The transcript records a Supreme Court proceeding concerning the death of a medical student in Kolkata. The bench interrogates the investigative timeline, focusing on the search and seizure conducted between 8:30 PM and 10:45 PM, the collection of photographic evidence after the body was removed for post‑mortem, and the status of CCTV footage. The counsel confirms that the full CCTV footage was handed over to the CBI, yet other speakers allege missing or incomplete video, citing technical glitches and a full hard‑disk. Further discussion reveals forensic findings: the victim’s clothing was removed, she was found semi‑nude with injury marks, and foreign blood samples were sent to the Central Forensic Science Laboratory (CFSL) in West Bengal for analysis. The dialogue highlights contradictions between the prosecution’s claims of complete evidence hand‑over and the defense’s concerns about gaps, with occasional emotional outbursts from a speaker expressing frustration over perceived silence and possible evidence suppression. The hearing underscores procedural disputes over evidence integrity, chain of custody, and the adequacy of investigative documentation.
Chapters
Mr. Dibin, also second question, when was the search and seizure actually carried out?
8:30 to 10:45. 8:30 to 10:45. The photographs have been taken before, Madam.
8:30 in the morning or in the evening? Evening.
In the morning at 9:30.
That's right. Photographs were taken once the body was removed, Madam, for postmortem.
Then only And by whom there is some relevance. Therefore, I would like my learned friend to ask. There is some some relevance.
Well, we have photographs on 12:45 p.m. onwards of everything that happened. We have the original.
That's capillable.
Now, due to the force of the previous hearings, and therefore we, as you know, the investigation is going on. We can share this because you all said it.
Yes.
That there is evidence to— there is CCTV footage to indicate what time the accused enters the seminar room and what time he's exiting the seminar room, right? This is what the applicant would ask. Now, obviously, therefore, there would be CCTV footage after 4:30 in the morning throughout the day.
Yes, there will be.
Has the CCTV footage in its entirety been handed over to the CBI? Yes, yes, yes.
Yes, we have taken.
Oh God, there are there are no CCTV footages. Why are they lying?
We had to reconstruct the scene because of the distance, but here.
How to explain this?
This is the biggest silence I've ever felt in my life. The direct telecast of the Supreme Are they going to pass the verdict today, or is it going to be? What are they going to pass? What verdict? Look at Kapil Sibal. This is the deadly silence. Judges are consulting on themselves.
The entire footage of the proceedings which were taking, which took place between 8:30 PM and 10:45 PM, was given. Yes, yes, yes.
What he shared with us is about 27 minutes.
27 minutes.
Yes, sir.
The 4 clippings total in duration for 27 And proceedings conducted from 17:06, that is 5:06, to 22:45.
मलत आंखों क्या हो रहा है?
Two separate things, मलत. Seizure 8:30 to 10:45.
मलत.
Seizure 8:30 to 10:45 given. Then, my lords, in parts the videos have been given. In parts. There was something CCTV in hard disk, in parts, completely given. There was some technical glitch. It was stored in part but given in full. Hard disk is full. And he's made a statement that they are given.
But in this context, I need to come in here because there is something which According to me, is very very serious. Lord, Lord, I want a flag. Lord, we have the forensic examination report. I will not read it, my lords. But one thing, my lord, is admitted: when the girl was found at nine thirty, I'm sorry, but her jeans were removed and even the undergarments. रिमूव्ड एंड वेर लाइंग समवेर नियर, सो शी वाज़ इन अ सेमी न्यूड कंडीशन। इट इज़ आल्सो एन एडमिटेड पोजीशन नाउ। क्या है? बिलो इस। And this blood, this is a foreign blood. Your office remark. They have taken the samples. They have sent it to an FSN in West Bengal, and this is the result.
Hence, CFSN.
CFSN West Bengal.
Central lab.
Not.
You should remove the.
Taglines from below foot.
No, I have only one copy right now. Please see this one. This is serious, and the CBI has taken a decision to send the samples correct blood to Ames and other blood central forensic science laboratories. The person enters; the body parts are not covered. The girl is being nude. There are injury marks.
And this is the result of everything.
Therefore, who took the samples becomes relevant. Anybody?
संसद जनरल दुषार मैदावती ने प्रश्नों को लेने जे फॉरेंसिक एग्जाम रिपोर्ट्स तादे रहते हैं शेषी वंशकाने रखा था जे जे शपथ छाड़ी नोटाएं जो अपन देहो उधार होए कप
