How to choose your niche for your Digital Marketing Agency

1 Apr 2022 · 46 min
46:05

In this live workshop Joshua Nelson (host) and co‑presenter Jody Underhill guide agency owners through the process of selecting a profitable niche. They begin by warning against analysis paralysis and stress the value of "imperfect action". Using personal anecdotes (e.g., starting with restaurants, then pivoting to plumbing and building a $5 M agency serving 190 plumbing firms) they illustrate the "path of least resistance" and the concept of a "right to win" – a unique combination of experience, relationships, and positioning that gives an agency a defensible advantage. The session then outlines concrete criteria for evaluating niches: self‑identification by the target market, propensity to spend on marketing, sufficient market size (e.g., at least a few thousand businesses with $1 M+ revenue), presence of industry associations or events, and the founder’s background or affinity. Practical tools such as InfoUSA/Data Axle for market sizing are mentioned. They debunk the myth that a niche can be "taken" and show that even saturated‑looking markets (e.g., plumbing) contain vast untapped opportunity. Jody introduces a four‑stage emotional journey of niche selection (uninformed optimism → informed pessimism → valley of despair → informed optimism → category king). The workshop concludes with a hands‑on workbook exercise: participants shortlist 2‑3 niches, run an affinity test, assess direct path to results, and evaluate profit potential, then use a coin‑flip to commit to a choice. Throughout, the tone is conversational, instructional, and enthusiastic, aiming to empower participants to move from indecision to focused action.

Chapters

More from Joshua

youtube.com

How to Stay in Front of Your Prospects Everywhere They Look

5mo ago
youtube.com

From 26 Years in Business to Nearly Doubling Recurring Revenue | Sandy Waggett

5mo ago
youtube.com

How We Handle Different Financial Mindsets in Marriage & Business

5mo ago
youtube.com

Title 1: Why Boundaries Matter More Than Hustle

5mo ago
youtube.com

The best agency niche comes from your past experience

5mo ago
youtube.com

How Luke Truetken Scaled His Agency to $110K MRR by Going All In on One Niche

5mo ago
youtube.com

Luke Truetken's Podcast Interview with Josh Nelson

5mo ago
youtube.com

Why Agencies Can’t Ignore AI Anymore

5mo ago
youtube.com

Website Production at Scale - The AI Tool Stack for Modern Agencies with Marcel Knopf

5mo ago
youtube.com

The Hire I Wish I Made Sooner in My Agency

5mo ago
youtube.com

Hiring people like you is a mistake most founders make

5mo ago
See all content