Ashish KothariMake flourishing your competitive edge

The Secret to Business Success? It's NOT What You Think #alexedmans #podcastclips #businesssuccess

18 Jun 2025 · 1 min

Watch on YouTube

1:11

Single-speaker YouTube/podcast clip (Ashish Kothari) critiquing Simon Sinek’s 'Start with Why' thesis. The speaker argues that Sinek’s flagship examples (Apple, Wikipedia, the Wright brothers) are cherry-picked survivors, and that survivorship/selection bias undermines the claim that having a stated 'why' (purpose) reliably predicts success. The clip focuses on demonstrating the absence or ambiguity of stated purposes in the cited examples and pointing out omitted counterexamples that would weaken Sinek’s argument.

Chapters

Simon Sinek, he says don't just take my word for it, that purpose is the secret of success. Let me prove it to you by giving you some examples. Apple was successful and it started with why it had this purpose. Everything we do, we believe in challenging the status quo. Well actually Apple never said that. Nowhere can you find Apple saying this. But let's say they did say that. Let's give them the benefit of the doubt. Wikipedia, they had a purpose which was to democratize knowledge. And they have surpassed the Encyclopedia Britannica as the world's fountain of knowledge. Successful. And the Wright brothers? They were also successful. They launched the first powered flight. Now again, it's not true, it's not clear that they had a purpose. But let's assume they did have a purpose. They have clearly been successful. But those are just cherry picked, hand selected examples. There could be thousands of other companies or non profits or people who also started with Y and they failed. But Simon Sinek will never tell you about them because they just don't support his thesis. So even if the facts that you do see are correct, it's the fact that you don't see where all the action might lie.