A former CBC host argues the network's decision to cut executive performance pay is political theatre, not smart policy. He explains performance pay is withheld salary tied to targets, not bonuses, and warns removing it will drive away talent and push the broadcaster toward mediocrity as it already struggles with chronic underfunding.
Chapters
You know what really warms my heart? When political parties stop everything to fix a complex problem with nuance and care. Ah, just kidding. This week the political rage machine finally caught up with the CBC, which announced that it is scrapping performance pay for its executives, which I think is a terrible idea. Let's first be clear about how this pay worked. This was not money that was given to them on top of their base salary. In fact, it was quite the opposite. It was money that was held back from their base salary until they hit specific targets. That's the difference between a bonus and performance pay, the latter of which is not a golden parachute, it's not yacht money, it's not stock options. It's just— it's money that is held back until you deliver. But now, gone. Why? Because certain politicians, let's call them conservatives, don't understand the difference between a bonus and performance pay. Actually, I take that back. They do, they do understand the difference between bonus and performance pay, but they also understand that angry is a better fundraiser than accurate. Look, the CBC has been trying to get stories of this country out while competing not with Global or CTV, but with Netflix and Disney Plus and whatever fresh hell Instagram spits out today. If you want Canada's stories to survive that onslaught, you need sharks— hungry, ambitious Sharp people, the kind who see performance targets not as a threat, but as a challenge. I worked there for a decade as a host. My show was a national live radio show. Our studio was in a hallway. And not a metaphorical "we're very scrappy hallway," an actual hallway. Because they didn't want to give up the spare change they made renting their real studios out to outside groups. Okay, there's no cafeteria at CBC Vancouver. There is a folding chair next to a vending machine that only takes coins and hasn't been restocked since 1990. 1997. The CBC isn't bloated, it is stretched thinner than a cell phone signal in a Canadian tire. Especially when you remember that it's not just a TV channel, it's 4 radio networks, 5 digital platforms, 7 TV channels, all in 10 languages, for the cost of half of what the rest of the world pays for its public broadcasters. And now with this decision, what does the future hold for the CBC? Well, sadly, we know exactly. What will happen, because generations of businesses before it have gone down this path. The ambitious leave, the innovative stop bothering, and what's left is a slow drift into mediocrity. Turns out you starve something long enough and you make people believe it was never worth saving in the first place. That is how public institutions die. Not in fire sales, but in apathy. The CBC is being pushed to that brink, and when it falls, it won't be because it failed. It'll be because we let it.
