Here is the most POWERFUL prospecting weapon you have

Andy Neary argues that sharing personal stories is your best prospecting tool. He walks through his baseball career from Division 1 scholarship to the Helena Brewers and Ogden Raptors, then explains the real lesson: playing bigger requires competence, confidence, and a clear plan.
Questions this video answers
October 14, 2020
University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee (UWM)
5 foot 9 and 145 pounds
Helena Brewers and Ogden Raptors
To play bigger you need a "major league mindset": competence + confidence + an effective course of action.
Chapters
Hey. Hey. Did you know that using your personal story is one of the best ways to win business today? Yeah. Because when you share your stories, your weaknesses, your struggles with your target audience, you're giving them a chance to know you, a chance to like you, which is going to make it so much more easier for them to trust you and do business with you. But, Andy, I don't want to share my stories. I don't want to share my struggles. I don't want to show any weakness. I hear this from insurance and financial advisors every single day. Here's the reality. It's 2020. People want to see vulnerability. Humans buy from humans. They don't buy from logos on business cards. So start sharing your story now. If you're struggling with what your story is, take time to sit down and figure it out. What are your hobbies? What are your passions? What do you like talking about? Was there an event in your life that has impacted the person you are? You see, sharing your personal stories is probably the most effective prospecting tool there is, but so many are afraid to do it. So therefore, the bar is low. So put yourself out there, and you're going to give yourself a chance to resonate with your audience more. Let me give you an example. I've been keynote speaking for the last five years, and for the past five years, I've been sharing stories of playing professional baseball. Now, early in my speaking career, when I would talk about playing baseball, I shared all the amazing stories, how fun it was. But when the talk was over, I'm like, why isn't anybody coming up to me saying, yes, I love that. So about two and a half years ago, I said, you know what? I'm actually going to tell this audience why I failed in pro baseball. So I got up on stage, I shared some good stories, but then I told them why I failed in pro baseball. And when that talk was over, for the first time in my speaking career, I had people hugging me. I was onto something. Aha. And that's the power of showing vulnerability, sharing you with the world. So what I want you to do is watch this keynote. This is a talk I gave in 2019. I'm going to share this with you. It's about seven, eight minutes long. This is the intro of the keynote. It's sharing my story with you. And I want you to listen and key in for two things. Number one, I want you to listen to the story, listen to the details. Do you feel like you can put yourself in that story? You see, when you tell stories, you Talk about your life. And using the five senses, touch, smell, taste, hear, sound allows your audience to put themselves in the story. Number two. As I wrap up the story, I want you to pay attention to the message, the lesson I am teaching about my story, that can help my audience grow. See, that is the power of storytelling. It's one thing to share your story, great. But if you can tie a message, a lesson into your personal story, your experience that can help your audience grow and get better, boom, you've got them. You've got connection. They're resonating with you. And guess what? Your business and your bottom line is going to grow as a result. So watch this keynote and then sit down and take the time and figure out what your story is, because that is what is going to take your business to the next level for the rest of this year and on into the future. Don't overlook the power of storytelling. Don't overlook the power of sharing your stories. Don't be afraid to be vulnerable. Don't be afraid to share your struggles, your weaknesses, because everybody's going through them. And that's what your audience wants to hear from you. So listen, watch this keynote and then go use your story to take your business to the next level.
Well, my childhood dream, guys, was to become a professional baseball player.
I grew up in a baseball family. My dad was a college baseball player, also an extremely successful high school baseball coach. He was the longtime coach in my hometown. I played for him, and he's actually one of the winningest coaches in Wisconsin State history. So I grew up in a family surrounded by baseball. I grew up in a family in an environment surrounded by the skills, the knowledge and the mentorship I needed to become a great baseball player. So by the time my senior season of my high school career rolled around, I had my first taste of what it meant to play bigger. You see, going into my senior year, I had committed to playing baseball at Winona State University, a Division 2 college baseball program in Minnesota. But I wasn't satisfied. I wanted to play bigger. I wanted to play Division 1 baseball. But I had a slight challenge. You see, in high school, I was a shortstop and a pitcher, and I knew that playing at the next level would be on the mound as a pitcher. But.
I'm 5 foot 9 and I weighed 145 pounds my senior year. Not what I would call an intimidating presence on the mound.
But by the time my senior season came to an end, I had one last shot to play bigger. You see, it was the first round of the Playoffs. And I was pitching that night. And I knew that recruiters from the University of Wisconsin Milwaukee were coming, a Division 1 baseball program. They were coming to watch me pitch. And I knew that up until that point I had the competence and the confidence to be successful. And I knew that I had created the course of action that I could be the successful that night. And that night I had my first taste of what it meant to play bigger. Because I threw a one hitter that night. I gave up a hit on the first pitch of the game. That was it.
And later that night, I got a call from the head coach of the University of Wisconsin Milwaukee and was offered a scholarship. So here I was playing Division 1 baseball. Now, my first two years at UWM, I thought playing bigger literally meant getting bigger. So I hit the weight room, I pounded the weights, I took this magic powder we had back then called creatine. Where are my college athletes in the room who took creatine? It was the legal way to get bigger back then, right? God knows what the long term ramifications are. So I gained 30 pounds. Here I was 5 foot 9, 175 pounds. But I quickly realized I took the wrong course of action. Because when you're a pitcher, there's a little known secret that says you don't want a muscle bound bicep.
So my first two years on the mound at UWM were terrible. My stats were terrible. And by the time my sophomore season came to an end, I wanted to quit. I wanted to give it all up. Who's been there before in business with their job, maybe for the advisors in the room when the Affordable Care act came around, I know I was there. But something happened between my sophomore and junior year. I was named captain. And going into my junior year, being named captain gave me that confidence back, that I needed to be successful. I knew I had the confidence or the competence to be good. And over the next two years, I had developed a different course of action, a more effective course of action. In the weight room. I. I honed my craft of pitching, I worked on my mechanics. And by the time my senior season came to an end, I had given myself a chance to play bigger yet again by signing up a contract to pitch in the Milwaukee brewers organization.
Now, I wish I could keep telling you stories of massive success and how I overcame the odds and catapulted to the major leagues. But this is where the success story ends, guys. Because when I got to Pro Bowl, I lost my confidence.
You see, I was playing on the same field with guys from bigger schools, Arizona State, lsu, Texas. And I got to my head, and I got away from the course of action that made me successful in high school and later on in college. And that's why I only spent a couple years in pro ball. In fact, there's one game that sticks in my head forever that signifies what my pro career was like. I was pitching with the Helena brewers in Helena, Montana, and it was our first trip over to Missoula, Montana, to take on the Missoula Osprey. And I can remember the bus ride From Helena over McDonald Pass into Missoula. And on the bus, the coaching staff had warned us, watch out for the crowd in Missoula. You got the college kids there at the University of Montana, it's summer. School's out. They love to come to the games, and they love to make the opposing.
Night a nightmare for every opposing player because they drink a bit too much.
So here we are, it's the first game of the series, and our starting pitcher. I remember this game like it was last night. It was an odd night in Missoula because, first of all, it was hot and humid, which we're in this part of the country. This is not the norm. When it's hot and humid, there were 5,000 people in the stands, it was filled. And there was the most gorgeous red orange sunset over the mountains because there were wildfires burning around Missoula. And if any of you live in an area where there's wildfires, I live in Colorado. We get them a lot. One of the unintended beauties is the sunsets are gorgeous. I mean, ash was literally falling from the sky.
And that night, our starting pitcher was terrible. So bad that by the third inning, the call comes down to the bullpen. Get an Erie up. Get him loose right away. So I jump up, stretch out my arms, stretch out my legs, grab my glove, grab a ball, and I start warming up. And 10 throws later, I'm coming into the game. I'm jogging into this loud, obnoxious, drunk crowd.
So I get to the mound, and I grab the ball from Dan Norman, the Helena brewers manager, and I look to the Osprey dugout to see who I'll be facing right away. And it's Andres Torres, the top prospect in the Diamondbacks organization, one of the top prospects in all of minor league baseball. So here's my chance to play bigger, right? Like, here's my chance to go up against the biggest, the best and prove myself. So I start warming up, and as I start warming up, the crowd starts chanting. And little by little, the chanting gets louder. And after my third warm up pitch, I now can hear what they're chanting.
So can you guys help me relive a memory? On the count of three. Can we all chant this together? One, two, three. How can you pitch when you're five foot six?
Ah, thank you for that.
But in that moment.
My mind went somewhere it shouldn't have. Instead of getting jacked up, instead of playing bigger, my mind listened to the crowd. It said, yeah, who am I? I'm 5 foot 9, not 5 foot 6.
I don't have an overpowering arm. I wasn't a high draft pick. What right do I to have to stand on this mound and face on risk tours because I'm average?
Who's been there before?
Sucks, doesn't it? So I finished out that summer in Helena. I actually got transferred over to Ogden, Utah, right down the canyon and played with the Ogden Raptors. And the next spring training, I went back. And on the last day of spring training, I got released. I got cut. Now get this. The day I was cut, I was one day removed from breaking camp and going to spend the summer pitching in Bloit, Wisconsin with the Bloit stock snappers 50 miles from where I grew up. I was three promotions away from pitching for the Milwaukee Brewers, 30 miles from my hometown. You talk about a childhood dream.
Gone. It's over.
And when I look back at that day that I was released, I learned a lesson that will stick with me for the rest of my life. And that is this.
If you want to play bigger, you have got to have a major league mindset. And having a major league mindset requires having the right mix of competence and confidence mixed with one hell of a course of action.
More from Andy

Stop living in the gray of maybe! Your job in sales is to get a clear yes or no

How elite producers use “validation” to give prospects the confidence to hire them.

The Transition, every great sales leader goes through: Stop being the hero and develop heroes.







