Looks Ready But Refusing the Potty?

Smokey the Bear.

Smokey the Bear.

Then you know why Smokey tells you when he sees you passing through, remember, please be careful, it's the least that you can do. Don't play with matches, don't play with fire. After 80 years of learning his wildfire prevention tips, Smokey Bear lives within us all. Learn more at SmokeyBear.com and remember, only you can prevent wildfires. Brought to you by the USDA Forest Service, your state forester, and the Ad Council.

This podcast is sponsored by Talkspace.

Last year, I went through many different life changes. I needed to take a pause and examine how I was feeling in the inside to better show up for the ones who need me to be my best version of myself.

When you're navigating life's changes, Talkspace can help. Talkspace is the number one rated online therapy, bringing you professional support from licensed therapists and psychiatry providers that you can access anytime, anywhere.

Living a busy life, navigating a long-distance relationship, becoming a first stepfather, Talkspace made all of those journeys possible. I could speak with my therapist in the office. I could speak with my therapist in the comfort of my home. I was never alone.

Talkspace works with most major insurers, and most insured members have a $0 copay. No insurance, no problem. Now get $80 off your first month with promo code SPACE80 when you go to Talkspace.com. Match with a licensed therapist today at Talkspace.com. Save $80 with code SPACE80 at Talkspace.com.

Ella is 2.5 years old. She stays dry through naps, hides behind the couch when she's pooping, and she tells her parents after she's gone pee or poop. She loves reading potty books and even helps her stuffed animals go potty. Her parents keep it low-key. The potty's right here if you want to try, sweetheart. Every time they offer, Ella stiffens and shouts, "No!" They've tried gentle encouragement: "Let's try sitting just for a few seconds," or "We'll read you a book while you try," or "You'll get a candy if you sit," but Ella either runs away or bursts into tears. One time her dad gently carried her to the potty and sweetly said, "Just try, sweetheart," and she screamed until he gave in. Currently, even mentioning the potty shuts Ella down, and her parents are left wondering, she seems ready, so why is she refusing? And that's exactly what we're diving into in today's episode. What do you do when your child seems ready to start potty training but refuses to sit on the potty? Well, welcome to Toddlers Made Easy. This is the bite-sized No Fluff Parenting Podcast. I'm your host, Dr. Cathryn Tobin. Let's get started. So let's talk about what's really going on here with Ella. She's physically ready, but is she emotionally ready? Well, apparently not yet. She's curious, but she's cautious. She's interested, but kind of unsure. And what started as gentle nudges now feel like enormous pressure to her, even though sticker charts and candy, which are meant to be fun, can feel pushy when a child isn't emotionally there yet. So what does Ella need to move from resistant to willing? Well, she needs a sense of control. It's your choice if you sit or not. She needs zero pressure. Pause the potty talk and reading potty books for now. Ella needs to feel like she's the boss of her own body. So let's say your child is showing all those signs of potty training readiness, and I'm going to review a few of them with you right here now: staying dry for longer stretches, telling you when they're going or just went, loving copying you, they're curious about the potty, they can pull their pants up and down, they can sit for a few moments, and they're past the no phase. Well, you probably think this is it, we're ready. But when you gently invite your child to sit on the potty, well, what will you do if he refuses? Sometimes your child might refuse with a firm "no!" Sometimes with tears, sometimes with a full-on tantrum, and sometimes by peeing on the floor. And now you're wondering, how can somebody be so ready and so resistant at the same time? Well, let's stand back and look at the situation. Being physically and cognitively ready doesn't equal being emotionally ready. A child can be capable and still not feel ready. They can understand what you're asking of them and still say, "No thank you." They can feel your enthusiasm and still refuse. Because learning how to use the potty, it isn't just a skill. It's a big emotional and life shift. A big shift can feel scary. Or just not be your child's priority at this moment. So why is this so? Well, it's partly about control. Toddlers don't get much say in their day, so saying no to the potty is a fantastic way to feel in charge of something. It may be that they feel too much pressure. Even a sweet "let's just try" can feel like a huge push, and toddlers are wired to resist pressure. Especially around their body. It might be that they feel scared. The sounds, the sensation, the letting go. It's all new. It's all unfamiliar. And some kids don't know why they're afraid. They're just afraid. Other kids don't like the spotlight. Some kids freeze when they hear, "Oh, you're such a big kid now." It feels like too much pressure instead of praise. And lastly, "It's my body," is what many kids are thinking, and they need to feel in charge of their bodies. At this age, toddlers are just beginning to understand that they're separate from us, and this realization can feel both thrilling and terrifying. Potty training sits right at the heart of this developmental shift. So if a toddler senses that they're being pushed, even lovingly, they might slam those brakes on. They're not being difficult. They're saying, I need to feel like this is my decision. So here are a few things not to do in this situation. Don't push your child to just sit and try. Don't bribe or beg them, and don't insist or punish them. Also, don't assume you've missed your window of opportunity. These approaches might get some short-term results, but long-term, not so much. They usually build more resistance. So what should you do? Well, most importantly, you need to change the script. So instead of saying something like, "Go sit on the potty, sweetheart," say, "Looks like your body's telling you something. When you feel ready, the potty's in the bathroom, and I'm here if you need my help." It shifts the control back to your child. That one little change, it really matters. Here's another one. Instead of, "I know you have to pee. Now go sit and try." Say something like, "Trying something new can feel both exciting and scary, but I know you'll get the hang of it, and I'm here to help whenever you want me to." Tiny tweaks in how we say things lead to big shifts in how our kids respond. And these shifts don't just help with potty training. They're actually part of a bigger approach to toddler parenting, one where your child feels seen, And safe and supported. And that's the heart of everything I teach in my potty training course. And soon I'm going to be sharing something brand new to help you get more support, not just for potty training, but for all those toddler curveballs. Now let's say the struggle continues. Here's what you do next. You put a pause on the potty talk. You're not giving up. You're just creating a space and you'd say something like, Your job is to listen to your body. If it tells you it's time to pee or poop, let's see if you can make it to the potty. And I'm here if you want some help. Also notice what is working. So say something to your child like, you're really good at listening to your body, or you're learning what your body needs. That's so smart. Do you see? Sticker charts aren't needed. In fact, sticker charts are a subtle form of pressure. Lastly, trust your child. Kids rarely go from "no way, I'm not using the potty" to potty pro overnight. But resistance doesn't mean failure. It just means your child needs more time, more space, or more emotional safety. It's not about pushing harder. It's about shifting your mindset and slowing down the entire process to avoid those power clashes. And that's something we work on every day in my community of Big Hearted Parents. And if you're wishing you had a little more guidance or support, stay tuned. I've got something really special coming your way. Now, if your child consistently says no, gets upset, avoids the topic, and you've already tried adjusting your tone and timing, well, that's a sign it's time to give it a break. Not for long, wait a week or two weeks. And then try again with a zero-pressure approach when your child's resistance softens. Let's look at another real-life example before we finish up. So Linda, a lovely mom, reached out and asked me, what should I do, Dr. Cathryn Tobin? My son seemed ready to start potty training, but now he absolutely refuses to sit on the potty. And in fact, he's holding his pee for hours and I'm really starting to worry he's going to make himself sick. And then she asked the big question: Should I back off completely and try again later, or should I hold my limits kindly but firmly? And that's a great question, and here's what I told her: Your child needs to feel like he or she is the boss of his own body. So I encouraged Linda to shift her role from coach to cheerleader. Instead of leading from the front, stand on the sidelines and support your little guy as he's learning to use the potty. Let him know I believe in you and I'm here if you need me. A few days later, Linda messaged me, Dr. Cathryn, I stopped asking my little guy to try. I just said, you're in charge of your body like you told me to. And I said, when you're ready, the potty's right over there and I'm here to help. And you know what? The pressure lifted and Sam started to sit on the potty on his own. Unbelievable. Now that's a powerful reminder. When we give our kids back their sense of control, they often step forward with inner motivation. Now I'm going to be sharing more in the next episode about something really exciting coming. Hint, it's something I've never offered before, but I made it just for you. So make sure you're following the show so you don't miss it. Now, before we wrap up, I want you to remember this: if your child refuses to use or even sit on the potty, it's not a sign that you've done something wrong, and it certainly doesn't mean your child isn't capable. It simply means they need a different approach, and one that's rooted in curiosity, not pressure. Toddlers are wired to learn, explore, and imitate, so when we create a a stress-free environment that lets them explore, well, potty learning can unfold naturally and confidently. With trust, time, and support, not pressure, we can make space for their success. And that's what I teach inside my Potty Training Made Easy course, the no-pressure, no-drama method that works with your child and not against them. That's it for today's episode of Toddlers Made Easy. Remember, you've got this and we've got you. Have a great week and we'll see you next time.