Back Down for What?

Canada suspended its digital services tax after U.S. pressure, but the speaker argues this is strategic patience, not weakness. He cites the Avro Arrow cancellation and the fishing zone dispute as precedents where Canada appeared to back down but gained leverage for later wins with allies.
Chapters
Yes, I saw the news, and yeah, I'm mad too. Ottawa's backing down on Canada's digital services tax after Trump had yet another performative temper tantrum for his base. And maybe like me, you're wondering, why do we always seem like the kids that bring butter tarts to a knife fight? Backing down for a bit is not always the same as losing. Sometimes in Canadian history, it's how we end up winning. In the 1950s, Canada was building the most advanced fastest fighter jet in the world, the Avro Arrow. It was faster than anything else flying at the time. It was designed to intercept Soviet bombers, built and engineered entirely by Canadians. It looked like we were about to lead the world in aviation. And then in 1959, we scrapped it overnight. Why? A mix of reasons, but mostly because we backed down under pressure from the US, and instead we bought American missiles, Bomarcs, a system that didn't even work properly at the time. People were angry, not because we lost the jet, but because it felt like we lost our nerve. But here's the thing: as much as it hurt, as much as it looked like a capitulation, backing down might have saved us from something worse. The Arrow was a technical marvel, but a financial nightmare. Costs were spiraling, the mission was becoming outdated, and we couldn't afford to maintain a defense industry at that scale. So instead, we leaned into NORAD, which even today gives us protection without having to spend American-scale money. This tax isn't gone. There is an international group working on a global tax for the same American tech giants that gutted media and ad markets. We were part of that group, by the way. We only cranked out our own law because we felt they weren't working fast enough. So we'll wait a year, maybe two. This time we're coming with friends. That too is how we have managed these before. Around the same years as the Avro cancellation, we tried to claim a 12-mile, uh, exclusion zone for fishing in our waters. The Americans were pissed, so we backed off publicly to give the American leaders an easy win to crow about to their base. Meanwhile, quietly in the wings, we were building a huge international coalition that eventually backed the zone. This tax is one piece in a massive package, thousands of tariffs and line items and duties. We're not hearing about the wins because we understand that diplomacy is equal parts finding compromise and shutting your damn mouth during negotiations. So yeah, I get it if you're mad that we paused the tax, but if we let ourselves frame this the way the American media surely will, that the polite Canadians are pushovers, then we've forgotten that Canada is not here to win the noise war. That's not failure. That's maturity.
More from Tod

Ten times Canada helped the U.S. with its wildfires, instead of whining about the smoke. 









