#503 Radical Self-Confidence + A Different Take on Perfectionism; Best of Lisa Bilyeu, Katherine Morgan Schafler, and Tania Lester
4 Nov 2025 · 30 min
Heather Monahan brings together Lisa Bilyeu, Katherine Morgan Schafler, and Tania Lester to discuss radical self-confidence, perfectionism, and self-compassion. They explore Dr. Kristin Neff's three-part model: self-kindness, common humanity, and mindfulness. The conversations blend healing frameworks with practical manifestation techniques.
Chapters
Hi and welcome back. I can't wait for you to sink your teeth into today's incredible episode. In honor of Women's Month, I'm bringing back three of your favorite conversations on the podcast with three unstoppable women. Lisa Bilyeu, co founder of Quest Nutrition and Impact Theory, psychotherapist and author Kathryn Morgan Shapler and Theta healing practitioner Tanya Lester to bring you the very best of their insights on healing confidence and reimagining perfectionism. And as a source of your power, you'll learn how to build radical self confidence, tap into your intuition and align your body and mind for transformational growth. Together we'll say goodbye to burnout, gain a whole new perspective on perfectionism and understand how to heal from the inside out. This episode is literally handpicked life changing strategies and mic drop moments that will rewire your mindset so you can uplevel every aspect of your life. Here we go.
Come on this journey with me each week when you join me. We are going to chase down our goals, overcome adversity.
Adversity.
And set you up for a better tomorrow.
I'm ready for my close up.
The other thing you mentioned that I find really interesting is Sunk Cost Fallacy. And for anyone that doesn't really understand what that means. So often, whether it be in a relationship or in a business, we say, I've got 10 years in on this. I can't, I know I'm not happy. I can't walk away now because that's basically saying the last 10 years I was wrong or that it's a waste or there's got to be, I can't do that now. There's too much invested in this. And sunk cost fallacy is so interesting to me. I've done it in relationships before. You know, I'm four years into this. I can't give up now. It makes absolutely no sense. Every time I've had that internal dialogue with myself and of course eventually something will happen or, you know, I'll, I'll have an epiphany that I do need to make that change. And after I do, I have this moment where I sit down and say, yet again, here I am again. Cause so many of us have patterns in our life. You know, I stayed too long. And so that's dialogue I'm constantly aware of now. I don't allow myself to say, just because I was in something for a year or two years doesn't mean it was too long. You know, what if 10 years ago was the right time now Is the only time pull the trigger.
Yeah, it's so true. I go to like, is it still moving you towards your goal? Yes or no? So actually, there's two parts. Is it still moving you towards your goal and is this still fulfilling? Because those things sometimes, right, it's like, well, no, we get, you know, especially in entrepreneurial world these days, it's like, you know, be on your grind, hustle, hustle, work hard, move forward. And so the question is, yes, work hard, but are you working smart and are you working in the right direction? It's like, think of, you know, I love analogies. So just thinking about going in the car and it's like, you want to drive to New York, right? But you actually take the wrong freeway and you keep going and you're just like, but I'm on this freeway now. It will eventually get me to New York. But do you want it to take 10 times longer? What if you now realize, actually, I don't want to go to New York anyway, Right? Like having these assessments of am I still on the right path? Do I still want to go to New York? All these assessments. Just because you're one year in doesn't mean that you shouldn't. In fact, that's when you should. I wish I did that in eight years. I didn't do that even once. Me and my husband, we play this game called no bullshit. What would it take? And so the no bullshit, what would it take to X, Y and Z? So let's say your goal is to build a company and you're like, okay, no bullshit. What would it take? It would take me seven years to make $100,000. And in that path, I will have to give up on spending Saturdays with my partner and I can no longer get my hair done. Like, that's what. No bullshit. What would it take mean, to get to your goal? Actually refine. Where are you going? No bullshit. What is it going to take to get you there? And then are you willing to do it? Because that's the thing, right? Like for you with your C suite, if you're just like, I want to run this company. Great. Now you've got the goal. You know what you want to do. How do you get there? Okay, well, I need to fill this position. I need to work my way up the ladder. Okay, great. What skill sets are you going to build to work your way up the ladder? Now, when you're in the process each year, you need to assess. Are you having fun? Is it a life you still want? You have to Replay the no bullshit. What would it take? Because now your goal still may be I want to be to the top. But you know what? I actually really want to have a partner and I've given up dating for four years and the truth is this may not be the life I want anymore. I want to date. I want to go out there. Okay, so now maybe you've assessed your goal of running the company may not align with your day to day and now you better reassess. Does your goal still match the life you want? And I think that to your point of how do you make sure you're not wasting your years? Is the reassessment of is your goal still your goal? And are your acts on a day to day filling your heart? Because if it's not, do you actually want to get to your goal in the first place?
I like that idea of revisiting and constantly reevaluating what those goals are and accepting that what was working for you even two years ago just might not be working anymore. And that's okay. I remember just growing up that it was this one path and it was corporate America. And that's all I ever thought of, right? So when I was in it, it was tunnel vision. I never thought what is available to me? Is there anything available to me outside of this? And it's so important that we say we don't have to check the box and go to college and go to corporate America and get this prize. We can actually instead pick our head up and say, what suits me now? Just like that conversation that you had with your husband and I so appreciate you sharing that. Meet a different guest each week.
It's that time of year again. Everyone knows that the holidays can become overwhelming quickly, so the sooner that you get things done, the better. For both shoppers and businesses. The best time to score great deals during the holidays is Black Friday Cyber Monday weekend. Whether you're an established business or someone who is going to experience their first Black Friday Cyber Monday this year, you know that the most important thing you need is a platform that can handle everything that's about to be thrown at you. You don't want to find out that your inventory is off as orders keep coming in, or that your point of sale system cannot keep up with the requests, many from new customers who are buying your products for the first time. You need to make sure that your tools and platform are ready for anything that comes your way during the busiest weekend of the year. And that's why you need Shopify. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10% of all e commerce in the US from household names to entrepreneurs who will be participating in their first Black Friday Cyber Monday this year, including your girl right here. With creating confidence in everything that we put through Shopify, the one platform that manages it all, you don't have time to spend hours poring over every little detail. Me neither. Shopify has thousands of templates and tools to help streamline website creation, making sure that your site isn't just aesthetically pleasing but functional at the same time. Accelerate your content creation. Shopify is packed with helpful AI tools that write product description pages, headlines and even enhance your product photography geography to help increase your reach during the busiest time of year. You can also stress less knowing that Shopify's award winning customer support teams on standby 247 to help with any issues that arise, allowing you to get back to business as fast as possible this Black Friday. Join the thousands of new entrepreneurs hearing for the first time with Shopify. Sign up for your free trial today@shopify.com monahan that's shopify.commonahan go to shopify.com monahan and make this black Friday one to remember if you're like me, you're always looking for ways to feel stronger in your workouts, recover faster from working out, have more energy during your day and preserve your health, mobility and strength as we get older and might appear. Timeline is giving me that life and it's happening right now and I want it to happen for you too. This supplement really can help you because it supports your health at the foundation by encouraging cellular renewal. Miture is a precise dose of the rare postbiotic Urolithin. It works by promoting an essential cellular cleanup process that clears out dysfunctional mitochondria AKA your cell's battery packs. Mitopure is the only Urolithin, a supplement on the market clinically proven to target the effects of age related cellular decline. Hello. With regular use you are going to see and feel the difference in the form of improved energy levels, better workouts, faster recovery, more endurance, all of which are helping you achieve your New Year's goals and making you feel your best. PS might appear as shown to deliver double digit increases in muscle strength endurance without a change in exercise. For the win, Cellular health is a foundation of well being and longevity. Mito Pure recharges your cells supporting any goals by helping others all of your system work better. I'm excited to share that you can now get 20% off your first timeline purchase. There's never been a better time to experience the benefits of mitopure. Use my code Confidence at checkout. To receive 20% off today, go to timeline.com confidence that's T I M E L I N E.com confidence.
I asked you to try to find your passion.
I think one of the worst aspects of unhealthy perfectionism is when you get what you want. And it's like, I call it in my book, being struck with a thousand daggers at once because you finally got the thing that you thought would make you, you know, feel the way you wanted to feel or be who you wanted to be, whatever. To certify your belonging to something and you feel the opposite. You feel like shit because you have to confront the fact that there is no substitute for self worth and there's no substitute for real connection with other human beings. You know, so you talk about.
Thank you for breaking that down first of all. But you talk about these underlying issues, lacking self worth, fear, anxiety. How do you guide people away from those things into self love and self compassion and allowing and embracing and channeling this into a power instead of a holdback.
Yeah, well, that was what I was most excited to talk about in the book because I think we're getting a lot of that wrong with this. Like just love yourself. We talk about it like a panacea. And it's like, you know, someone who's struggling to love themselves hears that and they don't know what that really means. I mean, I don't even know what that really means. When people say, like, just be nice to yourself. It's like what? Like give me actionable steps, you know, And I think what we again, to go back to the emotional illiterate piece is like the self compassion. And this is what I am so excited to talk about. So I'm so glad you asked me that question. Self compassion is not being really nice and sweet and polite to yourself. Self compassion is a three step resiliency building skill. And the framework that I use in the Perfectionist guide to losing control is based on research by Dr. Kristin Neff, who was the first person to really research into compassion. She's like for self compassion what Brene Brown is to vulnerability. Right? She's like the one. And she breaks it down into these three steps and we don't know what those three steps are and we don't understand that when you exercise self compassion, that ushers you into a sense of real accountability for your life and real power instead of this like petty control. I mean, that's the spine of the book is like, we are trading our inherent power for all of this control that doesn't even work and is an illusion in the first place. And it's tantamount to like trying to move a car by getting behind it and pushing it instead of just sitting in the driver's seat and driving it. But we don't know the difference between control and power or like how to access our power power. And one of the best ways to access power is through self compassion. But we live in a culture which teaches us that self compassion is kind of like this hippie thing to do. And especially in corporate America, it's not the move, right, that you need to be hard on yourself and punitive with yourself and bust your ass and do all of this stuff. And that's what's going to get you across the finish line. And the research says the exact opposite. When people are punitive with themselves, they burn out. They don't operate with premium energy, they're not solutions oriented, they have less creativity. You know, it's just negative across the board. And so the three. Do you want to get into the three steps of self compassion? Okay, so the first is self kindness. And again, what I love about Dr. Neff is she really funnels it down to like talk about what kindness is. And she starts kindness with the most, in the most interesting way, which is being able to just acknowledge like you're in pain. And that's why you need to be kind to yourself. You're not just having a bad day, you're not just flustered. Like you are in pain right now. And you need to move towards yourself instead of away from yourself and have some empathy. So when I think about the difference between being kind and polite, empathy comes into play. And empathy is about being able to understand what someone is feeling. And the someone in this case is yourself. And so that looks like, you know, let's just say, you know, you had a really bad meeting and you're starting the negative self talk of like, I can't believe I said that. I can't believe I said that. I am so embarrassed. That was such a, you know, blah, blah, blah. All the things self compassion would look like disrupting that and saying, God, it is really hard to feel this embarrassed. I am in pain. Like this hurts. This is the worst. And you have to acknowledge that. Whereas I think when people, when we tell people to just be nice to themselves, they have the exact same flustered meeting and then they're like, it's okay, you're okay. And it like falls flat because we know what the truth feels like. And that's not the truth. You're not okay. Like, and it wasn't an okay meeting. You didn't do a good job. Like, that's the truth. And that doesn't have any commentary on who you are. Right. It just means you had a bad meeting. It was not your shiniest moment. And so that self kindness is being able to acknowledge like, God, this is hard, I'm hurting. The second one is common humanity, which is being able to say that we live amongst billions of people and billions of people live as have lived before us. And hopefully if we, you know, can switch gears, billions of people will live after us on this world which is in fire. And someone somewhere is having your exact experience. And like, you're not alone in that. And that is part generating connection, part like, get out of the narcissistic mindset that like you are the only one who's ever suffered this much. And the more you're experiencing something that is taboo in our culture to talk about, the more shame you're going to feel and the more alone you're going to feel. So for example, sexual molestation, right? We don't talk about that. It's not okay to talk about it. You know, all the things. So someone who is feeling that is not going to feel a sense of common humanity because it feels so uncommon to them. They are probably thinking, nobody in my circle has ever had to experience something like this. Or if you, you know, no, it's so common.
I want people to know this. And it's so common.
It's so common. You know, same with domestic violence, you know, suicide. All of these issues which are so common but are still shamed in our culture and which are still weighed down with stigma. It's like if you were in a, if you're feeling that stuff. One way to kind of generate common humanity is just imagining yourself in a room full of people who have, who are talking about that experience. And that's why support groups are helpful, for example, because they generate a sense of common humanity of like, oh, I'm not the only one who's, you know, X, Y and Z. And that's why, you know, frameworks like AA and things like that. It's a community. It's community. And what community is, is like shared common humanity. And then the last component of self compassion is mindfulness. Another word that's been radioactively commodified in our culture. And what Neff means by this is like being able to say, yes, that meeting was embarrassing. It was the worst. I hated it. But also, that's not all I feel. And being able to turn your head a little bit and say, like, what else do I feel? Do I also feel, you know, proud of myself for being introspective right now? Am I also looking forward to Saturday night with, you know, going out with my girlfriends? Am I also really curious about this book that's been sitting on my nightstand for two months that has nothing to do with my job, you know, and just being able to return to the sense that like, you're a whole human being and being mindful of the fact that like, this one experience you're having is not who you are. It doesn't say anything about what's possible for you in the future. It's feeling like it's eclipsing your whole reality, day, life, whatever. Because your stress response is activated and that narrows your line of vision. Because when your body is stressed, you're wired to focus on like the next one minute of your life. And so you're contracting. And mindfulness is about letting your body and mind know it's okay to expand. Now there's no tiger in the room with me, you know, and you're safe and this isn't all you feel. So perfectionists feel disappointment a lot amongst a litany of other emotions. And instead of feel, instead of asking yourself like, how do I feel less disappointed? How do I get rid of my disappointment? A better question is what else do I feel? Because then you make space for the disappointment and you make space for the rest of your emotional landscape, which is, you know, not just bad, it's filled with a lot of other stuff.
Meet a different guest each week.
When you want more, start your business with a Northwest Registered Agent and get access to thousands of free guides, tools and legal forms to help you launch and protect your business all in one place. Build your complete business identity with Northwest today. Northwest Registered Agent has been helping small business owners and entrepreneurs launch and grow businesses for nearly 30 years. They are the largest registered agent and LLC service in the US with over 501600 corporate guides. Real people who know your local laws and can help you in your business every step of the way. Build your business identity fast with Northwest Registered Agent and get access to thousands of free resources, forms and step by step guides without even creating an account. Sign up for a free account to begin managing your business hub with lawyer, drafted operating agreements, bylaws, resolutions, membership certificates, bills of sale and more, all at no cost. Northwest is your one stop business resource. Learn how to build a professional website, what annual filings your business needs to stay in good standing and simple explanations of complicated business laws don't wait. Protect your privacy, build your brand and get your complete business Identity in just 10 clicks and 10 minutes. Visit www.northwestregisteredagent.com/confidence free and start building something amazing. Get more with Northwest registered agent@www.northwestregisteredagent.com confidence free as the air turns crisp and the holidays draw near, comfort becomes the best gift of all. Quince delivers layers that last sweaters, outerwear and everyday essentials that feel luxurious, look timeless and make holiday dressing and gifting effortless. Quince has it all. $50 Mongolian cashmere sweaters made for everyday wear, denim that never goes out of style, silk tops and skirts that add polish and outerwear built to take on the season. Perfect for gifting or upgrading your own wardrobe. Honestly, Quinn's Italian wool coats are at the top of my list. The cuts feel designer and the quality rivals high end brands, but with without the high end markup. By working directly with ethical top tier factories, Quint skips the middleman and offers prices 50% less than similar brands. I mean if you want to look like you are wearing the highest end clothing out there without those huge price tags, Quince is the answer. Literally there's something for every single person on your list. The Mongolian cashmere sweater is the softest sweater I have and it is my go to every day. If you want to elevate your look without paying more, Quince is the answer. Step into the holiday season with layers made to feel good, look polished and last from quints perfect for gifting or keeping for yourself. Go to quince.com/confidence for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns now available in Canada too. That's Q U I n c e.com confidence to get r free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.com confidence.
I asked you to try to find your passion.
You know, I also teach people how to manifest. I also teach people how to increase their intuition, how to become empowered. Okay within their own person. So yes, I feel that if somebody wants something to change in their life and they want to learn how to manifest, we you know, the first thing I ask is, you know, what's your intention? Why do you want this to happen? Does anything scare you about this happening? You'd be surprised. Sometimes people will say things and I'm like okay, that's from a fear Base or a negative thing. So a lot of what you're seeing is miracles. Showing up is not just healing the mind, the body, and the spirit. It's also teaching the client how to access this energy field that some people call source, creator of all that is so that they can actually have these manifestations come to fruition, as everyone listening knows.
You know, my old life was very much corporate America. Never I thought people who talked about manifestation were on drugs or hippies and just. I truly did not. I thought that that was them. They're over there. And I'm part of the hardworking population driving value in the us. Like, I just saw that as so separate from me. And so through this whole journey since Getting Fire, I've opened my mind to a lot of different things. And I 100% believe in manifestation. And that's something that you've worked with me on. And I'll tell you, you know, I've watched the Secret. I've read all these different books, and, you know, again, all this information goes back hundreds and hundreds of years, if not probably thousands and thousands of years that I haven't accessed yet. But one profound statement that you made to me that helped turn the switch on for me. And I don't know if anyone's struggling with this, maybe this will help them. I was saying to you when we were in a session, I said, I just don't understand. It seems fleeting. Like once in a while it will happen, but I don't have control over it. I don't know how to make it happen on the regular. I feel like I'm blessed at a certain moment or time it could happen, but I still don't know what I'm doing. It's not methodical, and I don't have a handle on it, and I want to have a handle on it. And you said to me, do you know what your purpose is? And I think you called it divine timing is why you're here on this planet. And I said, of course I do. Yes, I know exactly what it is. And you said, do you see that certainty and that conviction that you have in that? I said, yes. She said, you need to have that same certainty, conviction, and knowing when you're manifesting something. Can you talk a little bit about that?
Most people are pretty much queued up. There's a lot of information out there. I'm not the only one. You're also a purveyor of. Of health and wellness and success. Okay, so there's a lot of us out there, but all of this information that we read, that we're taught. There's a huge difference between having all of this information in your mind, which you are consciously aware of through your cognitive abilities, of everything you've been taught, you've been hearing and you've read. There's a huge difference between what you have in the mind and what you actually. All of that information in your mind and actually feeling in your soul, in your heart, all of that information. When you actually feel in your heart and in your soul, everything you've read, everything that you resonate with, you know, cognitively, that's really. Heather, when the magic happens, when you actually feel it with that conviction, when you were like, of course, this is my divine timing. So that type of conviction and that, that feeling it in your heart, I think is when the magic, it happens before that transition. But I really feel that that's key for all of these blessings to keep coming to someone, to everyone, you know, to actually feel and know and just know that you don't know when it's going to happen, but that it's going to happen. So one of the things teach people is to make a manifestation list for their divine timing. And I think that's the challenge with most people. I want to have a family. I want to open my own business. I want to move to, I don't know, Colorado, whatever it may be. And I think they start to, in their minds, try to figure out how that's going to happen. And that kind of can slow it down. As opposed to, I want to move to Colorado. I'm just giving you an example. I want to move to Colorado in 2023 for my divine timing, to be able to do this, this, this, and this. Thank you, universe. Thank you, creator. And yeah, you want to Google real estate. You want to kind of see what's happening in Colorado, but you don't have to figure out exactly how that's going to happen and when that's going to happen. I'm not referring to someone who's in a corporate position where the company moves to another state and they move you to another state.
Okay.
I'm referring to someone who just doesn't want to be somewhere and wants to move somewhere else or wants to move out of the country or whatever it is that their manifestation is to put it out there and know that it's available and that's going to happen. Staying in the present moment and not trying to figure out exactly how that's going to happen.
For me, I've spent my entire life white Knuckling and working so hard doing the last bit that you just said the. Trying to figure out how to make it happen. So all this time I was spending all this effort and angst on something that I should have been letting go of.
Yes, I will use myself as an example. I've been practicing energy alternative medicine for 12 years now, and I have a nice, successful private practice. Thank you, universe. And a lot of my clients are video. Well before COVID because I've never. I've never had the privilege of meeting them. But, you know, we'll. We'll have a session every three or four months or what have not. And one of the things that I was manifesting was to start doing the podcast. To start, I kid you not, it's like, wow, I really want to start being interviewed. You know, my son's already 16 and a half will be in college next year. I'll have the time to travel around, start speaking publicly. I just put it out there, put it on a list, and then, I don't know, about three or four weeks ago, all of a sudden you're leaving and you turn around and you say, by the way, I'd love to have you on my podcast. I almost fainted. And I was like, keep it together. Heather's replying. And I was like, so I was beaming with joy. I had a smile from here to here. And when you left, and I was just like, yes, thank you, universe. Because that's what I really wanted to happen. But I didn't do anything. I didn't start calling people, hey, can I be on your podcast? It just happened. And that's another example of just wanting something to happen, knowing that it's going to happen and just throwing it out there without an emotional attachment to.
When.
I decided to change that dynamic, I couldn't be more excited for what you're going to hear. Start learning and growing. Inevitably, something will happen. No one sees succeed alone.
You don't stop and look around once in a while. You could miss it.
Come on this journey with me.
More from Heather


Confidence Classic: Why Your Energy Attracts Everything Into Your Life with Heather!


Confidence Classic: Break Free From NEGATIVITY and Start Moving Forward with Heather!


Confidence Classic: The Goal-Setting Habits That Turn Dreams Into Reality with Heather!


Confidence Classic: The Mindset Shifts That Help You Break Out of a Rut with Heather!


Confidence Classic: How To Turn Setbacks Into Strength and Gratitude with Heather!


Confidence Classic: How to Go Bigger and Stop Holding Yourself Back with Heather!