This Campaign Looks Great (But It's Actually Losing Money)

In this short dialogue, Speaker A outlines a practical framework for assessing whether a Facebook ad campaign that appears successful on the surface is actually profitable for a newsletter business. Three core questions guide the analysis: (1) how much can the business afford to pay to acquire a subscriber, (2) what the actual cost per user is on Facebook and why it might be high, and (3) whether the acquired user delivers the desired value after signing up. Speaker A provides concrete benchmarks: a typical newsletter generates $0.30‑$0.40 in monthly revenue per reader; acceptable CPM on Facebook is $10‑$20; outbound click‑through rates (CTR) of 1.5‑2% are acceptable, 2‑3% are good, and 3%+ are great; and landing‑page conversion rates (sign‑ups) are the final gate. By tying these metrics together, marketers can identify where costs are excessive and take actions to improve cost efficiency.










