Jim Katsoulis says keto's real problem isn't the diet itself, it's that almost nobody stays on it. Short-term weight loss means nothing if you quit after three months. He recommends ditching refined carbs instead and picking something you can actually stick with forever.
Chapters
The Main reason Keto is a Crappy Diet for Most people Now I'm not going to argue with you. If you eat a standard American diet and start following a keto plan to the letter that you will probably lose weight, which is true for most diets anyways. But the reason keto is such a crappy diet for most people is because no one sticks with it long term. So unless your goal is to just lose some weight for a little while and then put it all back on, what is the point? If you don't want to follow a keto diet long term, then don't follow it short term because you're just wasting your time and putting off the inevitable weight gain. Instead, focus on a plan that works for you. Now you can take aspects of the keto diet, begin to reduce refined carbs, but you do not need to live a life in ketosis in order to manage your weight. There are a lot of other strategies you can use that are a lot less rigid and increase your ability to live with them long term. So don't just judge a diet based on how much weight you'll lose in the short term. Start to look at how long you're going to be able to stay with that plan.