Before You Give Up, Hear Jessica Fein’s Story of Love, Loss, and Unbreakable Strength- EP 412
4 Feb 2025 · 78 min
Jessica Fein lost her adopted daughter Dahlia to a rare mitochondrial disease after twelve years of progressive disability and ventilator dependence. She also lost her sister, parents, and another sibling. Fein discusses how compounded grief reshaped her understanding of control and meaning, and the importance of community support and storytelling in preserving legacy.
Chapters
You know you need something, you're just not sure what. You've been listening, you're doing the work, but there's still this feeling that you're circling the same place, like you're waiting for the thing that finally moves you. Now maybe you've thought about working with me one-on-one. Maybe something's held you back, the timing, the money, or you're just not sure you're ready yet.
I get that.
And I want you to know there's still a place for you. I built a resource for exactly this moment, guided meditations for when the waves hit and you just need to breathe. Workbooks to help you get out of your head and onto the page, ebooks on what near-death experiences tell us about the people we've lost, and whether they're really gone, a full course for widows and widowers who are ready to find their way back to living, and a full course for the evidence of the afterlife. And all of it is available for pay what you want. Nobody gets turned away because of money. I think these resources are valuable, but I don't want to hold them back because you don't have the money to pay for them. You don't have to wait until you're ready for coaching. The next step might be a lot smaller than you think. To find out, go to grief2growth.com/store. That's grief, the numeral 2, growth.com/store. And check out the resources I've made for you.
Close your eyes and imagine.
What are the things in life that cause us the greatest pain? The things that bring us grief are challenges, challenges designed to help us grow, to ultimately become what we were always meant to be. We feel like we've been buried. But what if, like a seed, we've been planted? And having been planted, we grow to become a mighty tree. Now, open your eyes. Open your eyes to this way of viewing life. Come with me as we explore your true, infinite, eternal nature. This is Grief to Growth. And I am your host, Brian D Smith.
When I'm Brian D Smith, I'm the host of Grief to Growth, where we explore life's toughest challenges, and we uncover the meaning behind our journey. So whether you're joining us here for the first time, or you're a regular listener, I'm so glad that you're here. This podcast is about helping you navigate life's storms, to embrace growth, and to gain a deeper understanding of who we are, why we're here, and what comes next. Today, I'm honored to welcome Jessica Fine to the show. Jessica is the author of Breathtaking: A Memoir of Family Dreams and Broken Genes, and she's also the host of the podcast I Don't Know How You Do It. Through her writing and her podcast, Jessica shares powerful stories of resilience and triumph, even in the face of unimaginable challenges. Her own journey as a relentless warrior is inspired in part by her dynamic daughter, who she tragically lost to rare disease in 2022. And her daughter's name is Dahlia. Jessica's work has been featured in The New York Times, Newsweek, Psychology Today, and more. And she's here to share the wisdom, grit, and grace that she's gained along the way. So in this conversation, we're going to explore what inspired Jessica to write her memoir and how it captures her family's journey, how she found hope and humor amidst heartbreak and learned to face what— the unsolvable, the concept of ambiguous grief and understanding how it can help us navigate loss. And why vulnerability can be a gift to your loved ones and how it helps to create connection. So Jessica's story is one of courage and compassion. And I'm sure insights will resonate deeply with anyone who's faced life's toughest questions. So stay tuned as we dive into this heartfelt conversation. And remember, you can join the conversation and connect with others at grieftogrowth.com, grieftogrowth.com/community after the broadcast. And with that, I'd like to welcome Jessica Fine.
Thank you so much for having me. I'm really looking forward to this conversation.
Yeah, me too, Jessica. And whenever I have a parent on that's had a child that's passed in spirit, I always like to start off by, tell us about your lovely daughter, Dahlia.
Thank you. You know, and it's so interesting, I do feel like as a bereaved parent, we recognize each other. And we know that, you know, saying their name and asking to, to hear about them, what, what a gift that is to us, you know. So thank you for that. Yes, I had the honor to be Dahlia's mother until she passed one week after her 17th birthday. Dahlia was the sweetest child on the face of the earth. And I say that objectively. Anybody who knew her will agree with me. And she was just absolutely full of mischief. And love. And she had a really, really insidious decree when she was diagnosed with this horrendous disease, and she did not let that stop her. She was going to continue to live life to the fullest. And she showed all of us how that was possible.
Yeah.
So tell us how Dahlia came into your life.
Yeah, so Dahlia came into my life and my husband's life when she was 6 months old. We adopted her from Guatemala. Guatemala. We adopted 3 children and Dalia was our middle. We did not adopt them all at the same time. Um, we adopted each of them 2 years apart. And in fact, Dalia was the youngest of the 3 when we brought her home. And we even got to meet Dalia when she was 3 months old, which was so amazing. That was the smallest little baby I ever, I ever had. It was only for 2 days and then the court and paperwork and everything else took another 3 months. But we brought her home at 6 months and she was just an old soul. I don't really fully understand what it meant, but it was just— what that means. But it was just something about her, the way she would look at people. There was just— she exuded something like, I know a little bit more than you do, even as a baby.
Mm-hmm. Sounds familiar.
Yeah.
So, um, you, you, uh, adopted her at 6 months and when did, when was her diagnosis then?
So her first diagnosis came at 3, which was hearing loss. And, and I think it's such an important point I like to make that we did not know about Dahlia's disease when we brought her home and when we adopted her. And I do like to point that out because Some people think, oh, you went and you, you know, adopted a child with very severe disabilities and, you know, put, put us in kind of a different category of like, oh, isn't that amazing that you did that? And I'm like, no, no, no, that's not the story here of what happened. Dahlia came to us, as I said, at 6 months. And I just always kind of suspected something was not quite typical in terms of the way her speech and her physical movement was developing. And you know how it is. They, the doctors say, oh, you know, calm down, she'll catch up, you know, all that kind of there, there. And that happened for quite some time, both with the doctors and even like with early intervention. They kept saying, no, she's, she's fine. She's on the lower end of average. She'll catch up. But finally they agreed. The doctors agreed to do a hearing test when she was when she was about 3/4, we discovered that she had mild to moderate hearing loss. And that was really the beginning because even though that was a diagnosis that could be corrected with hearing aids, there was a big question. Why does she have hearing loss? Did something happen in utero? Is there something genetic? Like there was just question marks. Why, why should a young child have hearing loss? And so we were sent for genetic testing. And, you know, a lot of families, when you have a genetic disease, it takes years to get genetic testing. For us, it happened relatively quickly. So at 5, we got this diagnosis of MRF syndrome. And MRF is an ultra-rare kind of mitochondrial disease. It's degenerative. It's really particularly cruel to have a degenerative disease diagnosis when you're 5, when you're a little kid, because what's happening is you're learning and you're growing and you're developing and you're also losing. And it's like those two things are— it's like a tug of war. So Dalia was diagnosed at 5. We had no idea what that meant. No idea. I mean, we didn't know what a degenerative disease was. We didn't know what mitochondria were. We had no idea, you know? And, um, and that was the beginning of what became very much of an odyssey, uh, over the next 12 years. Stay with us. We'll be right back.
You know, one of the hardest things about grief, most of the people in your life just don't get it. They want you to be further along than you are. They get uncomfortable when you bring it up. So you stop bringing it up. And that's why I started writing. My Substack is where I go deeper. Thoughts I don't always get to on the podcast. Essays on consciousness, on continuing bonds, on what it actually means to carry a loss and still build a life. The stuff that used to keep me up at night, written out in a way that I hope meets you in the morning. But here's what I didn't expect when I started it. The community that showed up. People who are doing exactly what you're doing. Listening, learning, trying to find their footing. Readers who comment, who share their own stories, who remind each other that none of us are as alone in this as we feel. And that's what the Substack has become— a place to go deeper with me and to find your people. It's free to subscribe. Find me at grief2growth.com/substack. That's grief, the numeral 2, growth.com/substack. Or just go to Substack and search for Grief to Growth.
I hope to see you there. Yeah, I, and I, I can't imagine, um, that, that, that you said that, that tug of war between having a child that's got a degeneracy as they're developing. So, uh, tell me how Daya, how did she cope with that?
You know, for the first 4 years, so until she was 9, things were relatively— and a lot of this is in hindsight— relatively typical. And I use the word typical instead of normal. But what I mean is she was mainstreamed. We did the things that other families do. Yes, she had speech therapy and physical therapy and occupational therapy. Yes, she took more and more medication, and she ended up going from needing to wear ankle braces to needing to use a walker, to needing to use a stroller, to being in a wheelchair. So that was kind of how things were progressing. So to your question of how did she deal with it, that was the hardest part for her. Why my legs don't work like everybody else's. That's how she would say it. Why my legs don't work, Mama. Why my legs don't work. That's a really hard thing to have to explain to a kid. Why my legs don't work. So that for her was the thing that at that point until age 9 was the toughest. And then at 9, everything changed.
So tell me about that. What hap— what happened at 9?
So when she was 9, we went on a family trip. Actually, it was right before her 9th birthday. We went on a family trip. So at that point we were still flying places, you know, we could do things. And we're in the Boston area. We went to Florida for spring break and Dalia caught a cold. Now we all had colds, but when you have a disease, a degenerative disease of the kind that Dalia had, there's no such thing as like a simple cold, right? Mm-hmm. So Dalia had a cold and she started to sound really just like a, like a washing machine, you know, it just sounded— it didn't sound right. And I was like, I don't want to overreact, you know, but I took her into the, to the local ER and she was admitted. And that's when everything began to change in our lives, because what happened was she developed a pneumonia and needed to be intubated there in Florida in a hospital where nobody had heard of MERF syndrome. They didn't even have a metabolic specialist at that particular hospital. So now my husband and I, who, you know, a few years ago didn't know what mitochondria were, are educating all of the doctors and explaining what's going on. And poor Dalia was intubated and was just really, really struggling and really on the precipice. And all we wanted to do was get back to Boston where we had doctors who knew what MRF syndrome was and, you know, where we could figure this out, or so we thought. And that wasn't so easy. You know, you can't just get on a plane with a child who's intubated. And it's a whole other show how I had to fight with insurance to get a medical jet. And yeah, but we won't go there now.
But I know it's— I want to let people know it's in your book, and it's an amazing story.
Thank you. Thank you. Well, we did ultimately get back to Boston. And I'll never forget that, you know, that we got there, and it was one week before her 9th birthday. And We were in the pediatric intensive care unit, and I said to the doctor, can you just promise me that we'll be home for her birthday? And he said, well, I can't promise you that. I can promise you that you won't be in the intensive care unit on her birthday in a week. Well, that just shows, A, how naive I was, and B, even the doctor didn't really know because we were in the pediatric intensive care unit, the PICU, for the next 3 months. So yes, we celebrated her 9th birthday there. And she was just really, really struggling. Every time they would extubate her, she would go into respiratory distress and then she would need to be intubated again. And it was this whole thing of trying to figure out what was happening with her lungs, why she was no longer able to breathe in a way that was gonna sustain. And Pretty early on in that admission, they started talking to us about the possibility of a tracheotomy, which for anybody who might not know is when they put a hole in your neck and that becomes your breathing mechanism. And I really, really, really resisted that for a number of reasons. But the primary reason was that the chances are, were that a tracheotomy would mean Dalia would no longer be able to speak. I do wanna be clear that that's not always the case when you get a trach. In Dalia's case, because it depends upon how much air you're able to push up. And it's a— in her case, it meant we would probably lose her voice. And that wasn't something I was prepared to do, right? But over time, we were told, and we came to see and understand, that Dalia was not going home from the hospital without a trach, that that was her only chance of survival. And so we did move forward with that, and we did in fact get to go home. But when she went home, she had lost a lot of functionality. So it was a 3-month period during which she lost the ability to walk completely, to talk, to eat, and to breathe without a ventilator. She became ventilator dependent. So now everything changed. One of the things about being, um, a child on a— with a trach and ventilator dependent is she became what's called an eyes-on patient. Meaning myself or my husband or a nurse trained specifically in her care needed to have our eyes on her 24/7. She couldn't be in a room by herself because there's things that can happen. The trach can pop out, the vent can malfunction, you know, every minute is, is life and death. You're on the precipice. And so our house became a bit of an ICU. The medical equipment and the machinery and the medical personnel who were in and out. And remember, I had two other kids and I had Dalia who wanted to be a kid.
Yeah.
Who wanted to be more than a patient. And so that was really what the challenge was. How do you create a life, a life that has some joy, a life that has some meaning in the face of such a horrendous situation? And that was from age 9 to age 17, 8 years of that.
Yeah. As I was, you know, reading your book, and I know you've had other losses in your life as well. So you might want to tell us about that.
Bring the listeners up to speed on— yeah, that I was not a stranger to loss. The book actually begins with the sudden death of my sister, who was my best friend. And anybody who has the blessing of having a sibling who's also a best friend can understand what that was like. At age 27, my sister was 30. She died suddenly. She had a baby who was 1. She and I had been on the phone that morning, as we were every morning. And that was the first major loss. I had had other losses, but that was the one that really changed how I saw the world. How I understood what it meant to not have control, how I understood how things could change in an instant. And in the book, what I say is, you know, I had been in this bubble. I think most of us are until we experience something.
Absolutely.
And, uh, that loss punctured the bubble, and I now saw the world through the puncture, through the clarity of the puncture, not through the hazy bubble. So that was the first loss. And then I lost the rest of my, uh, nuclear family of origin over the time period in the book. So I lost both parents and my other sister. So two sisters and, and both of my parents. Um, yeah, so it was, it was a tremendous amount of loss. It was an understanding of what compounded grief means because of course each loss is experienced in relation to what has come before. Right?
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah, let's talk about compounded grief.
Yeah.
What did that feel like for you?
Well, I will tell you, I mean, if we jump all the way to the end, when Dalia died, all I wanted to do was like crawl into my mom's lap. Right? Or hold my sister's hand. So you realize who's not there. To hold you in your grief because they're gone. Right? And of course, there's a bit of magical thinking, and maybe it's not magical, who knows, where I think, "Ah, they're together. At least she's got people there wrapping their arms around her." But each loss, I think of it like, you know, if each loss is a string, I've got this ball of yarn, and it's so tangled, it's very hard for me to think about any loss without thinking of them all together, except that first sister. Because when I lost my sister Naomi, I didn't have those other ones to, to, you know, take— get tangled up in it. That one was a little bit more pure, if you will. And then everything after that, even my mother's, uh, illness— so, so I've had, I've had illness, I've had sudden And with my mother who died from breast cancer, even that, even taking care of my mother in those couple of years, Nomi's absence was so profound, right? Because she would have been in that with me and my other sister. So, so you see, they're all really— time for a quick break. Make sure to like and subscribe to continue to receive great content from Grief 2 Growth. And now back to the episode.
Yeah, it's interesting, as you were saying that, you said ball of string. I, I was just talking with someone a couple days ago, we were talking about loss, and she said it's like cold spaghetti, you know? And you know, like when you have cold— when it gets cold and it all kind of congeals together, it's congealed, and it's just—
and it tastes yucky, and there's nothing, nothing, nothing good about cold spaghetti. So yes, I like that one very much.
Yeah, so it's, it's And I'm really intrigued by the name of your podcast. You know, I Don't Know How You Do It, because we, you know, we've heard that. And so what does that, what does that mean to you when you hear that phrase? I don't know how you do it.
Well, and of course, you know, it's kind of tongue in cheek because for so many years, I mean, this whole course of the book, I also was working full time in a big job and my husband was working full time and we had the, you know, the 3 kids and literally There was not a day that went by that somebody didn't say to me, "I don't know how you do it." And you know where people are coming from, right? I mean, you know that they don't know what to say, and they're trying to acknowledge that, "Hey, I see you. I get it. There's a lot going on." But how do you respond to that? Like, "I don't know either," or like, "Yeah, what choice do I have?" Or, you know, I mean, there's just— there's no real way to respond to that question, even though, of course, it's well-intended. Or excuse me, to respond to that statement, even though it's well-intentioned. So my podcast is conversations with people who, for whatever reason, have found themselves often on the receiving end of that statement. "I don't know how you do it." And I will say it's not all trauma and tragedy. Some of the people who are on the show have just chosen really unconventional paths where other people are like, "I don't know how you do that." You know, like somebody who— sold her house and moved with 5 kids onto a boat and decided to have a life at sea, or somebody who traveled the world solo and landed in Central America building her own home. You know, so there are some stories that are just people who have these lives that are hard for other people to imagine. But the majority of the people on my show have been through— been through it, let's put it that way.
Yeah. Yeah. And, you know, what I have learned over the years, and I've interviewed people like yourself that have been through multiple trials traumas, um, you know, and, and it's, it's— I look at the human spirit as so much more resilient than we give credit for. And when— and as you said, when people say that, it's well intended, but as, as a person that's in grief, or a person that's going through it, it can, it can mean almost exactly the opposite. It's kind of like, well, your, your loved ones must not mean as much to you as mine mean to me, because I would just die Exactly.
It's the same thing as, you know, I can't imagine, right? It's like they— people say these things and it just erects a wall between you because it's like, oh, well, okay, they're— you feel a little bit judged, just like you said, of like, I don't know how you do it. I wouldn't be able to. So, so, you know, like you said, I must love my people more than you do. It's like a no-win situation. If we are out there trying, trying to have a life in the face of this tragedy, we feel, are other people looking at us and wondering, well, why is she out? Well, I saw her, you know, at the soccer game. What's she doing there? Right?
Right.
And then we question ourselves. How can I be out there? How can I be doing that when, you know, my people aren't here? And I think we're all really good at making ourselves feel guilty, so anything that comes from anybody else surely just exacerbates that.
Yeah, well, I have to confess, I mean, I said that to you earlier when we got started. I said, I can't imagine. Um, and, and we do say those things trying to empathize with the person, but you're right, it's— and the, the one thing I really want to illustrate is there's nothing really great to say when you're talking to someone in grief. There's no— there are no magic words. And we all get really awkward and we all stumble. And even when I said that, I was like, okay, you know, I shouldn't have said that.
So I feel that way too. And I— listen, I just did my TED Talk, was all about grief literacy and what to say and what not to say. And I am awkward, and I'm sure I say things that rub people the wrong way, right? It's hard. It is absolutely hard.
It, it is. And I think that's, that's something to acknowledge and say, okay. And I tell my people that are in grief, it's like, okay, we have to give other people grace because they're they're doing the best they can. And, and we have to try to, you know, really watch our language when we're talking to other people. Um, and, you know, I appreciate you sharing, you know, your story, you know, with us. And again, it's like, I think what one person can do, any person can do. So when we say, okay, Jessica is really special because she's been able to get through this, you are, but we all are. And You— and, and so I love these stories because it also lets me know that, okay, I can, I can do this, right? If, if someone— if Jessica could do this, if she could do what she did, I can do what I have to go through.
I agree 100%. And that's one of the things that people say, well, what do you want people to take away from your book? And I say, well, we are capable of much more than we think we are. Because I will tell you, if you had shown me a picture, a photograph of what my life was going to be, I would have said, no way, no way. And I have evidence. Not that anybody showed me a picture, but I have evidence that I would have said that. When you adopt, you fill out, as you can imagine, reams of paperwork and you have tons of interviews and home studies. And, you know, they don't just give a baby to you. You know, you have to really be deemed qualified. And one of the things that we were asked is, what kind of medical conditions are you open to? And there's a long, long list and it's everything you can imagine and a million things you can't imagine. And I said, none of them. I'm not open to any of them. Why would I? I'm not gonna raise my hand for that. And that's why earlier I pointed out that we did not know about Talia's disease when we adopted her. Thank God. Because if I had known, I would've said, no, I'll wait till the next, I'll wait till the next set, and I wouldn't have had my Dahlia. So, you know, I didn't want that. And mostly it's because I didn't think that I could handle it. Oh, I don't think I'm cut out for that. Right?
Yeah.
That's what we learned. We learned that we all are capable of so much more than we think.
Yeah, that really struck me, you know, in the book. And again, I love the way you were so open with that, because I thought, First of all, I wouldn't adopt. I'm not that person. And if I did, you know, if you get to that point in the form, it's like, well, am I going to be judged if I say, you know, none of the above?
So I didn't even want to tell my husband that I didn't want— I was like, well, he's— what's he going to think if I tell him? Because he's like, yeah, whatever, sure, you know. And I was like, I don't really want that, you know. And I'm thinking, oh gosh, he's so much of a better person than I am.
Yeah, well, we I want an easy life, right? I don't want to— I don't want to sign up for this, right?
Look, I mean, I knew that adoption might come with its own challenges, just the nature of adoption. And plus, we had been through 5 years of fertility treatment. I was like, no, let's just, you know, now let's have smooth sailing. We thought the hard part was over, right?
Right. So, um, your other— your other boys, or your other two— other two are boys, right? So how are they doing now?
Yeah, so, um, You know, it's really complicated. It's really complicated. And as you know, grief, even, even the loss of the same individual hits each person in the ecosystem in a totally different way. And so that's why, you know, I learned this when my first sister died. I thought, this is very different for me than it is for my other sister. Why is that? Both of us lost the same person. We both lost our sister. And yet, you know, each relationship is unique. Therefore, the loss is unique. It meant something different. I lost my older sister. She lost her younger sister, you know, so, so we all lost our Dahlia. But it has meant something different. And it manifests differently. It does for me and my husband, and it does for our children. So, you know, they are, they are working to move forward every day and to integrate the grief. And some days it's easier than others. And And we carry on. But I will tell you this, they are incredibly, incredibly empathetic, inclusive, beautiful human beings. And I do believe that at least some of that is due to the fact that they are Dahlia siblings.
Oh, sure. Yeah, sure. So what, what, um, and it's again, it's really interesting that, you know, when we, when we have a baby, you know, we We don't— it's just the, uh, not luck, but we, we don't get to choose whether they're going to have a, a disability or an illness or whatever, disability. Um, but you made the choice that you like, yeah, I want a healthy baby, and you, and you got Dahlia. What did you learn from having Dahlia in your life? What do you think that you would have missed if you hadn't?
How much time do we have? Because I will tell you, I am the— I am not the same person I was And I say that in— I learned so much from Dalia, from being Dalia's mother, from meeting the people that I got to meet through her. So first of all, what I learned is, as I said, we're capable of so much more than we think. Second, I learned that we really— any illusion of control is really an illusion, right? Number 3, we believe that our job as parents is to, you know, keep our kids happy and healthy. That's not always possible. It's not always, let me, you know, kiss your boo-boo and give you a Band-Aid and Mama's going to make it all better. We can't fix everything. There are some things in this world that we cannot fix. And that was a really hard lesson for me because I had thought, "Well, if you put your mind to it and you work hard enough, you can get what you want. You can fix what you—" You know? No. So, you have to find other ways to have, quote unquote, "control." You know? You can't change certain things, but you can change what the next hour is gonna be like with Dahlia. What are we gonna do? Are we going to snuggle up and read a story? Are we going to do an outing? You know, the most ordinary things that families, that parents and kids do, are extraordinary. And I realized that because there was a victory in doing these very, quote unquote, ordinary things. It makes you look at everything differently. Everything. And I, I had a strength in me that I didn't know. I mean, look, I would have said I was a strong person. It's not that this was like a shock to me, but in terms of what what we all in the family carried. But mostly what I learned from Dalia is you can have the single worst thing, not even the worst thing you can imagine, 'cause I'll tell you, I never could have imagined some of what we went through with Dalia. I mean, some of it was really beyond imagination. Right. And you can smile, you can be happy, you can find moments of joy, you can create beauty. All those things are not mutually exclusive. And I never would have understood that. I would have thought, how in the world can I have— can I be in a situation where my daughter lost her ability to blink and I had to tape her eyes shut so that her corneas wouldn't dry out when she was sleeping? How can that be my reality? And we can be, you know, giggling and being silly. How can that be at the same time? And it can be. And then those moments of joy or happiness or simplicity become precious.
Yeah, yeah. Oh wow, that's, that's so, uh, profound. Uh, and, and that's something that's, you know, that's us, those of us who have lost children. Um, I think we, we— I don't want to say— I always hesitate to say all or anything's universal, but it seems from the people I've talked to, it's kind of universal. It's I never thought I could get to this point, you know, because it feels like the worst thing possible that could happen. It feels like it's overwhelming. And I would think that you would have felt overwhelmed many, many times thinking, okay, this has got to be it.
This is the limit. Yes. Oh my God. Yes. Mm-hmm. It's like, what more can, can I be asked to carry? Shouldn't there be a ceiling on suffering? Right, right.
But, but what you said also, though, and again, it was as I was reading the book, those moments of joy, those moments of normalcy, the things that we tend to take for granted, you don't take for granted anymore.
That's right. That's right. Because we were living on the precipice. Literally every moment is life and death. So if you think about that, I mean, even just think physically of what that does to you when you are braced for impact all the time. So being able to just take a moment and breathe, and by the way, that's one of the meanings of the book, breathtaking, of the title. There's a few, but that's one of them.
Yeah. Yeah. So yeah. So talk about the different meanings of the title. Yeah. Yeah, please.
So it's breathtaking, two words, and I loved the title very much because it had so many different meanings. I mean, first of all, Dahlia's breath was literally taken from her. That was the crux of the disease, right? So, there's that meaning. And then there's the one I just described, which is the learning to be more in the moment, which was not my forte. Much happier being 10 steps ahead. And I had to say, "No, no, let's be here now." And... Take that breath. And then the third has to do with beauty. And I mean, it's Dalia herself who was just so beautiful, both ex— you know, on the— both physically, but so much more important, who she was as a human being was, was really just so, so beautiful. And learning to create corners of beauty, which is what I talk about in the book, which is what we did. We weren't gonna be able to change the trajectory. We didn't have that kind of control. So how did we create those corners of beauty, those corners that were breathtaking? And so for me, those are the meanings. The name.
Yeah, I think that it's beautiful, um, and it's so, it's so multifaceted. So in terms of, um, you've learned so much through this, through this experience. What are your thoughts about, um, soul planning? Do you think that maybe this was planned at some level? Have you thought about that? I, I, you mentioned earlier, I heard you say maybe it's magical thinking to think that they're together. So have you allowed yourself to go there?
Well, I'm so glad you asked, because that's really what I'm interested in right now, which is trying to understand— and this is a project I'm working on right now, so we'll have to, we'll have to connect offline on this— but really trying to understand what, what might be possible and what do other cultures believe. And, you know, how can I explore and experiment not only within the tradition that I was raised in, which I'm Jewish, but how can I explore other ways that we might be able to connect? And some of that is actually connecting, you know, whether that's mediums, etc. And some of it is the other ways that we feel connected to our people.
Yeah, yeah. And I always hesitate to ask people that question. But I'm— everybody that's listening that knows me knows what my feelings are on it. And it's something I came to after my daughter passed. By the way, when I first heard of this concept, I'm like, that makes no sense. But I see, you know, again, like you said, I would not have chosen— and you didn't, you didn't choose to have a child that had this, this disability or this disease, but you got what you got. And then so much joy and beauty, you know, come out of it. And it's all mixed up, right? It's, it's not like it's all, it's all joy, and it's like we, you know, we're like, oh yeah, I'm so glad that happened. But you can— we can start to see on some level, even while we're here, that maybe this makes sense in a bigger picture.
Uh, yeah, and I'll tell you, even in a simpler way that I can wrap my head around it is thinking about these 3 children who were born in a country I had never been to, right, to people I didn't know, you know, in a, in a world that was so wildly different from mine. And who are my children. And that to me cannot simply be accidental. My husband believes that if we had been matched with other kids, or if our journey had taken us elsewhere, that one day we'd be somewhere, I don't know, an airplane, a shopping mall, and we'd see our kids, you know, Dalia, JoJo, Theo, with some other person, and we'd be like, what are our kids doing with that other family? I mean, that, that you know, we all came together. It was not— it was not, I don't think, the luck of the draw.
I, I have to believe that myself. As I said, I— well, you don't maybe know this, but I'm an engineer, so I'm— and I think like, how does— how did this work? How do things work? You know, synchronicities, etc. But then I think about my life, and it's like any one little turn that would have been different if I hadn't I had a migraine one night and I was, I was supposed to go to this dinner and I, and I, I almost stayed home. And if I'd stayed home, I wouldn't have met the person that got me the job that led to me meeting my wife. And I'm like, if I just— that one little thing, if I'd done differently, I'd be living a totally different life right now.
I know, I think about this all the time. And it is kind of fascinating though, because you wonder what would that other life be, right? I mean, you know, this migraine. Do I stay home? Do I not stay home? So that, that's such a small little detail of one night's decision that changed everything. I almost didn't go to University of Michigan. I was going to go to Northwestern. I did orientation at Northwestern, and at the last minute I chose to go to Michigan. Okay. I mean, that's a bigger example than a migraine, but I would be a— I'm sure I would have a totally, totally different life. I'd be a different person because I probably, you know, so, so it does make you wonder, yes, is there some master plan at work? But the flip side is, what are all these other versions of me that would have been?
Yeah, well, I, I kind of think like, I don't know, it's— we're kind of pondering some really deep stuff here, but I feel like this is the way it had to be. It couldn't be any other way. I, I can't, can't imagine, uh, what that other life would be like. I wouldn't have my daughter Kayla. I would not have had my daughter Shayna. You know, I— it would be a totally different thing. And I have— what I enjoy about doing this and sitting down with people like yourself is, is being able to see the beauty even with the pain, you know, even now, before, you know, say we cross over and we get all the answers. I think we can get some of those answers now. And that's what I really love about, again, you sharing your story, because it helps me realize, okay, yeah, it seems crazy, it seems random, It seems like there's so much stuff here that people say, well, why would I possibly choose this? Why would I choose to have this, this really crazy disease that no one's ever heard of? But I've talked to people like you and my friend Don, who had a son named Willie who had, uh, lissencephaly, or lissencephaly. Yeah. Um, and, you know, Willie was never able to speak or walk or anything, but when I see the beauty that came out of, you know, the life and it complicated her other kids' lives and stuff too. But, you know, every parent I've talked to has had to say, I would not trade it. I would not, I would not trade, you know, a quote healthy child for the what I learned from that person.
Yeah. And I mean, same with me. And I, and I have, have the beautiful fortune of knowing so many families who have, have been through, you know, rare disease and, and just, you know, all kinds of things. And because we adopted, I feel like mine is, is so, for me, it's so clear-cut because it's not like, okay, well, you know, this is the child that I gave birth to and this was what, you know, this really was, it could, it could have, they could have called another person on, you know, on the list and said, we've got a baby for you. It was all, and, and when, when Dalia was diagnosed that very day, I said to my father, Thank God we hadn't known. I know I wouldn't have signed up. And I know she was my daughter and I was her mother. And that was there. There's no question. And I would not trade it. And even then, even, you know, on the day of diagnosis, I didn't say, oh my God, woe is me. Why? Why? You know, it was no, it was thank God. Thank God I didn't know so that we could be together.
So we talked about this a little bit before, but I want to go into a little bit more. You know me, I know you describe yourself as a problem solver, and people listening can see, you know, you went through the infertility, you solved that problem, you went to, you know, you adopted these kids, you're— and you, you are very much that, that person, right? That person that says, I'm going to take this on. How do you— how do we balance that with acceptance? Like knowing when to let go that I don't have control over this? Yeah, it was hard.
It was really hard because, because I decided I would cure mitochondrial disease. Right. Right. Now, remember, I did not know what mitochondria were. I was in marketing. I mean, it's not like I had any, any credentials or reason to believe that I personally was going to cure this incurable disease. But, you know, that's what we do. And I, and I at the very least, I was going to have— get Dahlia cured. And I did think if we work hard enough, right? And we've all seen like Lorenzo's Oil or, you know, that's what just came to my mind. Yeah. I had Dahlia's tincture. I was going to be— it was going to be Dahlia's tincture, you know? And I, I mean, I spent so much energy trying to get her into these clinical trials and trying to, you know, call these doctors, reading every study. I mean, this became consuming for me. Sure. Because how could it not? How could I not follow every single solitary little seed of a path, right? And meanwhile, there she is wanting to, like, play Chutes and Ladders and not, you know, so, so you have to start to think about what am I doing to try to fix it while here I have my child who wants to be with mom. And I, and I did, I put so much energy into trying to figure things out. And it wasn't until we finally did get into a clinical trial and we had our plans for going, it was going to be in Washington, D.C., and we'd go every month and we had to figure out a whole bunch of logistics and we had plane tickets and we were all ready to go. And very much at the last minute, she was— it was determined that she was not well enough to participate in the study. And that for me was a real turning point because that meant, okay, we need to turn our attention to what is happening now, what is happening today, because she's not going to be in the study. She's not going to be, you know, she was— her disease was progressing quite a bit. And my husband was— is not as much of a fix-it person. He is so— he's so much more able to really be present. In the moment. And we balanced each other out. You need both, you know? But I needed to look to his example a little bit more. I needed to look to his example of how is he being right now? And it wasn't about acceptance of, okay, I'm throwing my hands in the air and giving up, which is what I had understood surrender to be, right? You know, the concept of surrender, which is so gorgeous to me, I thought it meant I'm giving up. I will never surrender to this disease. This disease isn't gonna win, you know? Mm-hmm. And so how do you learn that it means we are going to be okay with what's happening now? We're going to be here, we're going to follow Dahlia's lead, and we're gonna trust a little bit. And thank God, because I was able to spend a lot of time being with her in the moment. And those are the memories that nourish me now.
Yeah, thank you for sharing that. Um, I think that's, uh, again, that's— it's— there's certain things in life you just have to kind of feel your way through. There's no— there's no right answer, right? We know, of course, we're not just going to roll over and give up, but it's— and the, the word surrender or acceptance, and especially in American society, is almost a dirty word right now. I will— I will never surrender. I will never I will never give up. But it's also, you know, again, accepting, accepting that this is what it is, and how do I make the most, the most of what, what it is. Um, Shayna had nothing like, like Daya, but Shayna had rheumatoid arthritis. So, you know, I remember the day we got the diagnosis of that, and we're like, okay, this is our healthy child. She's like 10 years old, and she loved to play basketball, and suddenly her fingers and her wrists were hurting all the time. She had a super high tolerance for pain. And I realized now the denial that my wife and I were going through, um, like trying to figure out, you know, what's going on. And then the rheumatologist told us, and I'm like, wow, I don't want this, you know. Um, and then she was diagnosed with a heart condition. And, you know, right.
And you realize that's like the hearing aids for me. I thought the hearing aids was— it was like such a huge, huge, huge thing. Right. Now I'm like, "Oh, sweetie," you know, to my younger self, right? Yeah. And when she first had to get AFOs, you know, braces for her legs, I remember I said to the person who was prescribing these and fitting her for them, I was like, "Well, how's she gonna wear tights?" You know? Like, this is where my head was, 'cause I was just like, mom thinking about her daughter wanting to go out and wear tights, and like, she's gonna have these big bulky leg braces, you know? So we look back— you have to give yourself compassion because I look back at that version of me and I think, oh boy.
Yeah, well, we're all— I think we're all that. And I loved what you said about when your sister Nomi's death kind of burst that bubble, because we all have this naïveté about the world and we think that things happen to other people, you know, they don't happen to us, they don't happen to our family. And we We live our lives in denial until something comes along and bursts that bubble. And it's going to happen to all of us, you know. It's— some people get to go longer than others, um, and some people it takes more to burst the bubble than it does for others. But it's, it's coming for all of us. And that's not— and that's not— again, I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing because, you know, we, we can see the— how it gives us opportunities to grow and gives us opportunities to have experience and to start to cherish life. I think, I think we've become— I think I've seen people become more grateful. Um, and it's really interesting. You think it takes something terrible to happen to make you be grateful. Yeah, I agree with that. So what's, um, what's, what's been the response? What's been the most surprising response you've gotten from your book or from your, from your podcast?
Well, from the book, I would say it's a couple things. Number one, people say, I never expected to laugh. So, I like that because, you know, I feel like, you know, there's humor in anything, right? And people all say, "I felt— I read it in, you know, one or two sittings. I felt like I was having a conversation with you." So, that's very gratifying. But the most gratifying thing is when people say, "Boy, I love Dahlia. I really got to know her," you know? And because, you know, look, when you lose somebody, you think— and I— I imagine you feel this way too. It's like, "Oh, man, the world missed out. They didn't get to know her." All the people, like, nobody else is gonna ever get to know her. But then when you do something like share stories through a podcast or write a book, people get to know her. And that, to me, is so gratifying. And the other characters in the book too, who I've lost along the way, I feel like sharing who they were with people is a— really meaningful way for me to continue to, um, make sure that their legacy survives and that other people get introduced to them. Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
I, I completely agree with that, about, about the legacy thing. And it's really interesting because Shana was 15 when she passed, and, um, we homeschooled our girls through 8th grade, so Shana was only in public school for a couple years. And I was really surprised. Like, I think like 700 people probably turned out to her memorial service, which we had no idea. We had this little place in the church, and my wife and I were greeting people, and we greeted people for like 2 hours. We were just standing there for a couple hours before we started, and now everybody couldn't even get in the room because we had no idea that many people were coming. And so what I realized that that was like, she had more of an impact than, you know, I had any idea. And yeah, and it's been almost 10 years now, and her volleyball coach, you know, sends us Christmas cards. And so that's really, you know, gratifying to know that, that our, that our children, even at that, that tender age, have that impact. Yeah, definitely. Yeah. And, you know, and in Dalia's case, um, wow, so many— who knows how many people that her story is going to, is going to impact. And, and inspire, you know, and encourage people, uh, that are again going through things that sometimes we feel like, uh, this is too much, you know, I can't handle this. And I can look at Jessica and say, yeah, I, I think I could do it. I mean, look, look at where she is, and, and wow.
Yeah, well, I, I hope so, and I hope that people read it and, and feel like they do maybe get a little bit of strength and know that we can't write our own story until we do. But we can't write our own story. But, you know, we get to figure out how we're going to live with the story that has been given to us.
Yeah, well, that's an interesting concept, too, you know, writing our own story and how much of that, how involved we are or not. And that's, that's a matter of belief, that's a matter of faith. But what we do know is we can control how we respond to things. Exactly.
And I will tell you also, I mean, for me, writing was a really good way to be able to also control the narrative, right? Because I wrote this book during Dahlia's life, and, uh, things were really swirling out of control. So writing it gave me a little bit of of that control over the narrative.
Yeah, at what point? That's interesting, because I, when I read the book, I expected it that you had written it after she had passed. But at what point did you write it in her life?
Yeah, so I will tell you that this book was agented and sold to a publisher during Dalia's lifetime. And it originally had a different ending. It ended at this very joyous scene where we celebrated Dalia's bat mitzvah. And I I was happy about it ending on such an uplifting scene. Mm-hmm. And then I did have to go in and write the epilogue, but I wrote it, most of it, at her bedside. You know, in the last few years, she spent a lot of time resting. Mitochondrial disease zaps your energy completely. Right. And like I said, she was eyes on. I was there. I was sitting in the chair next to her bed and doing a lot of writing at that time.
Yeah, yeah. Well, I, um, again, it's, it's a— I, I highly encourage people to get the book. It's, it's a great, um, you said it's surprising, there's humor in it, but also we've just touched on the surface of, of what you included in there. Uh, get to know, get to know Dalia better. Um, people should check out your, your podcast. So what would you— and I know we've been talking for 45 minutes or so. But if you could tell someone that's listening that is dealing with like a diagnosis, a terrible diagnosis, and they're just overwhelmed right now, what's something you'd like to say for them to understand?
Yeah, so if I may, a couple of things. Number one, I would say it really, really can be valuable to have people in your life who have been through it. And I don't mean it has to be the exact same thing. I wasn't gonna meet other people whose kids had Murph syndrome. Period. But to meet other people who were living with these lives they never would've imagined, who are living on the precipice, who understood— I mean, you and I, who met, you know, 5 minutes before coming on this show, you get each other in a different way 'cause we've both been through something so profound and so similar. And so, I think finding— people who can be, who can understand on that personal level, I think is so important because as supportive as your friends and other people will be, they don't know in the same visceral way what you're going through. So I would say that. I would say number 2, if we're talking about the diagnosis for a family member as compared to the diagnosis for you, your self is to try to take even moments, if that's what you can get, to have some aspect of your life that preserves your identity outside of being a caregiver, to remember who you were before and to remember who you will be after. You are caregiver. You are front lines. And you are other things too, and not to feel guilty about that, because I think that that makes you a better caregiver. It makes you able to be more present. So I would say that's the other piece of advice. Wow.
Yes. Awesome. I 100% agree with both those things. You know, it's interesting. I'm part of an organization called Helping Parents Heal, and we're all parents who have had children pass in the spirit and You know, sometimes we divide ourselves up like sudden loss, cancer, suicide, you know, whatever. And people say, I want to go to someone who's gone through the exact same thing that I am. But we do have that thing in common that we do have a child in spirit. But as, as supportive as your friends and family can be, some of them, they're going to surprise you in good ways and in bad ways. Oh yeah. So yeah, speak to what your experience is on that. Oh, yeah.
Well, I mean, I think what's interesting is there will be people who show up and become part of your inner circle that you never would have expected. And then the people you would have thought— some people just can't do it. They're too uncomfortable. They're too scared. They're afraid it's contagious, right? Yeah. And, and I don't mean that literally, even in terms of a sickness. But I mean, people think grief is contagious, right? And so, you know, you find out who your people are going to be. And I will tell you, there are people who showed up for us. For example, being in the PICU for 3 months, there are a couple of people in my life who came to that hospital every single solitary day I was there. I will never forget that. And it is not— I wouldn't have expected that actually of anybody. But, you know, to be there and to be in it with me at that level, And it is a scary place. The PICU— there's probably no sadder place on earth than the pediatric intensive care unit. And there are people who showed up every day. And then there were people who didn't show up at all. They just couldn't, you know. You know, so you remember those things. Yeah. And by the way, I will tell you, because I get people all the time, you know, in the grief space, and they'll say to me, well, I don't know, there's this funeral, should I go? When in doubt, show up, show up, get over yourself and your own discomfort. And you're right. Yes, it's uncomfortable and it's awkward. It's also uncomfortable for the person going through it. But you show up because it will be remembered. And it will always— I mean, I am so grateful. And you show up, you don't have to, you know, just show up. If you're in doubt, show up.
Yeah. And you might say something awkward like I did earlier. I mean, we all do. We all do. And we— I love what you said, you know, it's just, it's just showing up. And it's saying, I'm just here for you. You know, I, I'm willing to listen because people that are in grief, they, they need— we need to express ourselves, you know, that we, you know, so you don't have to really say a whole lot either. You can just show up and listen.
Yeah. I always say, don't just do something, sit there.
Yeah. Yeah. I love that.
Yeah. I love that. Yeah. And I just did this TED Talk about this. You know, there are certain things that are offensive, right? Like, so yes, we all are awkward. We're all going to be bumbling. We're all going to say things we don't mean. But please don't start any sentence with "at least." Yeah. Yeah. Because that's like saying, look on the bright side. Right? However that sentence ends. At least she lived a long life. At least she wasn't in pain. At least she didn't have kids. At least she had kids. At least she, you know, no. Yeah. Minimizes the depth of what the griever is going through. That's not on you to—
That's, that's, that's great that you said that. And it's interesting because we talked earlier about, you know, your sister with sudden loss and your other sister that wasn't so sudden and your mother. And, you know, because we, we all tend to like, we compare griefs. We'll say, well, well, you know, at least you got to say goodbye. Well, at least she didn't suffer, you know, all those things, right? And it's a very human thing because we want to make people feel better. Um, but I realized, because when Shayna passed, she was— it was sudden, and then she had a friend who lived around the corner, and hers was extended. She had a glioblastoma. So she died over a period of months, and it was wild because Shayna passed before she did. And I realized, okay, they went through hell and we went through hell, and there's no reason to compare the two. Because while we didn't get to say goodbye, you know, we also didn't have to go through what they went through watching their daughter suffer. And both are horrific, and we don't need to— we don't need to choose which one's better or which one's worse. Yeah, agreed.
And I've seen it every way. And, and, you know, when my sister Nomi died, 3 months before her, my cousin died. And my cousin was 35 and she was diagnosed with something. And we just, as you're describing, you know, we watched this illness progress and, and, you know, in the immediate aftermath, we were all sitting around going, which is, you know, which, which is better? Is it better to know? Is it better not to know? Right. Right. You know what? It's, it's, there's no better or worse at all. It all sucks.
Yeah, it does. And it's okay to— it's okay to, to admit that, you know, that it's, it's, it does suck in a very real way. Yeah. But, uh, I love the, the hope that you're giving people that we can, we can endure this and not— and more than endure it, we can come out on the other side and we can, you know, we can, uh, we can thrive and we can carry on our loved ones' legacies. So Jessica, remind people of the name of your book and where they can find out more about you.
Thank you. Yes, the book is Breathtaking, and Jessica Fine, F like Frank, E-I-N, and you can get it wherever you love to get your books in whatever format. So we've got print and ebook and audio. I have my podcast. I'd love for people to tune in. I don't know how you do it. And visit me, you know, on social. I love connecting with people on Instagram or Facebook, wherever you are, or just check out my website because that's the hub of everything. That's jessicafinestories.com. Awesome.
Well, thanks for being here today.
Thanks for doing this. Thanks so much for having me.
All right, have a good day.
Hi there, I'm really excited to tell you about my latest ebook. It's 4 lessons that you can learn from the near-death experience without going through all the trouble of dying to learn them. I've been studying NDEs for several years now. I am completely convinced that not only are they 100% real, but that there's some very universal wisdom that we can get from the near-death experience. And I've distilled that down in this book into 4 short lessons. And I've also given you all the reasons why I believe that NDEs are absolutely real. So go to www.grieftogrowth.com/NDElessons to pick it up for free. www.grieftogrowth.com/NDElessons. I hope you enjoy it.
More from Brian


John Promised He Would Come Through in Music. Then Marcie Heard Him. with Marcie Dean | EP 499


Healing After Suicide Loss: Breaking the Silence That Keeps Survivors Stuck | Jayne Madigan EP |


Empath Energy Protection: How to Stop Carrying Everyone Else's Pain | Lisa Campion


Remembering PMH Atwater: The Near-Death Experience Pioneer Who Died Three Times | EP 496






