforms these moments by giving your child the empowering role of comforter rather than the person needing comfort. This research-backed strategy works because it addresses the underlying need for security while teaching self-soothing skills. And remember, if this strategy doesn't work perfectly the first night, stay consistent, keep trying. Learning new bedtime habits, it takes time for toddlers and really for anyone. But with persistence, you'll start seeing fewer midnight visits to your bedroom. Now, if you'd like more sleep strategies like this one, I have a lovely masterclass called Help Your Child Fall Asleep Without You. It's a complete guide to establishing bedtime routines that actually work. There's no crying it out whatsoever. Soever. You'll find a link to it in the show notes. Thank you for being here today. Sweet dreams to you and your little ones. And until next time, stay big-hearted.
